Why some communities become collaborative while others turn territorial, and what that reveals about belonging

Some communities feel expansive. People share resources freely, celebrate each other’s wins, and welcome newcomers like there is enough room for everyone. Other spaces feel guarded. Information gets hoarded, collaboration feels performative, and every new voice quietly registers as competition.

In this solo episode, Tonya Kubo explores why that difference is rarely about whether people are “good” or “bad” and almost always about structure. Using examples from fiction writing communities, nonfiction publishing, online business spaces, and personal development ecosystems, Tonya breaks down how scarcity shapes behavior and how communities unintentionally teach people whether to connect or protect themselves.

This episode digs into the emotional architecture behind collaboration, competition, trust, and belonging. Why do some spaces naturally create generosity while others create defensiveness? Why do people become territorial when identity, expertise, or authority are tied to success? And what happens when communities reward visibility, curiosity, and shared discovery instead of exclusivity?

More than anything, this conversation is an invitation to stop asking whether people are “engaged enough” and start asking what behaviors the space itself rewards. Because communities do not become collaborative by accident. They become collaborative when safety, generosity, and contribution are intentionally reinforced.

You’ll hear how:

• Fiction communities often feel more collaborative because success is additive, not mutually exclusive
• Scarcity changes how people share knowledge, support others, and respond to newcomers
• Nonfiction communities become more territorial when trust is tied to the creator instead of the idea
• Community structure teaches members how to behave, whether intentionally or not
• Psychological safety creates generosity while fear creates defensiveness
• Rewarding collaboration publicly changes the emotional temperature of a space
• Belonging grows when people stop treating each other like threats
• Ambition and collaboration do not have to exist in opposition to each other

[01:15] The difference between communities that feel like potlucks versus cage matches

[03:40] Why fiction ecosystems naturally encourage collaboration

[07:10] How nonfiction spaces tie trust to authority and identity

[10:45] Why self-help and business communities often become more territorial

[14:20] The role scarcity plays in shaping community behavior

[17:05] Why plagiarism fears feel more personal in nonfiction spaces

[20:10] How communities teach members what behaviors are rewarded

[23:15] The connection between psychological safety and generosity

[26:00] Why belonging grows when people stop treating each other like threats

[28:05] The question every community leader should ask about their space

• Episode 024 – Interview with Michelle Chouinard
• Clutter-Free Academy by Kathi Lipp
• The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up by Marie Kondo

Tonya Kubo is a community strategist, marketing consultant, and rebel with a cause: helping people find the place where they truly belong. For nearly two decades, she’s built online spaces that feel less like comment sections and more like chosen family. She’s the fixer you call when your Facebook group has gone straight-up Lord of the Flies and the bouncer at the door of internet nonsense. As the host of Find Your Freaks, Tonya brings together unconventional thinkers and bridge-builders who know “normal” was never the point. Her favorite spaces? The ones where the freak flags fly high.

If Find Your Freaks matters to you, help us keep it ad-free by buying us a coffee (or two!). Every dollar goes to production so more weirdos can find their people.

You can purchase Find Your Freaks merchandise online through Abilities and Attitudes.

• Facebook Group
• LinkedIn
• Instagram
• Podcast Hub

Next time, Tonya Kubo sits down with Dr. Catrina Mitchum to explore why accessibility is not just a compliance issue — it’s the foundation of belonging. Together, they unpack what it really means to create online spaces where people can fully participate, connect, and thrive.