As promised, here’s the update in written version
Hello. It has been three weeks since my last update, so there is a lot to get through, and I am going to concentrate on two themes. First, science and health. Then immigration.
Science and health
So let me start with vaccines.
On the 18th Sept, in the Oval Office with his health secretary RFK Jr beside him, Trump said the administration would demand that vaccine makers split some childhood vaccines into five separate doses, each a fifth of the amount, given six months apart. He said this would bring, in his words, a “massive reduction” in autism. He gave no evidence, and he did not say which vaccines he meant. The idea that vaccines cause autism has been rigorously and repeatedly studied, and there is absolutely no evidence for it. Vaccine experts say splitting doses like this would simply leave children unprotected for longer and reduce the number of children who receive all the shots they need.
At the same time, the updated Covid vaccines for children are not getting to many children. The Food and Drug Administration approved them in August. But the CDC has not opened them up for ordering through the Vaccines for Children programme, which covers about half of all American children. In at least 11 states and one US territory, which buy vaccines for every child through that programme, that means children cannot currently get the updated shot that way. Officials have not said when, or whether, that will change. A former senior CDC official described it as testing the waters, and said there is nothing to stop them doing the same with other vaccines.
On the 17th Sept the health secretary, RFK Jr, spoke at the convention of Children’s Health Defense, the campaign group against vaccines that he founded, and told them they had, in his words, a strong and steadfast friend at the White House. The next day he named a new chair of the federal committee that coordinates autism research. The new chair, John Gaitanis, has long promoted a drug called leucovorin as a treatment for autism, for which there is no clear evidence. He cofounded a telehealth company offering that treatment to families of autistic children. And he has repeatedly been paid as an expert witness in cases claiming injury from vaccines, including the MMR. So the person now coordinating federal autism research has a commercial interest in an unproven treatment and a history of giving evidence against vaccines.
The second thing is about who decides which science gets done.
The National Institutes of Health is the largest public funder of medical research in the world. On the 20th Sept it was reported that Trump has told his budget director, Russ Vought, to draft an executive order creating a new board to decide which NIH grants are funded. The board would include Vought and the NIH director, and its decisions would have to be unanimous. This is a draft, reported by two people familiar with the plan, and nothing has been signed. If it goes ahead, the White House budget office gets a veto over what medical research is done in the United States.
And the third thing is what gets counted. At the start of September the CDC stopped using the system that states use to report cases and deaths as they happen during an outbreak. It switched to a different system, run by the National Center for Health Statistics, which is built to track mortality trends over years and works on a much slower clock. That system has only just updated to one death, with no details on where. Meanwhile Pennsylvania has confirmed four deaths, two of them babies. A former chief medical officer at the CDC called the change puzzling, because that system was never meant to confirm individual cases during an active outbreak. Members of Congress have now asked for an immediate briefing.
The same thing is happening in education. The National Center for Education Statistics is the main source of national data on how American pupils are doing. It was one of the agencies hit by DOGE last year, and its staff went from about 100 to four. It now has 12. According to tracking by the American Statistical Association, most of the data it used to collect has now been stopped or cut back.
Health and Science Sources
Trump says he will demand some childhood vaccines be split into five doses, citing autism, with no evidence (Reuters): https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/trump-says-he-will-demand-some-childhood-vaccines-be-split-into-five-shots-2026-09-18/
Vaccine experts say splitting doses will not work; the August executive order (CNN): https://www.cnn.com/2026/09/18/health/trump-split-up-immunization
Covid vaccines held back for all children in at least 11 states and one territory (Guardian): https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/sep/23/covid-vaccines-delay-children
CDC has not opened updated Covid vaccines to the Vaccines for Children programme (CNN): https://www.cnn.com/2026/09/17/health/covid-vaccines-delayed-children
Kennedy tells Children’s Health Defense convention they have a friend at the White House (NYT): https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/17/health/kennedy-vaccines-childrens-health-defense.html
John Gaitanis named chair of the federal autism committee; leucovorin and vaccine injury cases (Reuters): https://www.reuters.com/world/kennedy-names-new-chair-us-autism-advisory-panel-sources-say-2026-09-18/
Trump directs Vought to draft order creating a board to decide NIH grants (Reuters, reporting Politico): https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/trump-seeks-bring-health-research-funding-under-his-control-politico-reports-2026-09-20/
CDC changes how it counts measles deaths; four Pennsylvania deaths, federal count zero (CIDRAP): https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/measles/cdc-s-new-tracking-method-measles-deaths-puzzles-experts
Congress requests an immediate briefing on the measles count (Guardian): https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/sep/22/cdc-pennsylvania-measles-death-outbreak
National Center for Education Statistics data stopped or cut back; staff down to 12 (Guardian): https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2026/sep/25/student-math-reading-test-scores
Immigration
So now immigration, and I want to start with two cases from the 20th of September.
In Austin, Texas, an ICE officer shot Wilber Rafael Garcés Pérez, a 28 year old Venezuelan man who was delivering food for DoorDash. Exactly what happened is disputed. He had been ordered deported after missing an immigration hearing, and officers moved to arrest him. His lawyer says he asked to pull over and be detained, and was refused, and that an ICE vehicle then hit his car. Homeland Security says he drove off. What we do know is that video released by the Austin police chief shows his car already stopped, with an agent at the window, before a pursuit started again and he was shot in the torso..
His lawyer says he has no criminal record and came into the US lawfully. The officer who fired had been issued a body camera and was not wearing it, and reports say he was a recruit hired last year. Garcés Pérez was shot in the torso, and about four hours later he was moved from hospital to an ICE detention centre with the bullet still in his back. His wife and his lawyer were not told where he was. His lawyer says he has since been back in hospital for treatment of paralysis on his left side. Homeland Security says he was stable and in custody pending removal, and disputes his account of poor medical care. The local district attorney has asked that he be kept in the country, because he is a witness in their criminal investigation into the shooting.
The same morning in Evanston, just outside Chicago, federal agents in plain clothes tried to arrest a man they thought was a fugitive. He was a US citizen on his way to a pharmacy. Witnesses heard him shouting that he was a US citizen. Police found him on the ground with injuries to his head, neck and teeth, and he was taken to hospital by ambulance. Homeland Security says he resembled their target, would not identify himself, and that the officers relied on their training.
Those two cases are public because they happened on the street, in front of people with phones.
What’s happening in detention facilities where no one can see?
ICE runs an online locator so that lawyers and families can find out where someone is being held. On the 15th Sept, without any announcement, it took everyone with a final deportation order off the locator. That is thousands of people - In July alone, nearly 16,000 people in ICE detention had final orders. Lawyers say their clients have simply vanished from the system. The change only became public because current and former ICE officials told the Associated Press. immigration lawyers point out that if you cannot find someone, you cannot file a last minute challenge before they are put on a plane.
There are other areas where information is disappearing. After a freedom of information request from the Guardian, ICE said it has no data on miscarriages among pregnant women in its detention after October last year, because of a change in its medical accounting system.
When the Texas congresswoman Veronica Escobar went to inspect the largest ICE detention centre in the country, she says she was not allowed to speak to any of the people held there, and her request for surveillance footage has not been answered.
Conditions inside are said to be awful
In one of the rare official looks inside, a report from Homeland Security’s own inspector general on the Florida detention centre known as Alligator Alcatraz, reported that people were held in highly restrictive cages against ICE’s own rules, overcrowding, phones that did not work so people could not reach lawyers or family, and poor food hygiene.
Then there are children. Children who arrive in the US on their own are meant to be cared for by the health department, in licensed shelters, and placed with vetted relatives where possible. According to an analysis of immigration court data shared with the Guardian, over 80 percent of these children who got new court cases in July & August were sent to shelters in Texas. Shelters in Texas are not licensed by the state, and there are far fewer immigration lawyers. The administration has not explained the change. Advocates fear it is being set up to move children quickly through to deportation. The Guardian also reported that Stephen Miller, Trump’s deputy chief of staff, is personally leading a push across several departments to speed up the removal of migrant children, using tactics critics say are cruel and in some cases break federal law.
