Piper's Dojo Audio Experience

471 - Is There A Better Way To Grade Band Contests? (Dojo Conversations Episode 141)

Listen Later

Is there a better way to score pipe band competitions?  

This week, Andrew and Jim look at an unlikely comparison for inspiration: gymnastics. From artistic vs. objective elements, to the challenge of ranking large fields fairly, to the ever-present issue of bias, the guys explore what the world of sports can teach us about how pipe bands are judged. What makes a fair system? Should pipe bands stick to ordinal rankings? Would point-based scoring bring more consistency? And how do we balance tradition with the need for innovation?  

Got a topic you’d like us to cover in a future episode? Leave a comment or email us: [email protected]  

Here’s what we cover this week:

  • 00:00 – Andrew’s secret gymnastics passion revealed
  • 01:32 – Jim’s school days and flexibility struggles
  • 03:00 – Comparing movement and body types
  • 04:50 – The basics of gymnastics events and routines
  • 06:00 – Artistic vs. objective elements in gymnastics
  • 07:15 – How gymnastics is scored: D and E panels explained
  • 10:00 – The challenge of making subjective performances objective
  • 12:00 – Pipe band scoring vs. gymnastics scoring
  • 14:00 – Why not just rank gymnasts? The case for point-based systems
  • 16:00 – The problem with ordinal ranking in pipe bands
  • 18:00 – Handling ties, large fields, and the importance of standardization
  • 20:00 – The “big three” for judging bagpipe performances: sound, technique, musicality
  • 23:00 – The complexity of creating a fair, repeatable rubric
  • 25:00 – Bias, recency, and the human side of judging
  • 28:00 – The need for more judges and the realities of competition logistics
  • 31:00 – The importance of strong, sustainable institutions
  • 34:00 – Innovation vs. tradition in competition systems
  • 36:00 – Final thoughts
    • ...more
    View all episodesView all episodes
    Download on the App Store
    Piper's Dojo Audio ExperienceBy Andrew Douglas and the Piper's Dojo Team
    • 4.9
    • 4.9
    • 4.9
    • 4.9
    • 4.9

    4.9

    40 ratings

    More shows like Piper's Dojo Audio Experience

    View all
    This American Life by This American Life

    This American Life

    90,964 Listeners

    Stuff You Should Know by iHeartPodcasts

    Stuff You Should Know

    78,475 Listeners

    The Joe Rogan Experience by Joe Rogan

    The Joe Rogan Experience

    228,713 Listeners

    Hidden Brain by Hidden Brain, Shankar Vedantam

    Hidden Brain

    43,653 Listeners

    Wait Wait... Don't Tell Me! by NPR

    Wait Wait... Don't Tell Me!

    38,812 Listeners

    The Moth by The Moth

    The Moth

    27,169 Listeners

    99% Invisible by Roman Mars

    99% Invisible

    26,240 Listeners

    The Gray Area with Sean Illing by Vox

    The Gray Area with Sean Illing

    10,726 Listeners

    The Adam and Dr. Drew Show by PodcastOne / Carolla Digital

    The Adam and Dr. Drew Show

    8,755 Listeners

    Wetootwaag's Bagpipe and History Podcast by Jeremy Kingsbury

    Wetootwaag's Bagpipe and History Podcast

    24 Listeners

    The Big Rab Show Podcast by Big Rab

    The Big Rab Show Podcast

    49 Listeners

    The Shawn Ryan Show by Shawn Ryan

    The Shawn Ryan Show

    45,717 Listeners

    Droning On by PipingJim

    Droning On

    21 Listeners

    The Ezra Klein Show by New York Times Opinion

    The Ezra Klein Show

    15,867 Listeners

    Enjoy Your Piping! With Gary West by Gary West

    Enjoy Your Piping! With Gary West

    45 Listeners