
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Karen Read was acquitted and is launching a podcast. Lindsay Clancy's jury hung, and her lawyers say she can't be tried again. A former Stoughton officer is on federal trial in Sandra Birchmore's death. Three cases from my own backyard.
The state never prosecuted me. The feds did, and they got me. I take all three cases apart from that side of the line: why a state case leaves room to walk, why police can't investigate police, and why I'd hand every one of these to the feds, the same people who ruined my life.
(00:00) Too bad the feds weren't involved
(00:26) Karen Read's podcast
(03:04) Lindsay Clancy and the holdout juror
(05:21) Stoughton, Canton and Sandra Birchmore
(07:02) It took the feds to charge a cop
(07:14) Had I been prosecuted by the state
(07:30) "Yeah, but 3% don't"
(09:12) They threatened me with 40 years
(10:50) "The female Tony Soprano"
(12:03) The thread through all three
Follow the show so you hear me on the Clancy ruling, November 16.
Watch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AmericanRegret
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/fairygodfelon/
TikTok, LIVE every Tuesday at 6:30 PM ET: https://www.tiktok.com/@americanregret
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/AmericanRegret
Flinch, the newsletter: https://lp1.americanregret.net/flinch
I did time at FCI Danbury with two transgender women. One broke a 65-year-old woman’s face, and the Bureau of Prisons decided the victim provoked it. The other castrated herself in solitary to get out of men’s prison.
On October 21, 2026, the Supreme Court left in place an order that keeps the BOP from cutting off hormone therapy for transgender inmates while the case plays out. It settles nothing inside. The BOP does the minimum, and the rest gets fought out in the dark corners where women like Ms. Dottie, Bianca and Roxy serve their sentences.
Recorded in front of Rita’s Spotlight in Allston, Boston, the memorial to Rita Hester, whose 1998 murder is why Transgender Day of Remembrance exists every November 20.
In this episode:
Content note: describes prison violence, self-harm and sexual abuse. Explicit language.
Follow American Regret wherever you’re listening so the next episode finds you.
Watch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AmericanRegret
I came home from four years in federal prison afraid of everything. In this solocast I break down the three things fear takes from you: your clarity (the guy who put me away grew up in my neighborhood, and I never saw him coming), your money (lawyers selling hope to women doing 20 and 30 years, and a feed, a politician and an alarm company selling it to you), and your kids.
Franklin Roosevelt said the only thing we have to fear is fear itself. He was wrong. There's real danger out there. Careful keeps its eyes open. Cowed keeps its eyes on the feed.
So find your horseman. What did he cost you this year? Then pull the head off and see who's under there.
🔴 LIVE on TikTok Tuesday, Oct 27 at 6:00 PM ET. We're talking fear: the kind you write yourself and the kind somebody's selling you. Bring your horseman.
🎧 Listen to American Regret: https://lp1.americanregret.net/tune-in
Chapters
0:00 Being fearless got me sent to federal prison
0:19 A man with a motive
0:38 Coming home to a second sentence
0:53 Ichabod Crane and the Headless Horseman
1:20 Fear takes your clarity: the snitch
2:02 Fear takes your money
2:51 Fear takes your kids
3:07 FDR was wrong
3:25 Careful vs. cowed
3:47 What fear doesn't want you to see
4:21 Find your horseman
4:38 Live Tuesday on fear
American Regret is pattern recognition from someone who's lived the consequences. I'm Deana Martin, your fairy godfelon.
#AmericanRegret #Fear #SleepyHollow.
A son who was eleven in a towel when the rifles came through the door, his mother home from fourteen years in federal prison, and the argument neither of them could have until the recorder was running.
THIS EPISODE, THE BOOTH STAYS EMPTY
THE HOOK
THE PATTERN
QUESTIONS THIS EPISODE ANSWERS
KEY MOMENTS
THE FAIRY GODFELON TAKE
WHAT TO DO WITH THIS
RESOURCES & RELATED
If someone you love is inside, just came home, or went somewhere you couldn't follow, write to me: [email protected]. I read everything, and I'll point you where I can.
Mentioned in this episode:
NEXT EPISODE
CREDITS
FOLLOW & LISTEN
FCI Dublin was nicknamed the r*pe club, and it earned the name. The warden went to federal prison. So did the chaplain. The government paid $116 million to 103 women. I was the unit legal clerk in Danbury when the Dublin women transferred in, and at least four of them told me, in their own words, what they did with the payday. If you came here with a side in the gender war already picked, I’m about to take it from you.
What happens when a real prison sexual abuse scandal turns into a payout, and everyone involved does the same math: what do I want, and is the door open? Guards, inmates and the Bureau of Prisons all answered it. The gender war needs FCI Dublin to be he versus she. Every person in it was on their own side.
