AutoExpert

AutoExpert

By John CadoganLeisureAutomotive
Download on the App Store

All AutoExpert episodes

  • The truth about servicing automatic transmissions (even the sealed ones)

    You need to service auto transmissions - even the sealed ones. This report is the how, why and when - for ordinary and severe applications, as well as whether you need to fit an aftermarket cooler or not.  

    Save thousands on any new car (Australia-only): https://autoexpert.com.au/contact

    AutoExpert discount roadside assistance package: https://247roadservices.com.au/autoexpert/

    Did you like this report? You can help support the channel, securely via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=DSL9A3MWEMNBW&source=url

    This report answers the following question, from a dude named Barry:  

    "I really enjoy your videos as they give us non experts factual information that's difficult to get from other sources that are often less reliable. I'd like to get some facts from you about what are harmful temperatures of the oil in automatic transmissions. I drive a 2.8l Prado with auto transmission & occasionally tow a camper trailer weighing 1.6 tonnes. Connected to the OBD2 port in the Prado is a ScanGauge2 that allows me to see the readings from many of the sensors on the car. I've been particularly interested in the  readout of the transmission temperature.  

    "Some time ago you published a video that recommended using auto setting to tow & not to use the transmission as a "manual". Normally when towing I'd set the transmission into the 1:1 ratio 4th gear & tow in that mode. After watching your video, on the next camping trip to western Qld I put the Prado into Drive to see what, if any, difference it made. It did drive a little differently & shifted gears a lot more as it moved between the 5th & 6th overdrive gears to 4th gear or lower depending on the terrain. The transmission temperature in this auto mode was regularly in the range of high 90 to over 100 deg C with the ambient temperature in the mid to high 20's.  

    "Next I went back to my default towing mode with the transmission set to 4th as the highest gear ratio used. There were less gear changes (no surprises there) but the transmission temperatures were definitely lower, mostly in the 80's & occasionally into the low 90's. Ambient temperatures were the same as before. The downside was that the fuel consumption was slightly higher. At a service after that trip I got my mechanic to change the transmission oil as on inspection it appeared much darker than normal. I'm not sure whether this was  a result of the way it was driven on this trip or not.  

    "My understanding is that the optimum temperature for longevity of an auto transmission is somewhere in the 80 deg range & anything higher was likely to cause long term damage if the oil wasn't changed regularly (the Prado service schedule is for an oil change each 40,000 kms or 2 yrs). Can you give me some guidance on whether this is correct or not & what regularly running at the types of temperatures seen in auto mode are damaging. There must be many Prados (and other makes) out there that are used for towing & driven in a set & forget fashion that could be just waiting for an expensive appointment with a service centre.  "I'd appreciate your comments on this subject."  

    Many thanks  

    Barry

    23 min
  • The extreme beer garden physics episode (total nerd)

    Save thousands on any new car (Australia-only): https://autoexpert.com.au/contact

    AutoExpert discount roadside assistance package: https://247roadservices.com.au/autoexpert/

    Did you like this report? You can help support the channel, securely via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=DSL9A3MWEMNBW&source=url

    This report is inspired by the following question from Mike Bristow:  

    Hi John, Great report and fantastic clarity. No one else goes to such lengths to explain things like this the way you do. Great job. During your video, you stated that accelerating from zero appears quick and tails off the faster you go until you can't accelerate any more. Presumably due to the physical limitations of the engine (air/petrol intake, physical properties of the engine, and ultimately air pressure etc.)  Because you appear to me to be extremely adept at explaining issues involving the more fundamental properties of science, would you please indulge me in explaining something that is kind of  linked, but nothing to do with cars - yet anyway.  Your statement re acceleration struck a chord and made me think about a lifelong issue that no one has been able to explain. The issue being the finite speed of light.  A light wave or particle (not sure if they've decided which is which yet but never mind) travels, as you know, at a bit over 670 million miles an hour and according the prophet Einstein, nothing can travel faster. Is it because there is no known force that can give it more momentum or simply something that prevents it going faster by getting in its way like the fabric of space itself, if that actually exists.  I know this is a very simplified way of looking at it but surely things should be explainable so the common man can understand.  All the common axioms that get blurted out by nerds that think they believe in relativity etc. drive me round the twist. I'm just looking for an honest, down to earth answer as to why light can't go faster than 670 million mph. Sorry to bother you with this John but if you do have the time, I'm sure your answer would make not just me but a lot of interested science guys like me very happy.  If I don't hear from you, I completely understand.  All the best, Mike.

