Power Structuralism in Ancient Ontologies

Aristotle on Singular Thought


Listen Later

Mika Perala gives a talk on Aristotle's philosophy Aristotle states in the De Memoria et Reminiscentia that we have memories of individuals such as Koriscus. In line with this, he assumes in many contexts (e.g. logical and ethical) that we can make singular propositions on the basis of such perceptual states. However, commentators have been puzzled about whether singular propositions (and thoughts) can be given an adequate account in Aristotle’s psychological theory. The purpose of this paper is to argue that Aristotle’s account of thought admits of two kinds of singular thought: thought about an individual as an instance of a kind (‘This F is G’) and thought simply about an individual ‘a’, without the sortal concept F (‘a is G’). The difference between the two is that whereas the former requires knowledge of the kind (i.e. F) into which the singular item falls, or at least some sortal grasp of the individual in question such as through experience or the testimony of a knowledgeable person, the latter is simply based on, but cannot be identified with, sense perception, memory, phantasy or some other way of gaining non-sortal information about the individual. The view opposed is the Thomistic line of interpretation that, in Aristotle’s view, singular thought is to be understood as some sort of general thought, indirect or reflexive: general thought applied to a singular item given by a phantasm. The Thomistic view makes singular thought merely accidental and fails to give an adequate account of singular truth-claims.
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Power Structuralism in Ancient OntologiesBy Oxford University

  • 3.1
  • 3.1
  • 3.1
  • 3.1
  • 3.1

3.1

7 ratings


More shows like Power Structuralism in Ancient Ontologies

View all
Philosophy for Beginners by Oxford University

Philosophy for Beginners

328 Listeners

Approaching Shakespeare by Oxford University

Approaching Shakespeare

330 Listeners

General Philosophy by Oxford University

General Philosophy

73 Listeners

Aesthetics and Philosophy of Art lectures by Oxford University

Aesthetics and Philosophy of Art lectures

75 Listeners

Theoretical Physics - From Outer Space to Plasma by Oxford University

Theoretical Physics - From Outer Space to Plasma

56 Listeners

Critical Reasoning: A Romp Through the Foothills of Logic by Oxford University

Critical Reasoning: A Romp Through the Foothills of Logic

38 Listeners

The Secrets of Mathematics by Oxford University

The Secrets of Mathematics

42 Listeners

Critical Reasoning for Beginners by Oxford University

Critical Reasoning for Beginners

30 Listeners

CortexCast - A Neuroscience Podcast by Oxford University

CortexCast - A Neuroscience Podcast

4 Listeners

Poetry with Alice Oswald by Oxford University

Poetry with Alice Oswald

25 Listeners