Today we got the first report of foreign reserves movements in NE Asia for March. My technical models recognized that the dollar broke out of its weakening trend and established a strengthening trend against the SDR currencies starting March 9, so it was reasonable to expect some pressure on Asia's massive fx holdings simply because of that. In fact, in March the dollar gained 1.6% against the SDR basket (which of course includes itself as a major component). In addition, of course, US bond markets got hammered, with 10yr yields rising from 1.44% at the beginning of the month to 1.76% by month-end. Not, in other words, a great month to be tasked with preserving the value of Asia's c $6tr foreign reserves.
So what happened? Well, the collective foreign reserves of China, Japan, S Korea, Taiwan & Singapore fell by $52bn, or 0.9% to $5.906tr. How did they do? It went with size - the biggest were the least able to take evasive action. So China's reserves fell 1.1% to $3.17tr; Japan's fell 0.8% mom to $1.368tr; Taiwan's fell 0.8% to $539bn; S Korea's fell 0.3% to $446.1bn, Singapore's fell 0.2% to $382bn.
A couple of things to say: this fall will have a small tightening effect on Asia's money markets, and will slightly depress - nothing too dramatic, however, and I don't think this is the most significant thing about today's results. Two other things are more important.
First, when you look at the data, its clear that Japan has really bought the 'inflation's back' story. Overall reserves fell $10.9bn, but within that securities holdings fell $19.6bn, but deposits rose $6.8bn. In other words, they didn't just lose money on bonds, they sold reasonably aggressively on the way down. But there's more: they also started buying gold: in dollar terms gold holdings rose $3.1bn, or by 7.3% during a month when the gold price fell 5.2%. In other words, they actually raised their holdings of physical gold, up 2.6mn troy oz, or by 10.6% on the month. I don't know when the last time Japan's reserves managers bought gold, but it certainly has been any time in the last three years. Selling bonds and buying gold - Japan believes in inflation.
Second, Taiwan is interesting: the central bank blamed its 0.8% mom fall not only on the dollar's strength, but also on 'large capital outflows'. But that's not right: foreigners net holdings of Taiwan deposits and securities fell only $1.1bn (vs a fall of 4.3bn in foreign reserves), or by 0.2%. In other words, those capital outflows were responsible for only a quarter of the fall in reserves. And, note, those holdings now could to $670bn, which is 124% of Taiwan's 539bn of foreign reserves.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit mtaylor.substack.com/subscribe