Send us a text

Ever wondered why a president can send the National Guard into a city that didn’t ask for it? We light the fuse on a late-night, no-bleeps conversation that links today’s deployments to a long trail of precedent—from George Washington’s march during the Whiskey Rebellion to Woodrow Wilson’s 1916 overhauls and the 14th Amendment’s slow centralization of power. It’s not just a rant; it’s a map of how federal authority grew, why states ceded immigration control, and how both sides spin law and order to score political points while locals live with the consequences.

We walk through the legal gray zones around ICE, the friction between cooperation and obstruction, and the realities of federalism that most headlines skip. Then we pull history closer: Washington’s show of force, Hamilton’s tax, and Wilson’s National Defense Act that standardized and federalized state militias into today’s National Guard. Along the way, we question whether “emergencies” justify muscle, and who gets to say when the emergency ends. The 14th Amendment’s incorporation story gets its due too, reminding us how rights protection and centralization became intertwined.

On the culture side, we’re having fun with serious stakes. We set prop bets for Ken Burns’s new American Revolution series—who gets named, what themes hit first, how “complex” villains become—and we cheer Netflix’s upcoming Death by Lightning, a gripping take on President James Garfield’s assassination, Charles Guiteau’s chaotic spiral, and the era’s flawed medicine. These stories aren’t detours; they’re primers on how a nation learns to read power. If you care about civil liberties, federalism, immigration policy, and the history that keeps repeating, this after-dark session is your field guide.

If you’re into smart, unscripted history with sharp edges, hit play, share this with a friend, and tell us: where do you draw the line on federal force? Subscribe, leave a review, and drop your boldest prop bet for the Revolution series.

Send us a text

We announce our ambitious new project covering each state's journey to joining the Union, starting with Delaware and proceeding in order of ratification or annexation. This special series will coincide with America's upcoming 250th anniversary celebration.

• John recaps his experience hosting an office trivia contest where his fashion choice (suit jacket with jeans) became a controversial talking point
• Discussion of fan feedback from "Dick Pepperfield" about the trivia contest and suggestions for improvement
• Analysis of Born on the Fourth of July film and connections to American patriotism
• Announcement of our new 50-state podcast series examining how each state joined the Union
• Preview of Delaware as "The First State" with fun facts about its size, population, and corporate significance 
• Plans to keep episodes concise while covering each state's unique story and historical context

Join us for our next episode as we properly begin our journey through all 50 states, starting with Delaware's path to becoming the first state to ratify the Constitution!

Send us a text

When newlywed John returns from his California nuptials, the podcast takes a refreshingly personal turn as Matt recounts his best man experience and the unexpected drama surrounding the wedding's signature cocktail. The "Simply Peach Juice debacle" becomes a running joke throughout the episode, as the hosts describe their frantic day-before search for this elusive ingredient, only to run out during cocktail hour anyway.

What makes this episode particularly enjoyable is how organically it transitions from wedding talk to an impromptu American history quiz session. John reveals he's been tasked with creating Fourth of July trivia for his workplace, and Matt becomes the reluctant guinea pig for testing these questions. Their back-and-forth banter creates both humor and genuine historical insights as they debate the difficulty level and entertainment value of each question.

The trivia section uncovers fascinating Independence Day connections many listeners might not know: Calvin Coolidge was the only U.S. president born on July 4th; Thomas Jefferson and John Adams both died on July 4th, 1826 (exactly 50 years after the Declaration of Independence); and Italian patriot Giuseppe Garibaldi, born on July 4th, 1807, was offered but refused a commission in the Union Army during the Civil War.

Beyond just facts, the episode showcases the hosts' different approaches to making history engaging. John tends toward straightforward questions, while Matt advocates for injecting humor to make the trivia more memorable. Their friendly disagreement about whether questions should be multiple choice or fill-in-the-blank reflects wider debates about history education – should we focus on accessibility or deeper knowledge?

Whether you're planning your own history-themed trivia night or simply enjoy learning American history through casual conversation, this episode delivers both entertainment and education in equal measure. What Fourth of July fact would surprise your friends the most? Let us know and join the historical conversation!

Send us a text

Have you ever paid good money for a disappointing experience? In this continuation of our Virginia adventure, we dive into the reality behind the tourism facade of the Historic Triangle – and it's not always pretty.

We pick up where we left off after Sherwood Forest, as our four-man crew embarks on exploring Jamestown, Williamsburg, and Yorktown. What should have been a fascinating journey through America's colonial beginnings quickly devolves into a series of increasingly bizarre encounters with historical interpreters who can't seem to decide if they're in the 18th century or the 21st. From the young man dangerously swinging a hoe while attempting to explain tobacco farming, to the tattooed kitchen worker who responds to genuine questions with a dismissive "stuff," the supposed guardians of historical authenticity left much to be desired.

