Behind The Shelf

Behind The Shelf

Download on the App Store

All Behind The Shelf episodes

  • Why Great Recipes Fall Apart Between the Stove and the Shelf, with Travis Zissu
    What happens to a great product between the stove and the shelf? For many founders, that's exactly where it quietly falls apart.

    In this episode of Behind the Shelf, Keren Novack sits down with Travis Zissu, Founder of Scale Food Labs, to unpack what he calls the messy middle: the gap between a delicious idea and a product that can be made consistently, safely, and at scale. Travis shares the clearest red flag he sees in founders who don't yet have a real product or process, walks through a flavored mayo brand that had to pull tens of thousands of units off shelves after it started turning brown, and explains why chasing the cheapest contract manufacturer almost always costs more in the end. They also dig into his ninety percent rule for knowing when to launch, the hidden costs founders underestimate before going to market, and why natural flavors get blamed for problems they don't actually cause.


    What you will learn:

    •  The clearest red flag Travis sees when a founder has an idea but not a real product or process
    • Why a delicious stovetop recipe can fall apart the moment it meets a co-manufacturer's minimum order quantity
    •  How swapping fresh ingredients for dry or powdered versions can quietly compromise shelf life
    •   Why chasing the cheapest contract manufacturer at the start often costs founders more in the long run
    •  What Travis's ninety percent rule means for knowing when a product is ready to launch
    • Why the true cost of bringing a product to market goes far beyond the recipe itself


    Travis Zissu is the Founder of Scale Food Labs, an FDA-certified pilot production facility based in Golden, Colorado, that helps food and beverage brands navigate what he calls the messy middle between a bench-top idea and full-scale manufacturing. A Culinary Institute of America graduate with a background in food science, Travis has worked with everyone from Fortune 100 companies to early-stage founders, translating recipes and product concepts into processes that can be made consistently, safely, and profitably at scale. Today, he helps brands avoid the costly mistakes that can sink a promising product before it ever earns its place on the shelf.

    Episode Resources:
    • Travis Zissu on LinkedIn
    • Scale Food Labs Website
    • Keren Novack on LinkedIn
    • Curion Insights Website
    • Curion Webinars and Podcasts
    • Behind the Shelf on Apple Podcasts
    • Behind the Shelf on Spotify
    • Behind the Shelf on YouTube



    Episode Highlights:

    • [07:50] The Clearest Red Flag
    Travis says the biggest warning sign isn't a bad recipe, it's a founder who says they made it on the stove and it comes out great sometimes and not other times. To Travis, that means there's no real product and no real process yet, just a validated idea. Before scaling anything, his team digs into what actually makes the ingredients and the process special, then works out how to standardize that from one batch to a hundred thousand.

    • [08:42] The Mayo That Turned Brown
    A chef-founder built a flavored mayo with fresh ingredients that tasted great in small batches. When he scaled with a contract manufacturer, he was locked into a 50,000-unit minimum and had to swap nearly every fresh ingredient for dry or powdered versions. The taste suffered, and the product ultimately oxidized and turned brown on shelves, forcing stores to pull it and the founder to throw out tens of thousands of units. Travis's team later rebuilt the product from its value proposition rather than its ingredient list, replacing egg with a tapioca-starch base so it could be cooked, hit the same texture and flavor goals, and scale far more easily.

    • [20:14] Don't Cheap Out On Your First Co-Man
    Founders often default to the cheapest contract manufacturer they can find, but Travis says that's rarely where the savings show up. He's seen co-mans bring on clients before they even have the right equipment, run early batches with no real experience on that equipment, and produce inconsistent, sometimes unsafe product as a result. He advises founders to expect their first production run to cost more than they'd like, in exchange for a manufacturing partner with real experience catching failure points early.

    • [24:04] The 90% Rule
    Travis's advice for founders on the edge of launching: if a product is ninety percent there, launch it. He's watched founders hold back genuinely great products chasing the last ten percent, only to miss out on the feedback and iteration that only comes after a real launch. Waiting for perfect, he says, often costs founders more than launching imperfect and learning fast.


    Quotes:

    1. “a lot of times we'll have people come to us and say, I've made it on the stove, and sometimes it comes out great and sometimes it doesn't... to me, that's those are massive red flags because it says you don't actually have a product. You don't actually have a process.”

    2. “our MOQ is 50,000 units, and that's what you have to make... he ended up in a place where he had to throw out forty, fifty thousand units of product pulled from all the shelves, and almost starting back as step one again.”

