February 20, 2026

#201 – A theist and an atheist compare notes

1 hour 1 minute

… on science, religious belief, and the meaning of life.

Our guest — Dr. Philip Clayton — is an exceptionally credentialed and highly acclaimed philosopher, speaker and author standing at the interface between science and religion. In this book, he teamed up with a non-theist — Claudia Pearce — to write a book which addresses that interface in brutally honest vulnerability.

Both authors have weaved their way through a broad spectrum of Christian belief. Philip grew up in an atheist home, but embraced Fundamentalist Evangelical Christianity as a teenager (to spite his parents); but with time and life’s experiences, he has now settled comfortably into Open and Relational Theology. Claudia had been a very Conservative Evangelical Christian, but also, over time, shifted comfortably into a non-theistic, agnostic humanism.

In the first half of the book, they scrutinize three major fields of science — cosmology/astrophysics, biology/evolution, and cognitive neuroscience — and find that they can agree on so much: not just the details of the scientific discoveries, and the interpretations and models which arise from those, but also common existential values, as well as the perception that religions are generally founded on beliefs and worldviews which are not a good fit for the early 20th century.

The very small area of non-overlap between their worldviews pertained to the implications of these findings. For example, we discussed at length whether the discovery of fine tuning of the universe pointed to either a Tuner or to chance, and the discovery of exquisite design in biology pointed to either a Designer or chance.

In the second half of the book, Philip and Claudia compare notes on a number of religious concepts: the nature of God (omnipotent/omniscience/omnipresence), Scripture, miracles, and the afterlife. We unpacked the first and third of those four.

In the last chapter of the book, this theist and non-theistic humanist talk about their two different perspectives on one sacred story … and find that they’re really not that far apart at all! It’s a lesson we can all learn from!

We highly recommend this book!

As always, tell us your thoughts on this topic …

Find more information about Dr. Philip Clayton and this book at his web-site.

If you enjoyed this episode, you may also like Episode #90, where we talked with Dr. Thomas Jay Oord about Open and Process Theology.

To help grow this podcast, please like, share and post a rating/review at your favorite podcast catcher.

Subscribe here to get updates each time a new episode is posted...

Join our private discussion group at Facebook and our YouTube channel.