Backyard SmokeMaster BBQ

BBQ Gone Wrong, Epic Pitmaster Fails, and How to Fix Them

Listen Later

Even the best backyard pitmasters burn a brisket now and then. Whether it’s overcooked beef ribs, underdone chicken, a surprise fireball from your grill lid—or a gear malfunction right in the middle of a long cook—we’ve all been there.

In this episode of the Backyard SmokeMaster BBQ Podcast, we shared some real-life fails (including my own), plus tips for how to bounce back and barbecue smarter next time.

1. The Great Beef Rib Fail

My first attempt at beef ribs was a disaster. I followed someone else’s recipe to the letter—ignoring feel, bark, and instinct—and ended up with scorched, tough ribs that nobody wanted to eat…except my sister-in-law, who’s clearly a saint.

Lesson learned:

Don’t cook by temperature alone. Learn to trust your senses: bark texture, probe feel, and aroma. Recipes are a guide, but every smoker is different.

2. Undercooked Chicken Happens

Joe from Q Bellies BBQ shared a story about serving chicken to a neighbor, only to realize it was undercooked. It happens, even to pros.

Fix it tip:

Use a reliable instant-read thermometer and aim for 165°F in the thickest part of the chicken. Cook at a higher heat (around 350°F) and always dry the skin beforehand if you want it to crisp up.

3. Over-Salted Ribs & Rub Mistakes

Layering commercial rubs sounds great until you realize you’ve basically made a salt lick.

How to avoid it:

  • Watch the ingredients list—salt is often listed first.
  • Go light if you’re stacking rubs.
  • Consider building your own rubs so you can control heat and salt levels.
    • 4. Firebox Blowback

    Opening a blazing-hot grill too fast can create a mini fireball—ask me how I know. My arm hair didn’t survive.

    Pro move:

    Always burp your grill when it’s running hot—crack the lid slightly first to let out some heat before fully opening it.

    5. When Equipment Lets You Down

    Pellet smoker flame-outs. Wireless thermometer disconnects. Connectivity issues mid-cook. Been there, done that.

    Must-haves:

    • A backup instant-read thermometer
    • A basic charcoal or stick burner that doesn’t rely on electricity
    • Heat-resistant gloves for safety
    • And a fire extinguisher, especially if you’re cooking on a wooden deck
      • 6. The Wind (or Weather) Wrecks It All

      Cold or rain might slow you down, but wind is what really wreaks havoc. It can spike or kill temps fast.

      How to beat it:

      • Rotate your grill away from wind direction
      • Use a windbreak or shield
      • Insulated blankets can help on some models
      • For offset smokers, keep your fire small and steady and adjust your intake/damper carefully
        • Final Thoughts: Fail Forward

        The real takeaway from every BBQ fail is growth. Learn your equipment. Understand your fuel. Trust your senses. And never be afraid to share your story—because odds are, another pitmaster has made the same mistake.

        https://youtube.com/live/9ppLCYpDHM0
        👥 Want to Level Up Your BBQ Game?

        Join the Backyard SmokeMaster Society, where we talk gear, recipes, fire management, and all things low & slow. The community’s full of helpful pitmasters who’ve been through every kind of BBQ fail—and come out better for it.

        🎧 Listen to the full episode on:

        Apple Podcasts,

        Spotify,

        Amazon Music

        ...more
        View all episodesView all episodes
        Download on the App Store
        Backyard SmokeMaster BBQBy Kenyatta T. Robinson