Where do people get deported to? For more than a year the administration has been sending people to countries, many in Africa, that are not their own, under deals that are often secret. On the 18th Sept an appeals court ruled this policy unlawful. Days later, ICE was still preparing to send a Peruvian man to the Central African Republic. He had already been granted protection from being returned to Peru because of the risk of torture. His lawyers had to go back to court, and at half past eleven at night the court issued a three sentence order spelling out that its ruling applied immediately. A flight with 70 people on board, bound for Burundi, Rwanda and the Central African Republic, was cancelled. Homeland Security called the ruling as reckless and The administration has now gone to the Supreme Court to fight the appeal court’s ruling.
And finally, what refugees are welcome? On the 22nd Sept the administration told Congress it would admit up to 17,500 refugees over the next year, primarily white Afrikaners from South Africa. This year, of nearly 5,000 refugees admitted, all but three were South African. Two years ago the US took more than 100,000 refugees from dozens of countries. The State Department says Afrikaners face land seizures and discrimination, and that they will, in its words, fully assimilate. The South African government denies they are persecuted..
Immigration Sources
ICE officer who shot a DoorDash driver in Austin was issued a body camera but not wearing it (NBC News): https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/ice-officer-shot-man-austin-wasnt-wearing-body-camera-rcna599263
What is known about the Austin shooting, the vehicle stop, and CNN’s count of people shot by agents (CNN): https://www.cnn.com/2026/09/22/us/venezuelan-man-shot-ice-austin
Garcés Pérez back in hospital for paralysis treatment; DHS disputes his account (Reuters): https://www.reuters.com/world/venezuelan-man-shot-by-ice-agents-is-back-hospital-paralysis-treatment-lawyer-2026-09-22/
Officer was a recruit hired last year (Independent via Yahoo News): https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/ice-agent-shot-doordash-driver-113825685.html
US citizen injured in Evanston after agents mistook him for a fugitive; DHS statement (The Hill): https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/6105929-ice-mistaken-identity-evanston/
DHS: ‘We know who we are targeting ahead of time’ (ABC7 Chicago): https://abc7chicago.com/post/evanston-il-ice-incident-man-hurt-wrongly-identified-federal-agents-howard-street-dodge-avenue-police-investigating/19855018/
ICE hides locations of thousands of detainees with final removal orders (AP via Houston Public Media): https://www.houstonpublicmedia.org/articles/news/politics/immigration/2026/09/21/562357/ap-exclusive-ice-hides-locations-of-thousands-of-detainees-with-final-removal-orders/
ICE has no miscarriage data for detained women after October 2025 (Guardian): https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2026/sep/15/ice-detention-miscarriages-pregnancy
Rep. Veronica Escobar prevented from speaking to detainees at the East Montana camp (Guardian): https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/sep/22/texas-democrat-visit-ice-detention-camp-east-montana
Inspector general report on Alligator Alcatraz: cages, overcrowding, phones (Guardian): https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/sep/14/alligator-alcatraz-immigration-jail-cages-report
Most unaccompanied children with new cases sent to Texas (Guardian): https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/sep/18/trump-undocumented-children-texas
The underlying court data analysis: nearly 80% in July, over 90% in August (bklg.org): https://bklg.org/blog/newly-detained-kids-sent-to-texas/
Stephen Miller leads push to accelerate removal of migrant children (Guardian): https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/sep/19/stephen-miller-trump-migrant-children
DHS tried to deport a Peruvian man to the Central African Republic after the appeals court ruling; DHS response (The Hill): https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/6110337-first-circuit-blocks-third-country-deportation/
Flight of 70 people cancelled; administration goes to the Supreme Court (AP via US News): https://www.usnews.com/news/politics/articles/2026-09-24/trump-administration-asks-the-supreme-court-to-allow-quick-third-country-deportations
Administration says it only deports to countries that give assurances (The Hill): https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/6110459-trump-deportation-third-country-supreme-court/
Refugee ceiling of 17,500, primarily Afrikaners (Reuters): https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/trump-administration-admit-primarily-afrikaners-under-new-refugee-proposal-2026-09-22/
State Department’s stated reasons for the Afrikaner programme (CBS News): https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-administration-white-south-africans-refugees-afrikaners/
Thanks for reading Making sense... of evidence, data, and the stories they tell! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit christinapagel.substack.com