Everyone in Dublin made a decision, and the gender war erases every one of them. The guard who knew the law and decided she was worth the risk made a choice. So did the woman who decided what she would trade for a lifestyle waiting on the outside, and the woman who heard the BOP was writing checks and wrote herself a story to match. The Bureau of Prisons made one too: it bought its way out of a scandal rather than fix the place that produced it. A slogan lets you skip every one of those decisions and go straight to a verdict on half the species, which is exactly why slogans sell. Score the decision, and the he-versus-she board stops working.
Pick the slogan you reach for when a story like this breaks. Men are predators. Women lie. Whichever one feels true to you. Now name one person you actually know who breaks it. Then ask yourself why arguing about half the species feels easier than looking at what that one person decided.
Mentioned in this episode:
The Dublin staff knew how to keep a secret. Next time: the guards’ brotherhood.
Host: Deana Martin, The Fairy GodFelon.
Production: American Regret.
Listen everywhere: pod.link/6788405697 (Apple, Spotify, iHeartRadio, Podbean, and more)
Watch on YouTube: youtube.com/@AmericanRegret
Instagram: instagram.com/fairygodfelon
TikTok: tiktok.com/@americanregret
Facebook: facebook.com/AmericanRegret
Reddit: reddit.com/r/AmericanRegretPod
A few years ago I ran what was arguably the largest weed delivery business of its time: a million dollars a month, a house on Toluca Lake, shopping on Rodeo Drive. Last week a breakfast place fired me after five days for being too proud. Before that, I watched the owner spend twenty minutes standing over a teenage hostess in front of customers, and I said nothing.
The pattern: an owner who can name his worst trait out loud, then staffs his floor with kids too young to make him do anything about it.
00:00 From Rodeo Drive to a breakfast shift
00:31 The kids at the host station
01:09 The corned beef hash standoff
02:10 The server nobody would name
02:29 Twenty minutes at the host stand
03:26 What I did, and what I didn't
04:05 The 20-year-old manager
05:15 Fired for being too proud
05:53 Why he hires young
06:09 What I told him on the way out
07:17 Watch the staff
07:52 What I regret
Every owner has a worst trait. The dangerous ones know exactly what theirs is, say it out loud, and build a staff too young to push back. Confession without consequence becomes a permission slip. The bystander math has its own architecture too: I had run kitchens, I knew what a correction looked like, and I still weighed a breakfast paycheck against a kid's dignity and let the paycheck win for twenty minutes.
I was sentenced to 48 months in federal prison. Some lessons are priceless secondhand.
Subscribe to American Regret so the next episode finds you.
Listen: https://lp1.americanregret.net/tune-in
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/fairygodfelon/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@americanregret
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/AmericanRegret
Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/AmericanRegretPod
f your son was one of the seven men in that room at Cornell, you’d find a way to call it a mistake. If your daughter was the one on the other end of it, you’d call it the worst night of her life. You already know both of those sentences are true.
Everybody covering this case is arguing about who, where, when, and why — because those four questions have an exit on every side. I’m not interested in the exits. I raised a son who was active in a fraternity. I’ve sat on the side of the courtroom that decides someone’s fate. And people close to me have survived exactly what’s being argued about here like it’s abstract.
So forget who, where, when, and why. Here’s what’s actually in dispute: intoxicated and absent are not the same word. There’s a line somewhere between “had a few drinks” and her own words to investigators — “the lights are on, but nobody’s home.” And here’s the one piece of this case you don’t need a jury for: four men and zero women went to check on her. Nobody in the history of actual wellness checks has ever needed that ratio to ask if somebody’s okay.
Three questions, yes or no. Would you have traded places with her? Would you have wanted your sister there instead? Your daughter? And would your mother have been proud of what you did in that room? If your answer starts with “you have to understand,” you’re not answering the question — you’re building an excuse, and part of you already knows it.
The DA’s own decision called her intoxicated, not forced — his word — in the same decision that closed this case without ever picking up the phone to call her. I have real questions about that. And I still wonder why boys come first in 2026. Tell me I’m wrong.
If this one got under your skin, that’s the show. Subscribe for the next one.
Listen Everywhere: https://lp1.americanregret.net/tune-in
My daughter once described online dating as wading through a pile of shit looking for something shiny. I thought that was hilarious enough to climb into a porta-potty and make a reel about it. Nobody watched it. The metaphor wasn't wrong about the pile — it was wrong about the shiny thing. Everybody standing in it thinks they're the one.
This is the full accounting: the dating profiles that should come with a warning label, the exact moment a man becomes "they," and the three men who actually taught me what pattern recognition costs — Keith, Adam, and Eric. It ends on the bear. You know the one. I'm still picking the man, every time, and I'll tell you exactly why.
If you've ever built an entire theory about the opposite sex out of one bad profile, this one's for you.