Williamsburg emerges as the villain of our tale – a $35 per person tourist trap where asphalt streets are somehow meant to transport you to 1774, rollerbladers cruise past colonial buildings, and the main attraction (the Capitol Building) locks its gates in our faces at precisely 5:00 PM with a smile. The experience raises fascinating questions about historical tourism: When does educational entertainment become exploitative? How do modern sensibilities interact with historical interpretation? And why do some sites succeed where others fail so spectacularly?

Fortunately, Yorktown provides redemption with its well-managed National Park Service battlefield tour and thoughtful exhibits, including a proper recreation of Washington's command tent. Through our misadventures, we offer genuine insights for anyone considering their own historical journey through Virginia – which sites deliver authentic experiences worth your time and money, and which might leave you running back to the 21st century in search of something real.

Join us for laughs, frustrations, and genuine historical curiosity as we navigate the awkward middle ground between past and present in Virginia's Historic Triangle. And learn from our mistakes so your own historical adventures might prove more rewarding than ours!

Send us a text

When typical bachelor party debauchery gets replaced with historical site tours, you know you're dealing with history nerds of the highest order. What began as an attempt to check off the "Historic Triangle of Virginia" quickly spiraled into a comedy of errors featuring annoyed tour guides, historical mansplaining gone wrong, and the touching of things that should not be touched.

Our journey begins at the White House of the Confederacy in Richmond, where a young, knowledgeable tour guide expertly schools our overconfident host who tries to show off his Civil War expertise. The painful silence following his fumbled explanation of the Peninsula Campaign might be the most educational moment of the entire tour. Despite expectations of controversy, the site offers a surprisingly thoughtful perspective on this complex chapter of American history.

The real highlight comes at Sherwood Forest, home of President John Tyler and the only presidential residence continuously inhabited by descendants of a former president. Here we meet Tim, a ponytailed guide with questionable fashion sense who delivers a marathon three-hour tour filled with football field analogies and protective rage when antique candlesticks are touched by unauthorized fingers. "Yeah, but I know which one to touch" might be the perfect retort to sum up the entire experience.

Between Jefferson Davis's restored citizenship (which he might not have wanted), John Tyler's fifteen children, and the current resident who is "63 going on 18," this episode captures the strange, fascinating characters who inhabit our national story—both historical figures and the dedicated, if sometimes eccentric, individuals who preserve their legacies.

If you've ever felt that rush of embarrassment when someone in your group asks a stupid question at a museum, or fantasized about touching the artifacts behind the velvet rope, this episode validates all your historical tourist urges and anxieties. Listen now to experience the Historic Triangle of Virginia through the eyes of two podcasters who can't help but think they could do everything better—even while proving the exact opposite.

Send us a text

History is built on pivotal moments where the outcome could have gone either way—and perhaps no American moment carries more weight than our fight for independence. But what happens when we flip the script and imagine George Washington captured at the Battle of Long Island, the patriots defeated, and the British Empire maintaining control of its American colonies?

In this mind-bending episode, we examine a fascinating alternative timeline where the butterfly effect of a British victory in the Revolutionary War ripples through centuries of global development. The consequences reach far beyond American shores—the French monarchy potentially avoiding revolution without the financial strain of supporting American independence, Napoleon never rising to power, and the map of Europe developing along completely different lines.

We contemplate how westward expansion would have been dramatically slowed by British colonial policies, potentially allowing Mexico to emerge as a greater power on the continent. We debate whether slavery would have ended earlier under British abolition or continued longer due to economic interests, and which Founding Fathers might have quickly reconciled with British rule versus those who would have remained defiant to the end.

The conversation takes a lighter turn as we imagine modern American life under British influence—driving on the left side of the road, adopting British humor and cuisine, maintaining stronger ties to the monarchy, and perhaps never developing our distinctive gun culture. Would America have eventually gained independence during World War I when Britain's attention was divided, or would we be part of a Commonwealth of Nations today?

Text us your own "what if" historical scenarios through the link in our description, or email us at [email protected]. The butterfly wings of history are always fluttering, and we're here to explore where they might have taken us.

Send us a text

Join us on a sartorial rollercoaster as we navigate the hilarities of wedding suit shopping with our friend Emily M, dialing in from her racetrack-adjacent hideaway in the Poconos. As the best man, I recount my misadventures alongside our groom-to-be, John, whose unique fitness regime of daily push-ups didn't quite prepare us for the comedic chaos at the fitting. Emily brings her wit and wisdom on looking wedding-ready while throwing in amusing anecdotes of NASCAR memories that are sure to tickle your funny bone.

Switching gears, we take a deep dive into one of the most sensational legal dramas of the 20th century: the O.J. Simpson trial. From the infamous Bronco chase to Johnny Cochran’s unforgettable courtroom moments, we dissect the intricacies of the trial and its lasting impact on public perception, media, and the justice system. The rollercoaster of events includes Judge Ito’s unexpected celebrity status and the defense's strategic decisions that had everyone on the edge of their seats. Our discussion brings to light the often overlooked aspects of the trial, including the challenges faced by both the jury and legal professionals involved.

