PSA: Starting Effective Immediately, our live recording night is switched to Thursdays at 8:00pm (CST).

Follow the 4Player 2025 Fantasy Critic Staff League
Follow the 4Player Community League #1
Follow the 4Player Community League #2
Follow the 4Player Community League #3
Follow the 4Player Community League #4
Follow the 4Player Community League #5

You are invited to join our FREE community Discord - Download the app to your phone and use it to keep in touch with other members of the community and the podcast crew as well!

Don't forget to help our cause by subscribing to the show via your preferred content subscription service (iTunes, SoundCloud, RSS, etc). Click here to Learn How to Subscribe!

Enjoy the show? Let us know how you feel about the topics discussed in the comments below! We'll address your comments and questions during the first 10 minutes of next week's podcast! Involvement with the show via the comments automatically enters you in the monthly giveaway as well!

We take a quick detour this week to focus entirely on the current status of our Fantasy Critic leagues! With only 2 months left in the year, there is a lot of reflect on and speculate about for both our staff league and our various community leagues! So buckle up for some extreme nerd talk.

PSA: Starting Effective Immediately, our live recording night is switched to Thursdays at 8:00pm (CST).

You are invited to join our FREE community Discord - Download the app to your phone and use it to keep in touch with other members of the community and the podcast crew as well!

Don't forget to help our cause by subscribing to the show via your preferred content subscription service (iTunes, SoundCloud, RSS, etc). Click here to Learn How to Subscribe!

Enjoy the show? Let us know how you feel about the topics discussed in the comments below! We'll address your comments and questions during the first 10 minutes of next week's podcast! Involvement with the show via the comments automatically enters you in the monthly giveaway as well!

PSA: Starting Effective Immediately, our live recording night is switched to Thursdays at 8:00pm (CST).

Follow the 4Player 2025 Fantasy Critic Staff League
Follow the 4Player Community League #1
Follow the 4Player Community League #2
Follow the 4Player Community League #3
Follow the 4Player Community League #4
Follow the 4Player Community League #5

You are invited to join our FREE community Discord - Download the app to your phone and use it to keep in touch with other members of the community and the podcast crew as well!

Don't forget to help our cause by subscribing to the show via your preferred content subscription service (iTunes, SoundCloud, RSS, etc). Click here to Learn How to Subscribe!

PSA: Starting NEXT WEEK, our live recording night is switching to Thursdays at 8:00pm (CST). We are not sure yet about the new release schedule for the audio version but we will keep everyone posted.

Follow the 4Player 2025 Fantasy Critic Staff League
Follow the 4Player Community League #1
Follow the 4Player Community League #2
Follow the 4Player Community League #3
Follow the 4Player Community League #4
Follow the 4Player Community League #5

You are invited to join our FREE community Discord - Download the app to your phone and use it to keep in touch with other members of the community and the podcast crew as well!

Don't forget to help our cause by subscribing to the show via your preferred content subscription service (iTunes, SoundCloud, RSS, etc). Click here to Learn How to Subscribe!

Enjoy the show? Let us know how you feel about the topics discussed in the comments below! We'll address your comments and questions during the first 10 minutes of next week's podcast! Involvement with the show via the comments automatically enters you in the monthly giveaway as well!

Spooky season has arrived! Before we delve into the absolute chaos of October 2025 in the world of video games, we indulge our desire to talk horror films and getting into the Halloween spirit! After that, Brad dives deep on yet another "definitive" version of his favorite game of all time: Final Fantasy Tactics: The Ivalice Chronicles. Chris Davis and Nick deliver some early impressions of Ghost of Yotei and discuss how Sucker Punch approached the sequel from a design standpoint. Brad also shines some light on an inspired new indie game, Consume Me, which is already sweeping up awards but struggling a little to gain traction for consumers.

Follow the 4Player 2025 Fantasy Critic Staff League
Follow the 4Player Community League #1
Follow the 4Player Community League #2
Follow the 4Player Community League #3
Follow the 4Player Community League #4
Follow the 4Player Community League #5

You are invited to join our FREE community Discord - Download the app to your phone and use it to keep in touch with other members of the community and the podcast crew as well!

Don't forget to help our cause by subscribing to the show via your preferred content subscription service (iTunes, SoundCloud, RSS, etc). Click here to Learn How to Subscribe!

Enjoy the show? Let us know how you feel about the topics discussed in the comments below! We'll address your comments and questions during the first 10 minutes of next week's podcast! Involvement with the show via the comments automatically enters you in the monthly giveaway as well!

Chris Davis turned 40 but enough about that... October 2025 is poised to be one of the most beautifully chaotic months of gaming that we've seen in a long time. We recorded late this week but it gave us more time to delve into Silent Hill f, another impressive (original) entry in Silent Hill's ongoing comeback tour. Brad also siezes the opportunity to finally talk about Hades II after patiently waiting for the game to leave early access! Of course, there is more Hollow Knight Silksong to discuss as we each move through this difficult game at varying paces.

Follow the 4Player 2025 Fantasy Critic Staff League
Follow the 4Player Community League #1
Follow the 4Player Community League #2
Follow the 4Player Community League #3
Follow the 4Player Community League #4
Follow the 4Player Community League #5

You are invited to join our FREE community Discord - Download the app to your phone and use it to keep in touch with other members of the community and the podcast crew as well!

Don't forget to help our cause by subscribing to the show via your preferred content subscription service (iTunes, SoundCloud, RSS, etc). Click here to Learn How to Subscribe!

