In 2010, call-girl Shannan Gilbert disappeared into the cold Long Island night. The search for her began, but instead 4 other women were found dead where Shannan disappeared. And then, still more. The dumping ground stands at 7 today, and many of the victims remain unidentified. A serial killer's work-- but is he the only one on Long Island? The case has long run cold thanks to a corrupt and perverse police captain, and many other loose end suspects have come and gone. But at long last, the killer of the Gilgo Beach Four has been captured. 

Former cop Kendra and Jon break down this complex case, and talk about what stymied investigators and allowed a monster to walk free on earth.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices