March 20, 2023

A Deep Dive into Langstroth Hives: Innovation, Limitations, and Alternatives

42 minutes

This episode of "The Poor Proles Almanac," titled "Episode 145 #10: Sending Bees to the Cube Farm; the Reverand's Langstroth Hive," explores the history, design, and limitations of the Langstroth hive, the most common type of beehive used in modern beekeeping. The hosts, Andy and Elliot, use their characteristic humor to unpack the complexities of this widely adopted hive model, highlighting its advantages, shortcomings, and potential alternatives.

The Langstroth Hive: A Revolutionary Design with Enduring Legacy

The episode introduces Reverend Lorenzo Langstroth, an American clergyman and beekeeper often hailed as the "father of American beekeeping." While acknowledging that Langstroth didn't invent the concept of removable frames, the hosts credit him with discovering the "bee space," a crucial gap of approximately one centimeter that prevents bees from gluing frames together with propolis, a resinous substance bees use for hive construction and maintenance. This innovation allowed for easy inspection and manipulation of hive components without damaging the comb or disrupting the colony.

The hosts emphasize that Langstroth's discovery, although significant, wasn't entirely unique. A Polish apiarist, Dr. Jan Dzierzon, had actually identified the same bee space 20 years prior and applied it to top-bar hives. However, Langstroth's design gained widespread recognition and adoption, largely due to its simplicity, affordability, and ease of use.

Anatomy of a Langstroth Hive: From Roof to Bottom Board

The hosts provide a detailed breakdown of the basic components of a Langstroth hive:

Outer Cover: The roof of the hive, providing protection from the elements.

Inner Cover: A barrier between the outer cover and the hive body, preventing bees from gluing the roof down and aiding in ventilation.

Supers: Boxes placed above the hive body for honey storage.

Queen Excluder: A mesh screen that prevents the queen from laying eggs in the supers, ensuring honey purity.

Hive Body (Mediums or Deeps): Boxes where the bees live and raise brood. Mediums are shorter and lighter than deeps, making them easier to handle.

Frames: Wooden structures within the hive body and supers that hold the honeycomb.

Foundation: Sheets of beeswax imprinted with a hexagonal pattern, providing a guide for bees to build their comb uniformly.

Bottom Board: The floor of the hive, providing an entrance for the bees.

The "Hot Potato" Problem: Disrupting Natural Bee Behavior

While acknowledging the advantages of the Langstroth hive, the hosts criticize the conventional practice of rotating hive boxes, which they humorously refer to as the "hot potato" method. This technique involves regularly shuffling the position of hive bodies and supers to encourage bees to build comb and store honey in desired locations. The hosts argue that this constant manipulation disrupts the natural bee behavior of building downward from the top of a cavity, potentially stressing the colony and hindering their ability to prepare adequately for winter.

They point out that conventional beekeeping often involves harvesting honey from the supers during the summer, leaving the bees with insufficient stores for the colder months. To compensate, beekeepers typically feed bees sugar water, which, while providing calories, lacks the nutritional complexity of natural honey.

Insulation: A Forgotten Factor in Modern Beekeeping

The hosts express concern that modern Langstroth hives are often constructed with thinner wood than those used in Langstroth's time, compromising insulation and forcing bees to expend more energy to maintain hive temperature. They advocate for a return to thicker hive walls and the incorporation of insulation materials to reduce stress on the colony and enhance their ability to thrive.

They cite research indicating that insulated hives may not produce more honey but contribute to higher bee survival rates due to reduced mortality from cold stress. This suggests that insulation plays a crucial role in maintaining colony strength and resilience.

Rethinking Hive Design: Exploring Alternatives to the Langstroth

The hosts explore alternative hive designs that address some of the limitations of the traditional Langstroth model:

Long Langstroth Hives: These hives, resembling top-bar hives in their horizontal layout, provide bees with a larger, continuous space to build their comb and store honey, mimicking their natural nesting behavior. This design eliminates the need for box rotation and reduces disturbance to the colony.

Extra Deep Frames: Using deeper frames within a Langstroth hive can provide bees with more space to store honey above the brood nest, allowing them to prepare more effectively for winter.

While acknowledging the benefits of these alternatives, the hosts recognize that the Langstroth hive remains the dominant model in conventional beekeeping due to its portability and ease of management in large-scale operations. They suggest that the choice of hive design depends on the individual beekeeper's goals, resources, and commitment to promoting bee health and natural behavior.

Moving Beyond the "Honeymaking Machine": A Holistic Approach to Beekeeping

The episode concludes with a call for a more holistic approach to beekeeping that recognizes bees as "living intelligent creatures" rather than simply honey production units. The hosts advocate for a shift in beekeeping practices that prioritize:

Reducing Stress: Minimizing hive manipulation and transportation to allow bees to build and manage their homes naturally.

Improving Nutrition: Providing bees with access to diverse and nutritious forage, reducing reliance on sugar water supplements.

Learning from Wild Bees: Observing the behavior and adaptations of wild bee populations to gain insights into sustainable beekeeping practices.

The hosts emphasize that a balanced co-existence between bees and humans is possible through a deeper understanding of bee biology, a respect for their natural behaviors, and a commitment to promoting hive health and resilience.

For sources, transcripts, and to read more about this subject, visit: www.agroecologies.org

To support this podcast, join our patreon for early, commercial-free episode access at https://www.patreon.com/poorprolesalmanac

For PPA Restoration Content, visit: www.restorationagroecology.com

For PPA Merch, visit: www.poorproles.com

For PPA Native Plants, visit: www.nativenurseries.org

To hear Tomorrow, Today, our sister podcast, visit: www.tomorrowtodaypodcast.org/

...more

View all episodes

By The Poor Prole’s Alamanac, Bleav

4.9

748748 ratings