Jim Rutledge and Alex Strouf pair up for their fifth show of the week on this Phish Friday. Jim throws out a question jumping off of KBN's hypothetical from earlier in the day, asking fans if, taking contracts into account, would fans rather have Jordan Love or Caleb Williams as the Packers' quarterback next season? Jim makes the case for a potentially generational level QB on a rookie deal while Strouf makes a case for the *more-known* commodity in Jordan Love. Strouf and Primetime bicker about whether age matters between a 24 and 25-year-old, and we hear the return of legendary caller Carlito: the Bear-Badger! They review the results and mean responses to today's poll question, and Jim says that Brewers fans are "giving off big small-ball energy" with their memes about Craig Counsell. Strouf and Primetime question the legitimacy of Bears, Chiefs, Badgers, FAU, and Cubs fan, Jim Rutledge.