A Sam Girl Retrospective

Enjoy 3 minutes from this month's Patreon exclusive podcast cover S11-S15 of Supernatrual! Season 1 just started on our $3 tier!

Welcome to the 2nd episode of “First Impressions with Audree,” exclusively on our lowest cost Patreon tier! Vic and Kasey (from “Idling in the Impala”) are back to hear Audree’s first impressions of  S11E05-E08: "Thin Lizzie," "Our Little World,","Plush," & "Just My Imagination." There are so many rabbit holes in this one, including quite a lot of true crime tangents (thanks to “Thin Lizzie”), so be sure to check out the show notes!

Also, THIS is the episode where the Dean Spice rating system was born, so take note of the rating below, Dean fans! (We love him but we are frustrated in this one 🥲.)

Please check out the hilarious and unhinged visuals that go along with each episode on our Instagram. If you aren’t subscribed to the Dimples tier, you can always purchase an ep a la carte from our Patreon shop. Share this post, drop comments of your thoughts on our takes, and rate/like and subscribe!

Introducing the Dean Scale to warn of Dean criticism in our reactions. 

This episode measures at a yellow: “DEAN SPICY.”

Links:

Supernatural: “No Exit”

The Ghostfacers

Sam and Colby Youtube Ghost-hunters

The real Lizzie Borden House

What would real lawyers think of Ted Bundy on Quora

Ted Bundy: Falling for a Killer

The Morbid Podcast series about Lizzie Borden

Dallas' Adolphus haunted elevators video 

Hacks series on HBO

Statues of women discoloring around their breasts/etc.

Jack Nicholson grew up believing his grandmother was his mom and his mother was his sister.

Golden State Killer: Former fiancée (Bonnie) confronts Joseph DeAngelo in court

Pulp Fiction (1994)

The Julie Andrews episode of The Muppets Show

Jensen pranks Jared with a Bear on the set of “Walker”

She's Out of My League (2010)

Hot Professor Sam tag on Audree’s tumblr blog

Zara Larsson on IG

Audree’s “Choices” tag on Tumblr: Sam’s thesis

BitterSamGirlClub on Tumblr

Like/Rate/Review & Subscribe to the show on:

Email us at: [email protected]

Follow us on IG for visuals and updates.

Images from Supernatural Archive.

Enjoy 5 minutes from this month's Patreon exclusive podcast cover S11-S15 of Supernatrual! Season 1 just started on our $3 tier!

Welcome to the inaugural episode of “First Impressions with Audree” exclusively on our lowest Patreon tier! In this series Audree watches S11 of Supernatural for the first time and reacts to Vic and Kasey (from “Idling in the Impala”) who have both seen it before. Chaos ensues, so buckle up! We start by covering 4 Spn episodes per podcast episode, but we’ll break some of them in two because (as you can imagine) we yap too much! This month you guys get the entire first episode, though. Audree, Vic, and Kasey cover S11E01-E04: "Out of the Darkness, Into the Fire,” "Form and Void,” "The Bad Seed,” and "Baby." 

Please check out the hilarious and unhinged visuals that go along with each episode on our Instagram. If you aren’t subscribed to the Dimples tier, you can always purchase an ep a la carte from our Patreon shop.

Share this post, drop comments of your thoughts on our takes, and rate/like and subscribe!

Introducing the Dean Scale to warn of Dean criticism in our reactions. 

This episode measures at a yellow: “DEAN CRITICAL" with a little "We Love Dean!" sprinkled in at the end.

Links:

Katie Sarife on Supernatural 

Anything for Jackson starring Julian Richings

Zombieland movie

The script of deleted scene where Sam is cleaning up

Watch the clean-up deleted scene here

S11E02 Form and Void vs S10E23 Brother's Keeper - Deleted Scene

Audree’s Piper ficlet from Baby

Vic’s Piper ficlet from Baby

Jensen teaching Alex to drive the Impala

“Working On My Night Cheese” scene from 30 Rock

Like/Rate/Review & Subscribe to the show on:

Email us at: [email protected]

Follow us on IG for visuals and updates.

Images from Supernatural Archive.

Introducing a brand new Supernatural podcast series called, “First Impressions!” from the Sam Retrospective crew!

Go on a journey through Seasons 11-15 of Supernatural with Audree for the first time! This will post monthly on Patreon to our first tier, the $3 Dimples Tier.

With guest hosts, the “Retrospective’s” own Vic and “Idling in the Impala’s” Kasey, Audree will watch the final 5 seasons of Supernatural for the first time and discuss what she expected from each episode, what she actually got, and everything in between! It’s unhinged and hilarious. 

Enjoy this series on our first tier for only $3 monthly starting in September ‘26! See you there!

Like/Rate/Review & Subscribe to the show on:

Email us at: [email protected]

Follow us on IG for visuals and updates.

Images from Supernatural Archive.

This is the final episode of our season and we finish with a discussion about season 3 overall. Listen to all your hosts discuss the best and least best parts of the season by the numbers, and then they each share their top 3 favorite Sam moments of season 3. We will be back with season 4 in the future. Until then, catch us monthly with bonus content and extra episodes on Patreon and watch this space for main-feed events and celebrations! We love you guys. 

Don’t forget to check out the visuals for this episode on Instagram, drop comments of your thoughts on our takes, and rate/like and subscribe! 

