The fundamental institution of Jewish identity, the synagogue is struggling. Prayer is no longer grabbing people and the cultural offerings available outside the community are increasingly more attractive. Should the idea be scrapped, gutted, renovated? The very first synagogues in the first century CE were town halls where scripture was read and interpreted and hostels where travellers found a meal and a night's rest. If the synagogue has served different needs throughout Jewish history, then what needs should it be serving today?