    3. “I have this ninety percent rule... if you're ninety percent there, just launch. Don't let that stop you... I've seen products that I thought were amazing and didn't launch because it wasn't just quite there. And I feel so bad for the founders 'cause you learn so much after launch.”

    4. “The repeat purchase will come every single time from meeting or exceeding consumer expectations. It doesn't matter how amazing the branding is... If it doesn't taste good, you're never gonna buy it again, period.”

    33 min
  • How Simon Solis-Cohen Is Rethinking the Energy Drink Category at Huxley
    What if the key to disrupting the energy drink category isn't more caffeine or bolder flavors, but a return to real ingredients and genuine refreshment? Simon Solis-Cohen saw an opportunity to challenge the category's conventions and build something different with Huxley.


    In this episode of Behind the Shelf, Keren Novack sits down with Simon Solis-Cohen, Founder of Huxley, to explore how his background in food and wine shaped his approach to product development, why moderate caffeine and real fruit juice offer a point of difference, and how repositioning Huxley as an "energy refresher" is opening doors to new consumers. 


    Simon shares how DTC and Amazon data revealed an unexpected customer base spanning millennials and older generations, challenging assumptions about who buys energy drinks. They also discuss the realities of retail buying cycles, why consumer feedback needs careful interpretation, and how founders can balance data with instinct. Their conversation offers valuable lessons in finding white space in crowded markets, building a differentiated CPG brand, and recognizing that how a product is positioned can matter as much as the product itself.


    What you will learn:
    • Why the "grown, not made" philosophy applies directly to building an F&B brand 
    • How to identify white space in a crowded category 
    • Why reframing your product's category label can remove stigma and unlock new customer segments
    • How to interpret negative consumer feedback 
    • Why DTC and Amazon data can reveal surprising core customers
    • The reality of retail buying cycles
    • How to decide when to trust founder instinct over consumer data


    Simon Solis-Cohen
    is the Founder of Huxley, an energy refresher brand that reimagines the beverage category through real fruit juice, moderate caffeine, and intentional ingredient curation. With a background spanning the Culinary Institute of America, Michelin-starred kitchens, and Napa Valley wineries, Solis-Cohen brings a refined approach to functional beverages that prioritizes taste and consumer experience over artificial additives.  

    Episode Resources:
    • Simon Solis-Cohen on LinkedIn
    • Huxley Energy Refresher Website
    • Keren Novack on LinkedIn
    • Curion Insights Website
    • Curion Webinars and Podcasts  
    • Behind the Shelf on Apple Podcasts
    • Behind the Shelf on Spotify
    • Behind the Shelf on YouTube


    Episode Highlights:

    • [03:32] Start with Great Ingredients, Not Clever Marketing

    Simon explains how winemaking shaped his product philosophy: great products begin with great ingredients. Rather than relying on artificial flavors and clever branding to compensate for shortcomings, Huxley prioritizes real ingredients, including strawberry juice as its second ingredient after water. His approach offers founders a simple lesson: build product quality into the formulation from the start, before investing in packaging or promotion.


    • [05:03] Find Your Edge by Breaking Category Conventions

    Simon chose not to compete with energy drink giants on caffeine intensity or bold artificial flavors. Instead, Huxley offers 90mg of caffeine and light, fruity refreshment, creating an experience closer to a champagne cocktail than a traditional energy drink. His strategy shows founders how challenging established category conventions can reveal untapped opportunities and create meaningful differentiation in crowded markets.


    • [13:30] When Negative Feedback Reflects Consumer Conditioning

    When a customer said Huxley's strawberry flavor didn't taste like real strawberries, Simon saw an opportunity to understand consumer expectations. Years of exposure to artificial flavors can shape perceptions of what fruit should taste like. He explains why founders must distinguish genuine product flaws from conditioned preferences, allowing them to respond constructively to feedback without abandoning their original product philosophy.


    • [17:28] Change Your Category Label, Change Who Buys

    Simon repositioned Huxley from an energy drink to an energy refresher without changing its ingredients. The shift helped distance the brand from associations with artificial ingredients, excessive caffeine, and jitters. By aligning with language gaining traction across foodservice brands, Huxley could communicate its value more effectively. Simon's experience shows how category positioning can reshape consumer perceptions and attract previously overlooked buyers.


    • [21:00] Let Purchase Data Reveal Your Real Customer

    Simon initially expected Huxley to appeal primarily to Gen Z, but Amazon and direct-to-consumer data revealed a different picture. Its strongest customer segment was millennials aged 35-45, alongside baby boomers and grandparents. These findings challenged his original assumptions and highlighted the appeal of ingredient transparency. Simon explains why founders should use actual purchasing behavior, conversion, and repeat purchases to refine their target audience.


