Today your matron saints of spice are breaking down Taylor Swift’s latest album The Life of a Showgirl. We’re unpacking the false binary of “literary Taylor” versus “fun Taylor,” defending intellectualism in giddy romance, and explaining why performative activism on social media isn’t the same as actually loving your neighbors.

Plus, we’re getting real about how knowing too much about Taylor’s life actually ruins some songs because we can’t separate her lore from our own experiences.

Topics Covered:

* First impressions of the album and how the stark tonal shift from TTPD to Showgirl hit different depending on which era of Taylor you entered the fandom through

* The problem with binary thinking in both theology and art criticism—moving past “I liked it/I didn’t like it” to actually engage critically with what the work is doing

* How people vilify women (and specifically female theologians) for processing pain through Taylor Swift’s music, which is really just policing grief in weird patriarchal ways

* The false binary of career woman versus domestic goddess, and how women (including Taylor) contain multitudes without having to choose one identity forever

* How the emphasis on performance over practice keeps us from doing actual neighborhood-level activism, because posting black squares isn’t the same as loving Black people

The cringe is intentional, the depth is real, and Happy Taylor deserves the same literary analysis as Sad Taylor. Also, dick jokes can be spiritual practices after hard hospital shifts—chaplains said so. 🎭✨💕

Timestamps:

02:00 First Impressions: Opposite Listening Trajectories

05:00 Community Theater Experience Making Art Hit Different

10:00 Moving Past Binary Thinking in Art and Theology

13:00 Policing Women’s Grief Through Celebrity Criticism

18:00 Defending Intellectual Depth in Surface-Level Work

23:00 The Cringe Factor and Permission to Be Fully Human

27:00 Folklore Fans and Projecting Pandemic Sadness

31:00 Taylor the Poet vs Taylor the Brand

34:00 Intellectualism in Giddy Romance and Fun Art

38:00 Reimagining Trauma Through Creative Storytelling

40:00 False Binary of Career vs Domestic Life for Women

46:00 Performative Activism vs Actual Community Practice

49:00 Stadium Security and Why Speaking Out Is Complicated

53:00 Performance Over Practice in Online Activism

57:00 Favorite Songs

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit irsbpodcast.substack.com