In December 1984, Mötley Crüe was one of the fastest-rising bands in rock. Then Vince Neil got behind the wheel after drinking, lost control of his car, and caused a collision that killed Hanoi Rocks drummer Razzle and seriously injured two people in another vehicle.
In this episode, Robert John Hadfield and Shelle Crow revisit a Circus magazine article published while Neil’s future—and the future of Mötley Crüe—remained uncertain. They examine the accident, the surprisingly limited sentence Neil ultimately received, and the band’s decision to continue recording what would become Theatre of Pain.
They also explore the uncomfortable contradiction at the center of Mötley Crüe: the dangerous rock-and-roll lifestyle that helped make the band famous eventually produced devastating real-world consequences. Along the way, Robert remembers discovering “Live Wire,” the impact of Shout at the Devil, Nikki Sixx’s marketing instincts, Mick Mars’ importance to the band, and what it was like watching Mötley Crüe become larger than life during the 1980s.
00:00 A Dark Moment in Mötley Crüe History
00:41 Revisiting a 1985 Circus Magazine
01:33 Discovering Mötley Crüe Through “Live Wire”
02:50 The Impact of Shout at the Devil
04:12 Mötley Crüe Changes With Theatre of Pain
05:01 Three Bands Struck by Tragedy
05:31 Def Leppard’s Career-Altering Setback
07:16 Vince Neil’s Fatal Car Accident
07:50 Who Were Hanoi Rocks?
08:38 The Other Victims of the Collision
09:07 When Rock Heroes Let You Down
10:34 Mötley Crüe Pushes Forward
11:35 Racing to Finish the Third Album
12:44 Vince Neil’s Arrest
14:16 The Sentence and $3 Million Settlement
16:23 Did the Accident Change Vince Neil?
17:10 Rumors of a New Mötley Crüe Singer
18:19 The Interconnected Los Angeles Rock Scene
19:24 How Long Did the Original Band Survive?
20:19 The Truth About Vince Neil’s Voice
23:01 Mötley Crüe Attempts to Mature
23:49 A Chilling Prediction From 1984
24:36 Nikki Sixx’s Heroin Years
25:12 Living the Image Around the Clock
26:32 The Warning Mötley Crüe Added Themselves
27:44 Nikki Sixx’s Marketing Genius
28:24 Was Vince Neil Trapped by His Image?
29:26 Vince Neil’s Two Very Different Sides
30:41 When Rock Stars Jumped Into the Crowd
31:29 Mötley Crüe’s History With the Law
32:04 Three Alcohol-Related Crashes
32:45 The Message on Theatre of Pain
34:04 Fame, Money, Drugs, and Consequences
35:19 The Lawsuits Facing Vince Neil
36:19 “A Roller Coaster 24 Hours a Day”
36:55 Mötley Crüe’s Changing Image
38:02 Join Audiomover in Thailand
What do you remember about this period? Did the tragedy change the way you viewed Vince Neil or Mötley Crüe?
For information about joining the Audiomover community in Thailand, email [email protected].