    • [25:34] Retail Buyers Can Reject You for the Wrong Reasons

    Simon explains why retail selling requires persistence: founders may get just one meaningful opportunity each year to pitch a retailer. Even compelling data cannot overcome every buyer's personal preferences or familiarity with established products. Rejection isn't always evidence of weak product-market fit. Simon encourages founders to remain data-driven, recognize which feedback is actionable, and refine their positioning while preparing for the next buying cycle.


    Quotes:
    1. "At the end of the day, if it doesn't taste good, people don't come back." - Simon Solis-Cohen
    2. "Great wines are grown; they're not made. If you start with really poor quality grapes, you're going to end up with a bad wine no matter what you do." - Simon Solis-Cohen
    3. "There's something wrong with a drink that says mango on the front of the can but has no mango in the ingredient list." - Simon Solis-Cohen
    4. "We are literally the only energy drink I know of that actually uses real strawberry juice; it's 10% strawberry juice." - Simon Solis-Cohen
    32 min
  • From Idea to Aisle: Why Great Products Never Make It to Shelf | Monte Ammons
    Why do 90% of new products fail? Liquid Sherpas’ Monte Ammons shares CPG product launch, consumer insights, and beverage industry strategies.


    In this episode of Behind the Shelf, Keren Novack speaks with Monte Ammons, Founder and President of Liquid Sherpas, about why most new products fail long before they reach consumers. Drawing on decades in the beverage industry, Monte explains how scalability, consumer insights, and operational discipline determine whether a product becomes a category winner or costly shelf clutter.

    He shares why founders should validate sourcing, manufacturing, and regulatory realities before investing heavily in development, and how cross-functional collaboration prevents critical insights from getting lost. Monte also explores the importance of defining nonnegotiables, questioning untapped market opportunities, and continuously optimizing products after launch. This conversation offers a practical blueprint for product leaders looking to build brands that don't just launch successfully, but endure across changing markets over time. 

    What you will learn:
    • Why "scalability" isn't optional
    • How to build the "blueprint" before grabbing the first hammer
    • The hidden trap of consumer insights getting lost in translation between teams
    • Why asking "why isn't this in the market?" is smarter than celebrating that it isn't
    • How to identify and protect your nonnegotiables without sacrificing 
    • Why staying on shelf is harder than getting there


    Monte Ammons
    is the Founder and President of Liquid Sherpas and a beverage industry veteran with more than 30 years of experience helping brands move from concept to category leadership. His career spans restaurant chains, global companies like Coca-Cola, ingredient suppliers, and high-growth startups. Monte specializes in product development, commercialization, sales, marketing, and operations, helping founders build scalable businesses. He also mentors entrepreneurs through various programs, empowering the next generation of food and beverage innovators to turn ambitious ideas into enduring brands.

    Episode Resources:
    • Monte Ammons on LinkedIn
    • Liquid Sherpas Website
    • Keren Novack on LinkedIn
    • Curion Insights Website
    • Curion Webinars and Podcasts  
    • Behind the Shelf on Apple Podcasts
    • Behind the Shelf on Spotify
    • Behind the Shelf on YouTube


    Episode Highlights:

    • [05:29] Why Scalability Matters More Than Great Product Ideas

    Monte explains that most new products fail not because the idea is bad, but because it can't be produced consistently at scale. Founders often focus on taste and novelty while overlooking manufacturing realities. If consumers have an inconsistent experience between purchases, trust disappears quickly. Successful brands prioritize repeatability, cost efficiency, and operational discipline from the very beginning.


    • [06:05] Build the Blueprint Before Building the Product
    Monte compares product development to building a house: without a blueprint, failure is inevitable. Teams should validate sourcing, regulations, shelf life, and operational feasibility before creating a product. Skipping this stage leads to costly delays and rework. The brands that succeed are those that establish strong cross-functional alignment before moving into development.


    • [11:18] Stop Consumer Insights From Getting Lost Across Teams

    Monte shares how valuable consumer insights often get diluted as they move between departments. The answer is bringing marketing, operations, finance, supply chain, and regulatory teams together early. Cross-functional collaboration helps teams protect what matters most to consumers while finding practical ways to deliver products that can succeed at scale and remain competitive.


    • [17:10] Ask Why Nobody Else Has Solved the Problem Yet

    When founders claim they've discovered untapped market space, Monte encourages them to ask why it remains unoccupied. Hidden barriers often include sourcing challenges, regulatory constraints, shelf-life issues, or weak economics. Investigating these obstacles early helps teams avoid costly mistakes and uncover opportunities to build products with sustainable competitive advantages.


