Send us a text

History is built on pivotal moments where the outcome could have gone either way—and perhaps no American moment carries more weight than our fight for independence. But what happens when we flip the script and imagine George Washington captured at the Battle of Long Island, the patriots defeated, and the British Empire maintaining control of its American colonies?

In this mind-bending episode, we examine a fascinating alternative timeline where the butterfly effect of a British victory in the Revolutionary War ripples through centuries of global development. The consequences reach far beyond American shores—the French monarchy potentially avoiding revolution without the financial strain of supporting American independence, Napoleon never rising to power, and the map of Europe developing along completely different lines.

We contemplate how westward expansion would have been dramatically slowed by British colonial policies, potentially allowing Mexico to emerge as a greater power on the continent. We debate whether slavery would have ended earlier under British abolition or continued longer due to economic interests, and which Founding Fathers might have quickly reconciled with British rule versus those who would have remained defiant to the end.

The conversation takes a lighter turn as we imagine modern American life under British influence—driving on the left side of the road, adopting British humor and cuisine, maintaining stronger ties to the monarchy, and perhaps never developing our distinctive gun culture. Would America have eventually gained independence during World War I when Britain's attention was divided, or would we be part of a Commonwealth of Nations today?

Text us your own "what if" historical scenarios through the link in our description, or email us at [email protected]. The butterfly wings of history are always fluttering, and we're here to explore where they might have taken us.