Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber close the conversation by pushing back on the idea that every baseball game should create panic, while still acknowledging the Yankees are not playing good baseball. The offense has gone quiet, the team is coming off rough series against Milwaukee and Baltimore, and the Subway Series against the Mets suddenly feels like a bigger test.

The guys also break down the key moments from the Yankees’ latest loss, including Anthony Volpe’s strikeout in a scoring chance, Adley Rutschman’s home run, and the concern surrounding Max Fried’s elbow. Evan explains why the timing of any injury update could reveal a lot, while the show ends by teasing a debate over whether Suzyn Waldman was trolling Mets fans or simply offering sharp analysis.