Our journey through this monumental trial continues as we unravel the personal dramas and quirky tales of key figures post-verdict. We explore Kato Kaelin's guilty indulgence at McDonald's, O.J.'s unusual jail perks, and the dramatic sequestration endured by the jury. We also ponder the justice system's influence on high-profile cases, questioning whether public and media scrutiny helps or hinders the pursuit of truth. As Emily prepares to rejoin us for more enlightening discussions, we promise future episodes filled with thought-provoking insights and the occasional bout of laughter.

Send us a text

Ever wondered how a simple Italian-style egg roll could turn a day into a comedy of errors? Join us as we recount our holiday escapades, from the whirlwind of family chaos to the laughter-filled moments at La Scala's Fire in Philadelphia. The trip for an Italian passport turned into a day of surprises, with a humorous "Italianian" T-shirt thrown in by Matt, proving that it's the unexpected twists that create the best stories. As we attempt to embrace Italian traditions, we find joy in the little mishaps and the warmth of coming home for the holidays, which makes for a podcast episode full of laughter and relatable moments.

A visit from my Australian host family's son provided the perfect excuse to explore Washington, D.C., through fresh eyes. Serving as a tour guide, we ventured through the Smithsonian and the city's iconic landmarks, sparking conversations about the lesser-known stories of D.C.'s memorials. We even ponder if Billy Joel's "Allentown" might have found inspiration at the FDR Memorial. Our nostalgic ramblings take us back to childhood music memories and amusing school talent show performances, blending history with humor in a way that makes it feel like you were there with us.

We then wander through tales of historical intrigue, connecting the dots between unexpected events, like the deaths of Jimmy Carter and Peter Yarrow, and the playful what-ifs of their afterlife encounters. Our historical musings take a whimsical turn as we revisit Andrew Jackson's raucous inauguration and the scandalous Petticoat Affair, all the while wrapping up with a light-hearted take on bathroom luxury and state flags. It's an episode that promises history with a twist, blending humor, nostalgia, and insights into the quirks of the past and present.

Send us a text

Ever wondered what Mussolini and Hitler have in common with a good laugh? Join us on a whimsical trip down memory lane as we recount the year-long journey of the Nailing History Podcast. From our hilariously awkward first recording to the notorious internet mishaps that plagued John's connection, we’ve had our fair share of growing pains. Toss in some peculiar historical anecdotes, like the infamous "wee-wee" tales, and you have a recipe for a podcast that’s equal parts chaotic and charming.

Take a front-row seat as we recount memorable field trips and museum escapades, from Harper's Ferry to the Museum of the American Revolution. These adventures brought unexpected hilarity, like the anticlimactic tent exhibit, and left us dreaming of future listener-led trips. Our antics don't just stop at history; our attempts at movie reviews, like the infamous Al Pacino flick, added another comedic layer to our exploration of entertainment.

As we wrap up this milestone year with 35 episodes and over 2,000 minutes of content, we're filled with gratitude for listeners like you. We’ve welcomed amazing guests such as Emily M, who helped us dive deep into iconic moments like the OJ Simpson trial. Looking ahead, we're excited to embrace more organic content, host new faces, and continue this wild, historical ride. A heartfelt thanks to our audience and special guests for fueling our passion and making this journey unforgettable—stay curious, and may your holiday season be as joyful as our escapades!

Send us a text

What happens when global politics, family ties, and the complex world of presidential pardons collide? Join us as we unpack the shocking overthrow of the Assad regime in Syria and the assassination of the UnitedHealthcare CEO, events that have left the world buzzing with mixed reactions. Our journey isn't just about serious headlines—we also share our amusing adventure of getting verified on X (formerly Twitter) and losing a horde of bot followers along the way. The episode takes a twist into the volatile world of cryptocurrency, spotlighting the intriguing tale of internet personality Haley Welch and her meme coin escapades.

The controversy surrounding President Joe Biden's pardon of his son, Hunter Biden, takes center stage as we explore the legal, ethical, and political ramifications of such a decision. This move, covering federal crimes from 2014 to the present, including gun-related offenses and tax evasion, challenges the moral high ground of the Democrats, especially with impending elections. Throughout the discussion, we reflect on historical presidential pardons, offering a lens through which to view the complexities and familial pressures involved in such powerful acts of clemency.

Travel through history as we examine the origins and evolution of the presidential pardon, from the Whiskey Rebellion to Jimmy Carter's pardon of Vietnam War draft dodgers. We debate the most controversial pardons in U.S. history, questioning the motivations behind clemency for figures like Jimmy Hoffa and Patty Hearst. Ending on a lighter note, we recount Joe Exotic's failed pardon attempt, highlighting the bizarre yet captivating narratives that make presidential pardons a perpetual topic of fascination and debate.