An Insider's Edge - with Gary Bart

An Insider's Edge - with Gary Bart

By Gary BartBusinessTechnology
Download on the App Store

All An Insider's Edge - with Gary Bart episodes

  • Apple Changed Its Mind About Touch. It Didn't Change the Mac.

    Apple has finally introduced a touchscreen MacBook Pro.

    The keyboard remains. So does the trackpad. The machine retains the conventional laptop form factor and desktop operating system that distinguish a Mac from an iPad. Apple has expanded how people can interact with the computer while preserving its familiar working arrangement.

    I think that is the right starting point. Touch should earn its place by making particular tasks easier. It shouldn’t require everyone to change how they work.

    But keeping the Mac recognizable is a modest threshold for a company that resisted touchscreen laptops for sixteen years. The harder question is whether Apple’s implementation delivers enough value to justify the wait.

    The Objection Still Matters

    In October 2010, Steve Jobs explained Apple’s resistance to touchscreen laptops in ergonomic terms. Reaching toward an upright display could become tiring. Apple favored horizontal touch surfaces for notebook interaction. Contemporaneous event coverage

    That objection still deserves consideration. Adding a touch sensor doesn’t change the position of a person’s shoulder or make holding an arm in the air comfortable.

    It also doesn’t settle the question.

    There is a substantial difference between using a screen as the primary input surface throughout the day and occasionally reaching forward to manipulate something directly. A person might prefer a trackpad for most work and still find touch useful for enlarging a photograph or moving an object.

    Touchscreen Windows laptops have offered that choice for years. Microsoft’s 2015 Surface Book announcement Their existence doesn’t establish that everyone needs touch, but it does make coexistence an ordinary product-design question.

    Apple now has to demonstrate what its version contributes.

    The history is also more complicated than sixteen years of rejecting touch on the Mac. Apple introduced the Touch Bar in 2016, placing a changing set of touch controls above the keyboard. That was a different approach from touching the display, but it matters: Apple was experimenting with where touch belonged in a notebook, even while keeping it off the main screen. Apple’s 2016 announcement

    We can examine those decisions. We cannot claim to know what Apple learned from them without evidence.

    Adding a Feature Changes the Product

    I’ve spent much of my career developing hardware products, working with industrial designers, mechanical engineers, software teams, and manufacturing partners.

    One lesson from that experience is that adding a feature is usually easier than integrating it into a product without compromising everything around it.

    Consider the hinge. A laptop display must remain where the user positions it, while still being easy to open and adjust. Touch adds repeated physical pressure. Making the hinge resist that pressure creates another set of demands on the mechanism.

    Apple says its new MacBook Pro combines tandem OLED, a touch sensor built into the display panel, and a redesigned hinge intended to improve stability during touch interaction. Those are relevant engineering choices. Their effectiveness remains to be tested in daily use. Apple’s announcement

    Software presents a different problem. A pointer can select controls much smaller than a fingertip. Enlarging everything for touch can reduce the information density that makes desktop applications productive.

    Recognizing a finger is therefore only part of the job. The interface must help people act accurately without making familiar tasks slower or more cumbersome.

    Apple says macOS translates touches into clicks, allowing many existing applications to work immediately. Updated system gesture APIs let developers create interactions specifically for touch. Apple’s explanation

    That provides a bridge to existing software. It doesn’t establish that every application becomes pleasant to touch. A small control remains a small target, regardless of which part of the system translates the input.

    The real test is whether people can move between touch, keyboard, and trackpad naturally, with each method contributing something useful.

    What Did Waiting Accomplish?

    Apple’s announcement describes an integrated hardware and software effort. It does not establish that the effort required sixteen years.

    The company may have waited for an implementation it considered acceptable. Product positioning and commercial priorities may also have influenced the timing.

    The Next Web, citing Bloomberg, reports that Cook and Ternus began backing a touchscreen MacBook Pro roughly four years ago, with the aim of reviving Mac sales and charging more for premium features. That is a reported explanation, rather than an established account of every decision behind the product. It nevertheless belongs alongside the engineering argument. The Next Web’s report

    A company can pursue a better product and a higher selling price at the same time. Customers still have to decide whether the improvement warrants the expense.