    26 min
  • Unofficial advice from a police prosecutor on taking a traffic fine to court

    In this report: Unofficial pointers from a prosecutor in Redneckistan (which I think some people still refer to as ‘Queensland’).  

    Save thousands on any new car (Australia-only): https://autoexpert.com.au/contact

    AutoExpert discount roadside assistance package: https://247roadservices.com.au/autoexpert/

    Did you like this report? You can help support the channel, securely via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=DSL9A3MWEMNBW&source=url

    This report is inspired by the following unsolicited advice from a Queensland police prosecutor. (Name withheld to protect identity.)  

    "I prosecute Traffic offences in Queensland. The roadside conversations can help people if they’re dealing with your general duties police, not likely if you are dealing with our road policing guys.   

    "Queensland has the Penalties and Sentences Act, section 9 speaks about the sentencing guidelines and section 18, No conviction with no further punishment. No matter what the fine is, there is also the offender levy. The demerit points always flow no matter what the penalty, unless you receive the wonderful words of Not Guilty.   

    "The traffic penalties for traffic tickets in Queensland are set by Queensland Transport. We also have case law where the District Court makes reference to the amount of fine ordered by the court should be higher than the ticket amount to discourage people from contesting a ticket to get a discount.  

     "Hypothetically, if the ticket amount is $400, you contest it, go to court and decide to plead guilty, you wear the fine plus the offender levy. I say fine because once the ticket becomes a charge, you are open to the maximum penalty which for some offences is 20 penalty units or about $2800.   

    "One other thing, the prosecutor’s office is somewhat independent of the police who issue tickets. We factor in a range of considerations when deciding if we will continue with an infringement. An example of this, we have a road in Brisbane where there is a Bus jump zone. The lane is a left turn only lane, except for buses which can drive straight ahead, other vehicles must turn left. We recently had a case where a guy got a ticket for disobeying the left turn only sign. AT the time of the offence, every single lane on that road was bumper to bumper so no real gain to be in that lane, so in this instance we discontinued the proceeding.      

    Hope this makes sense."

    14 min
  • The good news about dying on the road

    An oxymoronically happy story … about dying on the road.  

    Save thousands on any new car (Australia-only): https://autoexpert.com.au/contact

    AutoExpert discount roadside assistance package: https://247roadservices.com.au/autoexpert/

    Did you like this report? You can help support the channel, securely via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=DSL9A3MWEMNBW&source=url

    When I was six, in 1970, road death was out of control in this country. In total, 3798 people died on the roads. Today, the annual death toll is just over 1100.  A bit less than five million vehicles were on the road in 1970. About 20 million today, in Shitsville. Population in 1970: 12.5 million. Today, double that. Four times the vehicles and twice the people - but significantly less than one third of the death. If that’s not the happiest story ever, I don’t know what is.  In 1970, nearly eight people died for every 10,000 registered vehicles. Today it’s well below 1 death for every 10,000 vehicles (0.56 in 2018). According to the Feds.  In 1970, 30-ish people died on the road for every 100,000 people in the nation. In 2018, it was about 4.5. Essentially, in real terms, the roads are between seven and 14 times safer, depending on how you decide to measure such a thing.  In 2018, we drove, collectively 227 billion kilometres. That’s 5.7 million laps of the planet. 57 million transcontinental runs from Steep Point to Cape Byron. It’s 22 return trips to Pluto, which isn’t even a planet any more - so, why bother going even once?  And, in all this driving, 1100 people died. Every death is a tragedy, certainly - I’m not suggesting those lives don’t matter. They do. There’s a burden on each of us, every time you put your hands on the wheel to act responsibly and avoid this kind of thing. It’s, like, the primary responsibility of driving.   To me, however, those 1100 deaths are tantamount to a cost of enjoying all that mobility, in an imperfect world. I’m sure many of those deaths were preventable, and I’m sure we can work on it, but it’s not out of control. It’s not even disproportionate.  If you compare those 1100 road deaths to accidental falls, which killed 3300 people in 2019, it kinda puts it in perspective. (Admittedly, the average age of the deceased there was 87.4, so that’s pretty much age-related, it seems.) Poisonous or noxious substances killed 1357 Australians in 2019 - about 200 more than on the road.  The big one for the grim reaper is what the statisticians call ‘intentional self harm. In total, this claimed 3317 Australians in 2019. Three times higher than the road toll.   (I know what a touchy subject this is. Suicide is absolutely not a solution to a problem. If this is confronting to you - call Lifeline in Australia on 13 11 14.) The median age for the deceased here: 43.9 - so, a lot of life-years lost to self-harm. Just like the road toll, and also skewed significantly towards males in both cases. Odd similarities there.  These data - from the Australian Bureau of Statistics, from: Causes of Death, Australia.  What I always find amazing is that - without controlling for risk factors specifically - the risk of dying from self harm is three times higher than that of dying on the road. That does my head in. Then I look at the resources marshalled at the prevention of road trauma versus the prevention of suicide, and I wonder about society’s priorities there.  (I’m not suggesting we take resources away from preventing road trauma - I’m suggesting we pay attention to other salient causes of preventable, premature death, to the overall betterment of society.)

    16 min
  • Putting kids in the front seat of cars...

    Perhaps you are going to strap your young kid in the front seat of your ute. This is legal (in a single cab, as far as I know) - but is it safe?  

    Save thousands on any new car (Australia-only): https://autoexpert.com.au/contact

    AutoExpert discount roadside assistance package: https://247roadservices.com.au/autoexpert/

    Did you like this report? You can help support the channel, securely via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=DSL9A3MWEMNBW&source=url

    QUESTION:

    "My son is 6 and has really taken to fishing and camping. I only have a cab-chassis Hilux, and have noticed that the RTA allows a child in the front passenger side, on a booster seat... What are your thoughts on this?" - Jamie Fitzgerald

    In a perfect world, only adult-sized humans would ever sit in a front seat. Airbag deployment choreography is kinda precise, and brutal.   Airbags deploy at brutal speed and their spatial movement assumes an adult human will be doing the interacting. Average six-year-olds are only 1-1.2 metres tall - and this dimensional deficit is a serious spanner in the works, vis-a-vis airbag interaction, which could lead to a poor outcome in a crash…  .And, Jamie here is probably driving a long way to go camping, fishing, get sunburned and find a death adder in his sleeping bag. All the fun outdoors stuff. And he’s probably driving at high speeds, too, like highway speeds, and also on imperfect roads - all of which amps up the risk of a high-mechanism collision.  On the flipside, modern Hiluxes are quite safe. And driving’s really not that dangerous. In the 12 months to September 2020, just 1107 people died on the roads - that’s 4.9 per cent down on the same period last year, and 9.1 per cent down for deaths over the past six months (thanks very much, COVID-19).  Injury rates on the road: roughly 40 to one. In other words, roughly 40 hospitalisations for every death, and about half those injuries are notionally ‘serious’ - meaning (in statistical terms) requiring more than one day in hospital. And, obviously some (I don’t have the data) result in lifelong disability - brain injuries and that kind of thing.  In a population of nearly 25 million, it’s hardly as if road trauma is out of control. Despite what the cops and the regulators and the media would have you believe, driving is actually quite safe. Especially if you do it responsibly and capably. But there’s never been a benign transport system - and there never will be.  Only 27 people aged from newborn to 16 died on the roads in the past six months, and they weren’t all in cars. Some would have been pedestrians. Being in a car is not all that dangerous for children - especially if your parents are responsible drivers who put you in the correct restraint.  If you drive responsibly, conservatively, and even better, if you get advanced driver training, and if you’re diligently monitoring the environment for hazards, such as approaching dickheads, and formulating numerous ‘plan Bs’ - and not fatigued, or texting, or whatever - then you'll have a nice time camping with your young son, with very little elevation of tangible risk.  In fact, when you think about all the things that can go wrong camping - all the poisonous reptiles and spiders, the blue-ringed octopus at the beach, the shark attacks, the falling out of a tree or down a cliff, the drowning … the trip there and back is likely to be the safest part of the whole Technicolor camping montage.

