It's the battle of the cities this week as I apply a 7 point checklist to assess the marketing effectiveness of 40 Web Agency websites in 4 different cities around the globe. We were really surprised by the results - it shows a huge opportunity for web design agencies out there to make some quick improvements.
The criteria:
1. Non Spammy SEO Titles
One or two keywords - no overlap between the two keywords, and the business name.
In terms of overlapping keywords, I don't want to see this : Web Design New York, Website Design New York.
2. Video
A marketing video trying to sell the agency and connect with the watcher. That's it. I didn't even subtract marks for shitfullness.
3. About
One wo/man agencies: have a photo, and talk in the first person. Preferably, don't bore the shit out of the reader.
Multi employee agencies: team photos, names and a personal intro.
4. WII FM - What's In It For Me
Tell the potential client why your services and offerings matter to them.
An easy way to do this is using the Feature-Benefit framework of communication.
Feature: We design beautiful websites.
Benefit: Good looking websites increase your credibility with potential customers which means more cash in your pocket from extra sales. Also, other websites are more likely to link to you if your website looks great.
5. Portfolio
I wanted to see websites putting examples of their designs on the home page. Portfolios demonstrate your CHOPS and put your work front and centre. A quick, easy win!
6. Human Speak
Talk like a human! Lose the corporate speak, the jargon and the over-optimised SEO content.
The test is this : if you couldn't see yourself saying it to a friend who has asked about your business, don't put it on.
7. Social Proof
Testimonials are a proven effective way of generating more sales. Why don't more people put them on their websites? A quick win if ever there was one!
In addition, big brand logos and portfolios and awards help.
Here are the final results:
City
London
Melbourne
New York
Toronto
SEO Titles
4
4
7
5
Video
1
1
0
3
About
4
2
5
3
WII FM
2
5
2
2
Portfolio
8
5
9
6
Human Speak
2
7
4
2
Social Proof
6
4
3
4
Total
27
28
30
25
Cool Thing Of The Week
Ben: How ESPN trains former athletes to be broadcasters
Mat: NPR Follows a Tshirt Process
Mentions
Brendan Tully (listen to our episode with him)
ClimaxMedia.com
TheWebKitchen.co.uk
Web-Page-Design-Melbourne
Three's a Crowd
WebandRank.co.uk - I quoted this line from their site "And it’s about turning browsers into buyers, with a web presence that never loses sight of your bottom line."