Enjoy the show? Let us know how you feel about the topics discussed in the comments below! We'll address your comments and questions during the first 10 minutes of next week's podcast! Involvement with the show via the comments automatically enters you in the monthly giveaway as well!

We dig deeper into Hollow Knight Silksong this week and take the time to debate some of the nitty-gritty design choices that make the experience divisive but brilliant. Chris Davis delivers some final thoughts on his extended playthroughs of Metal Gear Solid Delta: Snake Eater and we briefly discuss the fun we had together last week streaming Peak! In the news, Kojima Productions hosted their own showcase with a host of announcements including a first look at OD: Knock. We also take a closer look at some surprises that hit this week with games like Silent Hill f and Trails in the Sky 1st Chapter debuting with impressive review scores.

Follow the 4Player 2025 Fantasy Critic Staff League
Follow the 4Player Community League #1
Follow the 4Player Community League #2
Follow the 4Player Community League #3
Follow the 4Player Community League #4
Follow the 4Player Community League #5

You are invited to join our FREE community Discord - Download the app to your phone and use it to keep in touch with other members of the community and the podcast crew as well!

Don't forget to help our cause by subscribing to the show via your preferred content subscription service (iTunes, SoundCloud, RSS, etc). Click here to Learn How to Subscribe!

Enjoy the show? Let us know how you feel about the topics discussed in the comments below! We'll address your comments and questions during the first 10 minutes of next week's podcast! Involvement with the show via the comments automatically enters you in the monthly giveaway as well!

What is there to say? Hollow Knight Silksong is out and we have played a bunch of it. In fact, the game is so good that it brought Ed out of hiding and onto the podcast for the first time since our 2025 Fantasy Critic Draft! After slobbing all over Silksong, we take some time to recap this week's big Nintendo Direct and the abundance of announcements thaat continue to make 2025 one of the wildest years for gaming ever! Metroid Prime 4 and Hades 2 have new release dates and the next Fire Emblem is lookin hot.

Follow the 4Player 2025 Fantasy Critic Staff League
Follow the 4Player Community League #1
Follow the 4Player Community League #2
Follow the 4Player Community League #3
Follow the 4Player Community League #4
Follow the 4Player Community League #5
Watch our 2024 Game of the Year Content
Join Nick's new Dexter Daily Discord Server

You are invited to join our FREE community Discord - Download the app to your phone and use it to keep in touch with other members of the community and the podcast crew as well!

Don't forget to help our cause by subscribing to the show via your preferred content subscription service (iTunes, SoundCloud, RSS, etc). Click here to Learn How to Subscribe!

Enjoy the show? Let us know how you feel about the topics discussed in the comments below! We'll address your comments and questions during the first 10 minutes of next week's podcast! Involvement with the show via the comments automatically enters you in the monthly giveaway as well!

As the clock ticks down toward the looming release of Hollow Knight Silksong, we say goodbye to a bygone era. Strangely enough, that era ends with us revisiting three established franchises with vastly different approaches to modernization. Nick and Chris Davis talk about the impressive - but slightly unambitious - remake, Metal Gear Solid Delta: Snake Eater and Brad delves into Shinobi: Art of Vengeance which has reinvented the franchise with a shift of genre and a beautiful new coat of paint. Meanwhile, Krispy declares No Man's Sky: Voyagers to be the ultimate expansion which softens the barrier-to-entry and out Starfield's Starfield.

Follow the 4Player 2025 Fantasy Critic Staff League
Follow the 4Player Community League #1
Follow the 4Player Community League #2
Follow the 4Player Community League #3
Follow the 4Player Community League #4
Follow the 4Player Community League #5
Watch our 2024 Game of the Year Content
Join Nick's new Dexter Daily Discord Server

You are invited to join our FREE community Discord - Download the app to your phone and use it to keep in touch with other members of the community and the podcast crew as well!

Don't forget to help our cause by subscribing to the show via your preferred content subscription service (iTunes, SoundCloud, RSS, etc). Click here to Learn How to Subscribe!

Enjoy the show? Let us know how you feel about the topics discussed in the comments below! We'll address your comments and questions during the first 10 minutes of next week's podcast! Involvement with the show via the comments automatically enters you in the monthly giveaway as well!

This is not a drill. Hollow Knight Silksong not only has a release date... It's NEXT WEEK! As exciting as that is, we have to deal with the here and now. Brad tries his best to talk about Sword of the Sea without mentioning Journey but fails miserably. Nick delves into Heartworm, a 2025 indie horror game that harkens back to the days of PS1-era survival horror and Chris Davis continues his recent love affair with Call of Duty: Black Ops 6 but focuses on the campaign this week. With a little Lumines Arise (Demo), Death Stranding 2, Donkey Kong Bananza, and some Deadlock Beta impressions sprinkled throughout, you've got yourself a podcast.

Follow the 4Player 2025 Fantasy Critic Staff League
Follow the 4Player Community League #1
Follow the 4Player Community League #2
Follow the 4Player Community League #3
Follow the 4Player Community League #4
Follow the 4Player Community League #5
Watch our 2024 Game of the Year Content
Join Nick's new Dexter Daily Discord Server

You are invited to join our FREE community Discord - Download the app to your phone and use it to keep in touch with other members of the community and the podcast crew as well!

Don't forget to help our cause by subscribing to the show via your preferred content subscription service (iTunes, SoundCloud, RSS, etc). Click here to Learn How to Subscribe!

Enjoy the show? Let us know how you feel about the topics discussed in the comments below! We'll address your comments and questions during the first 10 minutes of next week's podcast! Involvement with the show via the comments automatically enters you in the monthly giveaway as well!