    14 min
  • Epic Automotive Livestream Q&A - answering your questions live (episode 3)

    Join me live on YouTube every Thursday evening at 8:30pm (Sydney time) where I answer your questions live for 1hr+.

    You bring the questions/comments (ask me anything) and I'll do my best to answer them.

    If that time's not convenient for you (wherever you re in the world) then the stream is replayable on my YouTube Channel, and the audio podcast is of course available here.

    Save thousands on any new car (Australia-only): https://autoexpert.com.au/contact

    AutoExpert discount roadside assistance package: https://247roadservices.com.au/autoexpert/

    Did you like this report? You can help support the channel, securely via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=DSL9A3MWEMNBW&source=url

    1 hr 13 min
  • Should I buy a hybrid car? (And, if so, which one?)

    In this report: You love the idea of a hybrid - but do you really need one?  

    Save thousands on any new car (Australia-only): https://autoexpert.com.au/contact

    AutoExpert discount roadside assistance package: https://247roadservices.com.au/autoexpert/

    Did you like this report? You can help support the channel, securely via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=DSL9A3MWEMNBW&source=url

    This report addresses the following question:

    "I’m looking at taking a step into the hybrid market.

    "I am certainly not ready to make the leap into an EV, so the HEV/PHEV option seems to be a reasonable stepping stone. Though the PHEV seem to be several $ks more expensive (and more limited in availability)."

    [This is because the batteries and electrical motors are bigger - they do more work. Batteries are expensive.]

    "I have a trade in - a 2010 Mitsubishi Outlander XLS, 60k odometer. A car I inherited from my father earlier this year. It is too big for my needs."

    [Trade-in: Probably $6500; Private sale: $8500]

    "I am looking at a net changeover of up to $40k(ish).

    "I have had a test drive in a Toyota Corolla Hatch ZR Hybrid - it's nothing fancy, a bit small in the back seat (that I wouldn't use often), but will do the job.

    "I'm not sure the sedan model has a ZR Hybrid option available in Aust (I haven't got back to the dealer to confirm yet)?"

    [Hatch-only, I think]

    "And the Hyundai Ionic that again would do the job, but didn't ring any bells for me (felt heavier, and the back window will need to get used to!)."

    "Pricing there, about $40,400 (hybrid) and $47k (plug-in hybrid).

    "Appreciate if you can point me in the direction of other vehicles that might suit the price range that I should consider (and recommendations). There don't seem to be many??!!"

    [Key question: Why do you actually want a hybrid?]

    "Once I have picked what I want, I expect to get the deed done through you guys :) Car dealers certainly are not there to be on my side!!

    "I'm sure you'll have other questions, and may want to fill me in on what I need to do to progress arrangements.

    "Hope to hear from you soon."

    Regards,

    Brian

    1 hr 6 min
  • How to get out of a (relatively minor) traffic fine (in Australia)

    In this report: How to get out of a (relatively minor) traffic fine (in Australia).

    I deal with interacting with the cops at the roadside, as well as getting legal advice, and maybe even making an application under Section 10 of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999. (Section 10 essentially gives the court the power to record a conviction without penalty if the circumstances of the offence warrant it.)

    • AutoExpert discount roadside assistance package
    • Did you like this report? You can help support the channel, securely via PayPal
    • This report was inspired by the following question from Richie Shearer:

      I’ve owned a 2016 St np300 for just over 4 yrs. A few months ago I was pulled over and booked for the towbar obstructing my numberplate. It is a genuine fitted Nissan towbar. It was fitted to the vehicle when I bought it brand-new.

      The police did not care that it was a genuine fitted object. I have not paid the fine. I’ve had to go to court where it has been put off to 15 January because I pleaded not guilty. I believe that it is Nissan’s responsibility to notify their customers if the vehicle doesn’t completely meet Australian design rules. I have emailed Nissan on this issue and they are pretty much just fob me off. Is it not the responsibility of companies selling products or vehicles to notify their customers or is it up to the individuals to make sure a brand-new vehicle is ADR compliant.

      Any advice would be much appreciated. The fine was $457 and three demerit points. I’m representing myself In the matter to save money. Thanks John - massive fan of the YouTube channel.” - Richie Shearer

      37 min
    • Toyota Landcruiser Troopy fuel consumption (why it's so bad)

      How can two engines have similar power & torque but hugely different fuel consumption? Are bigger (capacity) engines intrinsically thirstier? Details next.  

      Save thousands on any new car (Australia-only): https://autoexpert.com.au/contact

      AutoExpert discount roadside assistance package: https://247roadservices.com.au/autoexpert/

      Did you like this report? You can help support the channel, securely via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=DSL9A3MWEMNBW&source=url

      Here’s a question from a dude named Dave, concerning the King (of mediocrity) - Toyota.   

      "I'm comparing a Landcruiser Troopie with a new Prado. The Troopie has a V8 with 151kW & 430Nm. The Prado has an inline four-cylinder with 150kW & 500Nm. (Approximately the same power/torque.) But the Troopy uses about 15L/100 compared to the Prado at 10L/100 (both ballpark real world figures, not the ADR fantasies).   "If they output about the same power, where is the big difference in fuel economy coming from?  The weight of each car?  Aerodynamics?  Gearing?  Feeding four extra cylinders, with extra engine internal friction?  "If they were the same weight, and had the same Cd value, would they accelerate/overtake the same and have the same fuel usage, even though one is V8 and one an I4?" - David Deere  

      The data:  

      Diesel = 45 kJ/g (and if you do that once a second = 45kW) So, 2.2g/sec = 100kW (of potential heat energy) Combustion efficiency = 40% = 40kW @ crankshaft 15% loss via transmission = 34kW @ wheels  Prado: 2.755cc 6sp (5th = 0.687:1, 6th = 0.580:1, diff = 3.91:1) 265/65R17 (Circ. = 2.26m) 150kW @ 3400rpm 500Nm @ 1600-2800rpm Bore x stroke: 92.0 x 103.6mm ADR economy: 7.9 (combined, L/100km) Kerb weight: 2325 (GXL) 100km/h = 27.8m/s = 737 wheel rpm = 2883 tailshaft rpm = 1672 engine rpm (6th) = 1981 engine rpm (5th) Total swept cylinder area = 120,000 mm^2  Troopie: 5sp (5th = 0.75:1, diff = 3.91:1) 225/95R16 (Circumf = 2.62m) 4.461cc (+62% move volume) 151 @ 3400rpm 430Nm @ 1200-3200rpm  Bore x stroke: 86.0 x 96.0mm ADR economy: 10.7 (L/100km) - about 35% higher than Prado Kerb weight 2265kg 100km/h = 27.8m/s = 636 wheel rpm = 2487 tailshaft rpm = 1865 engine rpm (5th) = 11.5% higher than Prado in 6th Total swept cylinder area = 207,000 mm^2  = 72.5% more area than Prado ** but at 100km/h rpms are also 11.5% higher, so total cylinder wall friction = 81% higher (ballpark)  

      ** Hyundai/Kia 2.2 @ 147 kW & 440 Nm I4 

      ** Mazda 2.2 @ 140 kW & 450 Nm I4  Plus: Troopy needs to drive twice as many valves to do the same job, pumping more oil and water, etc. (Not as volumetrically efficient, and higher pumping losses, etc.)  And the single turbo 4.5 V8 is a rubbish engine - like it’s the cheap, slutty version of the 4.5 TT, which makes 32.5% more peak power, 51% more peak torque and returns slightly better fuel economy - despite being in a platform weighing 500kg more.