    • [20:56] Why Successful Founders Aren't Afraid of Tough Feedback

    Monte believes the best founders are willing to challenge their own assumptions. Rather than defending every idea, they actively seek criticism and use it to improve. This flexibility allows them to refine products before scaling. Teams that embrace honest feedback are more likely to achieve product-market fit and build brands with lasting appeal.


    • [22:35] Staying on Shelf Demands Constant Product Improvement

    Monte explains that launching a product is only the beginning. Many products disappear from shelves because of design and execution issues rather than poor marketing. Successful brands continuously evaluate formulations, operations, and customer feedback. Treating innovation as an ongoing process helps products adapt to changing consumer needs and maintain long-term relevance.


    Quotes:
    1. "You can have the greatest idea on the planet, but if you can't replicate it and get that done over and over again, it's going to fail. It doesn't matter how great it tastes one time, but really, great ideas fail if they can't scale. And that just kind of became a mantra of mine, and it started in my experience in the food service world." - Monte
    2. "Where founders and even multinationals fall into this trap is they go to what's sexy first, branding and the formulation. But it's almost like building a house: if I just start building by grabbing a hammer and some nails, it's probably not going to be something anybody wants to live in. You gotta have that architectural rendering with everything thought through before you start grabbing the first hammer or nail, or the whole thing's going to fall apart." - Monte
    3. "The development piece and the branding piece are fun. But thinking through all of the interrelated things; can I get the ingredients, can I make this profitable, can I execute this in a way that works for retail, that's hard to think through. And that's hard for people to get their heads wrapped around if they've got one singular background or lens that they look through." - Monte
    4. "Every one of those success stories is a ten to fifteen year ride. A founder, especially early on, has to be flexible and be able to call their own baby ugly because it's so rare that you come out of the gate and hit a home run. Look at Poppi; that was reinvented three times before it finally caught fire, and not just minor do-overs; it was major reworks." - Monte
    29 min
  • The Bakery Shelf Gap Nobody Else Saw: A Cookie Mix That Tastes Homemade, with Lindsay Hancock
    What if the best way to reinvent a category isn't to create something new, but to fix what's been overlooked? Lindsay Hancock saw a gap in the bakery aisle that was hiding in plain sight, and created a cookie mix designed to close it.


    In this episode of Behind the Shelf, Keren Novack sits down with Lindsay Hancock, Founder and CEO of My Better Batch, to explore how she turned years of CPG experience into a premium cookie-mix brand built around convenience without compromising on taste or ingredients. Lindsay shares how her experience scaling Creative Snacks through its acquisition by KIND shaped her approach to differentiation, why earning a place on the shelf proved easier than earning a shopper's first purchase, and how My Better Batch uses packaging, premium ingredients and even a QR-code video to improve the experience at home. They also discuss the realities of scaling through a co-manufacturing model, listening to consumers, and protecting product quality as costs and distribution grow.


    What you will learn:
    • How Lindsay spotted the gap in a category dominated by legacy brands
    • Why getting onto the shelf hasn't been My Better Batch's hardest challenge
    • How the brand engineers around kitchen mistakes
    • What Lindsay’s is staying protective of as the brand scales
    • How the co-manufacturing model changes where the investment goes
    • What consumers taught her that surprised her


    Lindsay Hancock
    is the Founder and CEO of My Better Batch, a premium cookie-mix brand created to make homemade-tasting treats more accessible for busy people. A longtime food-industry executive and former Creative Snacks leader, Lindsay built My Better Batch after recognizing a gap between convenience and the homemade experience. Today, she is helping busy families take the shortcut without compromising on taste, quality, or the joy of baking. 

    Episode Timeline:
    • 00:04 Keren shares her My Better Batch experience
    • 02:54 Lindsay explains her CPG career and experience
    • 06:11 Lindsay reveals the gap in boxed mixes
    • 09:48 My Better Batch reaches 3,500 retail locations
    • 12:31 Why earning the first purchase remains challenging
    • 13:55 Why branding matters more than manufacturing infrastructure
    • 15:19 Protecting premium ingredients despite soaring chocolate prices
    • 17:05 What positive consumer feedback taught Lindsay
    • 19:54 Why kitchen mistakes inspired QR-code instructions
    • 23:59 How packaging helps My Better Batch stand out
    • 26:03 Lindsay teases what's coming next for Better Batch
    • 26:27 Where shoppers can find My Better Batch



    Episode Resources:
    • Lindsay Hancock on LinkedIn
    • My Better Batch Website
    • Keren Novack on LinkedIn
    • Curion Insights Website
    • Curion Webinars and Podcasts  
    • Behind the Shelf on Apple Podcasts
    • Behind the Shelf on Spotify
    • Behind the Shelf on YouTube

    Episode Highlights:

    • [06:11] Find The Gap Consumers Aren’t Asking For

    Lindsay didn’t set out to create another cookie mix. After studying the baking aisle, she noticed that most innovation had focused on attributes such as gluten-free, paleo, or low sugar, while the core product experience had barely changed. My Better Batch was built around a different opportunity: give consumers the convenience of a mix without sacrificing ingredients, taste, or the feeling of something homemade.

