Okay, let's think about it - who had the saddest story arc of the entire season? To come to a conclusion, Mary and I debate (and remember!) all that happened in season four, to figure out who came out on bottom. There are definitely some upsets.

The brackets (in threes - with the third name getting a bye to the second round) are:

The Armstrongs

Alison

Billy

*** Brooke

Jake & The Girls

Jo

Jane

*** Jake

Michael & The Mancinis

Sydney

Kimberly

*** Michael

The Leftovers

Peter

Amanda

*** Matt