The series premiere of You Had Me at Rewind kicks off with a trip back to 1999 and the comedy that defined awkward teenhood: American Pie. Nathan and Whitney Chandler revisit the raunchy classic that shocked parents, spawned sequels and gave us band camp stories, Stifler chaos and one unforgettable apple pie. Along the way, they swap first memories, share laughs and ask—why does this outrageous movie now feel so strangely innocent?

Read Nathan's thoughts on ‘American Pie’.

Support the podcast: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/moviesarelife