It's August of '95, two in the morning, and Luna is sitting in a rusted-out pickup outside Mavis's Bait & Tackle on the shore of Sugar Lake. Mavis has been running the shack for forty years, selling minnows and nightcrawlers to men who never ask questions. But tonight, a man in a damp overcoat pulls up in a station wagon with no plates, asking for a dozen shiners and a pack of smokes. He pays with a wet twenty-dollar bill that leaves a dark smear on the counter. And when he leaves, he doesn't head toward the lake. He heads into the woods behind the shack. Mavis tells Luna she's seen him before — every year, same time, same ask. And every year, something goes wrong on the water. A story about the things that surface in the shallows, the bargains made in the dark, and what happens when you sell bait to something that isn't fishing.