TIMESTAMP 36:46 - L says makes a fandom inside joke that is so random, I had to bleep it with a cat sound, so don’t be alarmed. But there are explanations in the visuals and may be an IG Reel or Tiktok to explain it coming later. 

Episode Links: 

Like/Rate/Review & Subscribe to the show on:

Email us at: [email protected]

Follow us on IG for visuals and updates.

Images from Supernatural Archive.

We’ve made it to the finale of S3. Episode 10 of the podcast covers "No Rest for the Wicked" with L, Christie, Vic, and Audree on deck. We talk for so long about some of the most upsetting stuff from Supernatural that we actually end it a little slap-happy (check the visuals for Vic’s crab hair clip).  Let us know your thoughts in the comments. Don’t forget to check out the visuals for this episode on Instagram, drop comments of your thoughts on our takes, and rate/like and subscribe! 

Episode Link:

The origins of “gr8”

Crab hair clip to purchase 1

Crab hair clip to purchase 2

Like/Rate/Review & Subscribe to the show on:

Email us at: [email protected]

Follow us on IG for visuals and updates.

Images from Supernatural Archive.

Episode 9 comes in swinging this week. L, Christie, and Audree talk for nearly 3 hours. After a catch-up chit chat at the beginning, the hosts get into discussions about "Long-Distance Call" & "Time Is On My Side." We’re spiraling so close to the finale of Spn: S3! Let us know your thoughts in the comments. Don’t forget to check out the visuals for this episode on Instagram, drop comments of your thoughts on our takes, and rate/like and subscribe!

TW: Discussions/mentions of suicide within the Spn episode.

Episode Links:

Marry-Me Chickpea recipe

Orphaned on the Ocean by Terry Jo Duperrault

The Survival Of Terry Jo Duperrault: Mass Murder On The High Seas

MFM Rewind of the Terry Jo Duperraut survive story episode

Past Lives film

Her film

Once film

Once the Broadway Show 

Superman (2025) film

“What Happened to Dean’s Jacket?” video essay 

Chris Hansen and “To Catch a Predator”

The Princess Bride: TheROUSes (Rodents of Unusual Size) scene 

Peacemaker on HBO

Spirit Island boardgame

Dead of Winter game

Cards Against Humanity card game

Our Patreon collection of “Chatty Episodes”

Reference to Sid and Nancy

Corridor Crew discussing the FX of Supernatural 3.15

The Fellowship of the Rings Extended Edition actor commentary

“In Defense of Bela Talbot”

Steven Williams (actor)

Like/Rate/Review & Subscribe to the show on:

Email us at: [email protected]

Follow us on IG for visuals and updates.

Images from Supernatural Archive.

Episode 8 is here this week! It’s just Audree and Vic in a classic-style two-host episode. They cover "Jus in Bello” & "Ghostfacers!" which are both really fun ones to discuss. Let us know your thoughts in the comments. Don’t forget to check out the visuals for this episode on Instagram, drop comments of your thoughts on our takes, and rate/like and subscribe!

Episode Links: 

James Gunn’s search for Batman 

Batman is actually 6’2”

Jensen Ackles auditioned for Smallville

“I Shot the Sheriff” by Bob Marley

Top 5 BitterSamGirlClub prompts

Zak Bagans cheating on Holly Madison

Buffy the Vampire Slayer - 7.16: “Storyteller”

The GLAAD Awards

Like/Rate/Review & Subscribe to the show on:

Email us at: [email protected]

Follow us on IG for visuals and updates.

Images from Supernatural Archive.

SURPRISE! TODAY IS TUESDAY.

So you know we HAD to release this week's episode early to commemorate the podcast covering "MYSTERY SPOT," one of the most iconic episodes in Supernatural history. 

L, Vic, Christie, and Audree talk for nearly 2 hours about "Mystery Spot." Things get impassioned and heated as the hosts dig into every facet of this legendary episode. Let us know your thoughts in the comments. Don’t forget to check out the visuals for this episode on Instagram, drop comments of your thoughts on our takes, and rate/like and subscribe!

Episode Links:

Like/Rate/Review & Subscribe to the show on:

Email us at: [email protected]

Follow us on IG for visuals and updates.

Images from Supernatural Archive.

Episode 6 has L, Christie, and Audree covering "Malleus Maleficarum" & "Dream a Little Dream of Me" as we enter the second half of the 3rd season of our podcast! There is so much to say about these two episodes and you know we are basically professional yappers at this point.  Don’t forget to check out the visuals for this episode on Instagram, drop comments of your thoughts on our takes, and rate/like and subscribe!

Episode Links:

Sarah Jessica Parker Calls Out Double Standards

Like/Rate/Review & Subscribe to the show on:

Email us at: [email protected]

Follow us on IG for visuals and updates.

Images from Supernatural Archive.

Episode 5 only covers one Supernatural episode, but L, Vic, and Audree STILL talk for nearly 2 hours. That’s because it’s the Supernatural Christmas Special! Don’t forget to check out the visuals for this episode on Instagram, drop comments of your thoughts on our takes, and rate/like and subscribe!

Episode Links:

Like/Rate/Review & Subscribe to the show on:

Email us at: [email protected]

Follow us on IG for visuals and updates.

Images from Supernatural Archive.