0:00 The Shiny Thing
New solocasts and full episodes drop regularly — subscribe so you don't miss the next one.
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/fairygodfelon/
Episode 5A
Someone else's mess just became your mess. You didn't sign up for it or do anything to deserve it — you happened to be in the room, or the family, or on the lease when their choice became everyone's problem. Suhay was twenty, asleep with her one-year-old, when she turned over and saw a gun pointed at her face. Two days later, the letter came: she'd passed every exam for the Border Patrol Academy, and the federal system no longer wanted her. She lost a career she didn't choose to lose, and fourteen years she never sentenced herself to. The person who got arrested isn't the subject here. The subject is what you do with a consequence that was never yours.
When someone else's choice lands on you — a parent, a partner, a sibling whose decision became your problem — the easiest thing in the world is to spend years building a case against them in your head, pulling it out anytime your own life isn't working. Suhay refuses to do that. She names the pattern she inherited without using her mother's failures as the alibi for it. You don't have to forgive someone to stop running their tab.
There's a version of this story where Suhay spends fourteen years building a case against her mother — a tidy explanation she could reach for every time her own life wobbled. She had every right to it. She was twenty, holding a baby, with a brother to raise, a grandmother starting to falter, and a career the federal government erased two days after the raid for the crime of sharing a last name. Nobody would have blamed her for being bitter. But here's what she actually does: she names the pattern she inherited — the relationships where the minimum felt like enough, the same shape repeating — and in the same breath she refuses to make her mother responsible for it. "I've made the worst choices, and I don't blame my mom." That distinction is the entire episode. Most of us, when we hear ourselves echo our parents, route it straight through blame: I'm like this because they were like that. It's true, and it's also an off-ramp, and Suhay doesn't take it. You don't have to forgive someone to stop running their tab. You just have to stop reaching for their failure every time you need to explain your own.
Find the tab you've been running. The parent, the ex, the person whose choice became the thing you've organized your disappointments around. Now separate the two questions you've been keeping fused: what they actually did to you, and what you keep doing with it. The first one might be real and serious and entirely not your fault. The second one belongs to you. You can hold someone fully responsible for the damage they caused and still stop using that damage as the explanation for every place your own life is stuck. Owning your pattern doesn't let them off the hook. It gets you off it.
Related Episodes:
FOLLOW & LISTEN
Mentioned in this episode:
Next time, Hector. Same morning, same raid, but he was eleven and wrapped in a towel when four men with rifles came through the bathroom door. Same mother, same fourteen years, completely different kid. You're going to recognize him too — just for different reasons. And there's a stack of unopened letters we haven't told you about yet.
Host: Deana Martin, The Fairy GodFelon Guest: Suhay, Martha's daughter Producer: Deana Martin Editor: Deana Martin Production: American Regret
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | iHeartRadio | Podbean — or use the all-platform link: pod.link/6788405697
I served time with a woman who did something comparably brutal to what put Christa Pike on death row. She's doing twenty-one years at a federal camp. Pike was scheduled to die Wednesday night, and she survived the execution.
Same government, two eighteen-year-olds, two completely different answers, and a botched execution that raises a harder question than anyone's actually asking.
I'm not telling you Cinthya Proctor deserved worse, or that Christa Pike deserves less. That's not my call, on either side. What I will tell you is that the standard moves depending on who's standing in front of it. After Wednesday night, I've landed somewhere specific on what should happen to Pike now. You don't have to land there too, but you don't get to call this simple anymore.
Full show: lp1.americanregret.net/tune-in
Tags: Christa Pike, Cinthya Proctor, Tennessee execution, death penalty, botched execution, Colleen Slemmer, death row, American Regret, Fairy GodFelon, true crime commentary
From the publisher's feed
Smart people don't ruin their lives by accident. They do it by being convincing — and the person they convince is themselves.
American Regret is a forensic examination of how capable, self-aware people talk themselves into the choices that end their lives as they knew them — and how the rest of us are doing the exact same thing right now, just with smaller stakes and no federal agents involved yet.
Every episode takes one person who had everything to lose and lost it: the cancer researcher who trusted the wrong person, the dealer who cooperated with the DEA for six years and called it bad luck, the Border Patrol agent who refused to cooperate and did the time. We don't tell their stories for the shock. We dissect them for the pattern — the rationalization, the language people use on themselves, the four seconds of hearing yourself clearly that separates the people who stayed free from the ones who didn't.
This isn't true crime and it isn't self-help. There's no healing arc, no five steps, no redemption on a schedule. Just the unflinching architecture of self-deception, examined by someone who built her own and did her time taking it apart.
Your host is Deana Martin — the Fairy GodFelon. She's not a doctor or a coach. She's the smartest person who was ever wrong about everything, finally telling the truth. New episodes every two weeks.
Listen close. You're going to recognize someone. The problem is it's going to be you.