Elisha and Clark demonstrate that love can actually be… pretty easy. All it takes is a terrible movie and some secret messages.

Ailsa and Adam provide some competition in the storytelling department. If you thought you were cool in college, just wait until you hear this couple. Oh, and again- first dates never go quite as planned.

Bridget and Joseph are newlyweds and will soon become first-time parents. The hosts hear about the couple’s charming courtship and chivalrous ways — before the baby shakes things up!

Carla and Jason may or may not be human. The fun-loving, hard-working parents of two teach us how to explore life and love together- and even save a life.

Andy and Liz get visions of 1980s Wall Street with New Yorkers, Patti and Joe. After hearing their love story, our two hosts discover that love means taking risks– and sometimes, placing bets.

Andy and Liz rethink their own definitions of romance after meeting adorable couple, Kerry and Stuart. The lovebirds had a courtship that rom coms dream of— but, even fairy tales have their twists.

Andy and Liz meet Jacqlyn and Andy #2 and follow the texans’ journey in love. They learn that first dates can be far, far from romantic– and so can kids.

Andy and Liz discover the true meaning of opposites attract after meeting this week’s couple, Cathy and George. We also learn that Andy has no concept of romantic comedies.