      30 min
    • Why Ford will fail in Australia

      In this report: two reasons why Ford will fail in Australia

      Save thousands on any new car (Australia-only): https://autoexpert.com.au/contact

      AutoExpert discount roadside assistance package: https://247roadservices.com.au/autoexpert/

      Did you like this report? You can help support the channel, securely via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=DSL9A3MWEMNBW&source=url  

      "High performance icon to thrill Australian customers as Ford Mustang Mach 1 in manual and automatic transmissions set to debut in Australian showrooms."  I immediately thought: If this is a lottery, what’s second prize? Two of those death-trap shitboxes?  “Following the success of Mustang BULLITT and Mustang R-SPEC, we are very excited to introduce this highly capable, track ready Mustang to our Australian Mustang fans. The unique styling, which pays homage to the original model, is more than worthy of its legendary badge.” - Andrew Birkic  Andrew Birkic there - President and CEO, Ford Shitsville and Sheepshaggistan (or, as I like to call him: ‘Big Birk’.)  What is this “success” to which you allude, dude?  Let me paint the Mustang sales picture for you, shall I, lest you erroneously believe this vehicle is actually a success, as alleged by B-squared? Mustang sales peaked in ‘Straya at about 9000 units in 2017. That was a win - no argument.  But the next year, in 2018, they fell 30 per cent. In 2019 … a further 38 per cent implosion. And this year, Mustang sales have jumped off another cliff - 36 per cent down so far. ‘On track’ (if that’s the right term) for 2900 sales by the end of 2020.  So, let me get this straight: you Ford ‘Straya dudes took one of the world’s muscle car icons, which is roughly as old as me (within months, actually) with huge cachet … and you managed to turn more than 9000 sales into less than 3000 - in four years (inclusive). Well done. ‘Result’ as they say on The Sweeney.  So - that’s corporate out-of-touchedness. Here’s strategic vulnerability.  The fact is, Ford in ‘Straya is one vehicle away from outright commercial collapse - and that vehicle is Ranger, and (to some extent) its spin-off, Everest. Everest exists only thanks to Ranger, and they roll on essentially the same architecture.   Ranger 4X4 is the big win for Big Birk, with 26,377 sales so far this year, augmented by about 1800 Ranger 4X2s and about 4000 Everests. Together these comprise 32,000 of the almost-41,000 sales Ford Shitsville has made so far this year.  It’s about 80 per cent of the business.  In other words: Endura, Escape, Fiesta, Focus, Mondeo, and Puma are all nowhere. Statistically, nobody buys them. This is the real ‘Ford ‘Straya’ story - and it’s not being reported because publishers want Ford’s advertising revenue, right up to the day Dr Kevorkian gets on the line from Dearborn.   Every non-Ranger based vehicle in the Ford inventory is costing the business money just by being there, available for sale. Homologation, parts, training - whatever. Ford would be more profitable in Shitsville without them.  I guess the Ford Transit is successful in the context of vans, with about 2300 sales so far this year: Number three, behind Hiace and iLoad. Just to be fair.  But without Ranger and its derivatives, Ford Shitsville would have slightly less commercial footprint than Chinese upstart, MG. Or, it be slightly in front of LDV (by about 2500 sales) at this point of 2020.  To me, this is huge strategic risk. ‘Vulnerability’ is a better word. It takes just one disruption for Ford’s business to collapse in Australia.

      19 min