You're only a rookie once...unless you get a new gimmick. So I guess you can be a rookie twice then...unless you get another new gimmick....anyway, best first year as a new player or with a new gimmick, the Tate's show up with their favorite names.

12 favorites, probably another 10-20 honorable mentions, and not much of a shock as a the 'Taters reach their first unanimous number 1 in their "best of" format.

A tournament featuring a lot of cities you'd expect, and a few that you don't. Plus some crazy side matchups like Tony Schiavone vs Mike Adamle and Jackets vs Robes and Nu Naytch vs Honky Tonk Gotch!

Welp, it started out as 18 Good People/Nice Guys, but by the end of the episode almost no one is redeemable. Don't meet your heroes, or even talk about them for that matter.

Their specific Pay-Per-View events they they can remember being at, or watching, or remember hearing about!

Not just theme songs, not just wrestlers in bands, not just bands about wrestling, not just wrestling about bands, not just bands in the ring. Ok, I'm done.

Some were expected, some were shocking, some broke hearts. Plus,  the final few outs of a Phillies NLDS loss!

David Arquette AAANNNND Oliver Platt in the same movie?!?!?! The answer is YES.

...though the episode should be called The Worst Humans, because barring a few examples, there's a lot of god-awful people in this one.

This one got heated at points, some in agreement and some in disagreement. But mostly, Tim was difficult. Enjoy!