Join us for a super huge recap of A (*whispered) Secret in a Small Town, AKA the Tara Grinstead case, where we argue over what makes a douchebag a douchebag (and it's not over the douchebag you might think it is) and Katie brings out her very best Nancy Grace impression. Also, Kimberly pitches a new idea for an Andrea Canning game show and Katie doesn't think it'll get picked up, not even by the Game Show Network and they'll put anything on the air. We've got lots of opinions in this one and we're going to need yours to tell us who's right. So find us on Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook and give us your thoughts on a silver platter!

Official Description from NBC:

When a beloved teacher and former beauty queen goes missing in Georgia, it triggers a decade-long investigation that makes national headlines. Could a surprising revelation break the case wide open? Andrea Canning reports.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices