Should kids be able to access hardcore porn with just a few taps on a smartphone?

That’s the uncomfortable—but necessary—question at the heart of this episode. As more states introduce age verification laws for obscene content online, the debate over free speech, privacy, and child safety has never been more intense. Are these laws a smart defense against exploitation... or the beginning of a slippery slope toward surveillance and censorship?

In this powerful episode of The Brian Nichols Show, we take a deep dive into the Supreme Court's recent ruling on Texas’ age verification law—and what it means for the future of the internet. With minors just a click away from explicit material, lawmakers argue it’s time to draw a line. But our guest, David McGarry, warns that mandating ID checks for online access might destroy anonymity, chill free speech, and open the floodgates for government overreach.

Brian, a new parent himself, doesn’t shy away from the tough questions. He challenges David directly with real-life scenarios—like how checking a license at a video store differs from uploading your ID online—and why protecting kids might actually justify certain digital restrictions. Together, they tackle the biggest question of all: where should we draw the line between liberty and responsibility in the digital age?

This episode isn’t just about obscene websites. It’s about whether you should be forced to “show your papers” just to speak online. Should the same standards that protect kids from porn be extended to block free speech on Twitter or Facebook? And what’s to stop bad actors—or even the government—from misusing your data once it's collected?

Whether you're a parent, a free speech absolutist, or just trying to make sense of how we protect kids without destroying liberty, this episode is a must-watch. We cut through the legal fog, challenge both sides, and bring it all back to common sense and real-world consequences.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices