Up 6-3 with two outs in the ninth should be a win you file away and forget. Instead, the Yankees turn it into a 7-6, 10-inning walk-off loss to the Mets, and we’re left staring at the same uncomfortable question: how can a team with playoff goals look so helpless late in games?

I break down the 2026 Yankees bullpen meltdown, starting with why the closer situation feels fundamentally broken. David Bednar’s latest blown lead isn’t treated like a one-off mistake, it’s the clearest example of a bullpen with zero dependable arms and no clean path to the final outs. From there, I zoom out to the bigger roster-building problem and why patching relief pitching from the scrap heap keeps coming back to bite New York.

Then I get into the stuff that drives fans crazy in extra innings: the ghost runner on second, the inability to get a bunt down, and a lineup that too often swings like it’s home run or nothing. I also talk bluntly about the bottom of the order, including Austin Wells at catcher and Ryan McMahon at third base, and what it means when multiple spots feel like automatic outs in high-leverage spots. The trade deadline is coming, and “it’s only May” stops working when it’s getting late early.

If you’re fed up, you’re not alone. Subscribe to Jersey Guy Sports, share this with a Yankees fan who’s still making excuses, and leave a review with your take: what’s the first move you make to fix this team?

Send fan mail

Jersey Guy Sports is available on all podcasting platforms. 

• Listen on Spotify
• Listen on Apple Podcasts 
• Listen on YouTube
• Listen on PocketCasts
• Listen on iHeart Radio
• Listen on Amazon Music
• Listen on TuneIn and Alexa
• Listen on other podcasting platforms here

Socials

•  Facebook, JGS Twitter, Threads, Youtub...