In this episode, Niall tackles a heart-wrenching and emotionally charged question: Should a parent ever consider putting their child in care—especially when they feel completely overwhelmed?

The discussion was sparked by an emotional email from a listener, a mother who says she is at breaking point trying to care for her autistic child. She explains that despite her best efforts, she can no longer cope and is seriously considering placing her child into care for the child’s own safety and wellbeing—as well as her own mental health.

Some callers believe that if a parent is truly at breaking point, then seeking help—even if that means placing the child into care—is the responsible thing to do. They argue it’s not about giving up, but about ensuring the child receives the care and support they need, especially when the system has failed to adequately support families with special needs. These callers say the real problem lies in the lack of proper services, respite, and funding for parents who are stretched to their limits.

While other callers feel strongly that no matter how hard it gets, a parent should never consider putting their child into care. They argue there are always other options—respite services, therapy, family support—and that giving up sends the wrong message. For them, parental responsibility means sticking it out through the toughest times and continuing to fight for support rather than resorting to what they see as abandonment.

Niall reflects on the emotional weight of the conversation, acknowledging how complex and painful this situation is for any parent. He emphasizes that rather than judgment, what’s needed most is compassion—and a national conversation about how we support families dealing with special needs.