    The touchscreen models start at $2,899 for the 14-inch and $3,399 for the 16-inch in the United States. Buyers are paying for a package of changes, including the display and redesigned hardware, so those prices cannot be treated as the cost of touch alone. Launch pricing

    My view is that Apple deserves credit for addressing the surrounding product, but no automatic credit for the delay. A long wait creates expectations. It doesn’t satisfy them.

    The Judgment That Matters

    The Mac and iPad serve overlapping but different purposes. Those differences involve how people position the devices, use applications, and organize their work. A touchscreen alone doesn’t erase them.

    For writing, spreadsheets, coding, and precise work across multiple windows, the keyboard and trackpad remain compelling tools. Direct manipulation may be useful at other moments. The design challenge is to make that choice available without turning it into an obligation.

    Apple’s decision to preserve the MacBook’s basic arrangement looks sensible to me. A professional computer should accommodate useful new interactions while respecting the habits and capabilities people already depend on.

    There’s a difference between being early, being late, and being ready.

    Apple has often benefited from adopting technologies after competitors. That approach creates value when the eventual implementation improves the experience enough to make the timing matter less.

    This MacBook Pro has yet to meet that test. Does the display remain stable when touched? Can users select controls accurately? Does reaching toward the screen save effort, or interrupt the work? After the novelty wears off, which tasks become easier?

    Those answers will matter more than another argument about whether Steve Jobs was right in 2010.

    His ergonomic concern remains valid. Apple has now decided that the benefits of occasional direct interaction justify working around it.

    That is a defensible product decision. Whether it was worth sixteen years will be measured in the work the new Mac makes easier.



    Get full access to An Insider’s Edge at garyfbart.substack.com/subscribe
    8 min
  • Apple After Cook: The Second Signal

    Link to original article:

    Sources

    * AppleInsider, October 5, 2026: https://appleinsider.com/articles/26/10/05/ternus-and-cook-commemorate-steve-jobs-on-the-15th-anniversary-of-his-death

    * Bloomberg Power On, October 4, 2026: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2026-10-04/apple-s-john-ternus-leads-design-touch-screen-oled-macbook-pro-gets-lighter



    Get full access to An Insider’s Edge at garyfbart.substack.com/subscribe
    4 min
  • Apple After Cook: One Month In

    One month into John Ternus's tenure as Apple's CEO, the question isn't simply what has changed. It's whether Apple is beginning to rediscover the product-design culture that made it extraordinary.

    In this episode, I examine what Ternus's leadership could mean for Apple's future, particularly the relationship between design, engineering, and executive decision-making.

    Having spent decades developing consumer electronics, including founding XtremeMac and building products for Apple's ecosystem, I approach this transition from the perspective of someone who has experienced Apple's decisions from the other side of the table.

    In This Episode

    Why Ternus's engineering and product-development background matters.

    The difference between managing Apple's existing business and defining its next generation of products.

    How Apple's design culture evolved under Steve Jobs and Tim Cook.

    Why bringing design closer to executive leadership could matter.

    What the first month can—and cannot—tell us about Apple's direction.

    What to watch as Ternus begins establishing his own leadership identity.

    The Bigger Question

    Apple doesn't lack engineering talent, financial resources, or market reach. The question is whether its leadership can translate those advantages into products that genuinely redefine categories.

    A change in CEO doesn't automatically restore a company's creative instincts. But it can change which voices are heard, how decisions are made, and what the organization considers worth pursuing.

    One month is too early to declare a transformation. It's not too early to start looking for evidence of one.

    About the Host

    Founder of XtremeMac and a product-design executive with decades of experience developing consumer electronics, exploring the intersection of Apple, industrial design, technology, and artificial intelligence.



    Get full access to An Insider’s Edge at garyfbart.substack.com/subscribe
    7 min