The 2025 NFL Draft is in the books — and not every team came out a winner. In this episode your host, Brendan Maguire, breaks down the most questionable picks, head-scratching reaches, and provides evidenced based contrarian takes. From risky gambles to vibes based analysis we analyze where teams may have gone wrong and what it could mean for their future.

Time stamps:

• Travis Hunter - 2:34
• Ashton Jeanty - 8:08
• Mykel Williams - 12:53
• Jalon Walker - 22:15
• Malachi Starks - 26:06
• Tyleik Williams - 36:16
• Tyler Booker - 37:56

Will Campbell is on this list. You can find the analysis for that selection on the previous podcast "Reactions to Night One of the 2025 NFL Draft".