    • [09:48] Getting On The Shelf Isn’t The Same As Getting Picked Up

    My Better Batch added roughly 3,500 retail locations in its first year, but Lindsay says distribution wasn’t the hardest part. The bigger challenge was getting shoppers to notice a new brand when they’re moving quickly through a familiar aisle. For emerging CPG brands, earning shelf space is only the beginning. The next challenge is creating enough awareness and differentiation to earn that first purchase.

    • [19:54] Design For The Way Consumers Actually Behave

    Lindsay learned that even a carefully developed product can fall short when consumers interpret instructions differently. “Softened butter” means different things to different people, and some shoppers will substitute ingredients without considering the impact. Rather than simply blaming consumers, My Better Batch was designed around the reality. A QR code on every box leads to a video showing exactly how the cookies should be made.

    • [23:59] Your Product Has To Scream From The Shelf

    Lindsay believes great taste alone won't win in a crowded category if shoppers never notice the product. That thinking shaped My Better Batch’s bag-in-a-box packaging, designed to create a larger visual presence than the standard gusseted bags used by competitors. The lesson extends beyond baking: when shelf space is scarce, packaging has to work as both product protection and a billboard.


    Quotes:
    1. “It was really important that I was able to develop a product, not only that I felt like it tasted really good and looked really good in the packaging, but also warranted a spot on the shelf.”
    2. “Our biggest challenge is not getting to the shelf. It is getting people to find us when they are walking down the aisle... How do we get people to find us and pick us up for the very first time?”
    3. “People don't follow instructions. They just don't. So while asking confident in our instructions, people don't follow them... we just can't protect against all things that could happen in someone's kitchen.”
    4. “You've got to scream on the shelf. You've got to scream to that customer who's walking past. She's not looking for you... we had to be able to take full advantage of that shelf space.” 

    28 min
  • What if Actual Vegetables Were the Whole Point? With Hailey Swartz
    What if the plant-based revolution was missing the whole point?

    On this episode of Behind the Shelf, host Keren Novack sits down with Hailey Swartz, Co-founder and Co-CEO of Actual Veggies, to unpack a contrarian approach to the plant-based category: making vegetables the hero instead of trying to make them taste like meat. Hailey shares how Actual Veggies identified a gap between consumer motivations and what the market was offering, validated its concept ahead of the trend, and protected product quality by resisting feedback that compromised its core idea. 

    The conversation also explores what really drives repeat purchases, how the brand expanded from burgers into new products without losing its identity, and the operational details that can make or break retail growth. From product innovation to shelf strategy, this episode offers a fresh perspective on building products consumers genuinely want. 

    What you will learn:
    • Why consumer motivations and product positioning must align 
    • How to validate product-market fit before the market catches up
    • The power of deliberately ignoring certain feedback
    • What actually drives repeat purchase behavior beyond novelty
    • How to expand a platform without diluting core differentiation


    Hailey Swartz
    is the Co-founder and co-CEO of Actual Veggies, a food brand reimagining the plant-based category by celebrating whole vegetables rather than mimicking meat. Drawing on her technology background, including roles at AOL and Alibaba, Hailey brings a consumer-centric, data-driven approach to food innovation. Since launching in 2020, Actual Veggies has expanded to more than 15,000 retail locations nationwide, including Whole Foods, Kroger, Sprouts, H-E-B, Albertsons, and Costco, while also reaching consumers through online retailers, restaurants, stadiums, and hotels.

    Episode Resources:
    • Hailey Swartz on LinkedIn
    • Actual Veggies Website
    • Keren Novack on LinkedIn
    • Curion Insights Website
    • Curion Webinars and Podcasts  
    • Behind the Shelf on Apple Podcasts
    • Behind the Shelf on Spotify
    • Behind the Shelf on YouTube


    Episode Highlights:

    • [03:57] Find The Consumer Need Your Category Is Missing

    Hailey identified a major disconnect in plant-based food: consumers were choosing these products for health reasons, while much of the category focused on highly processed meat alternatives. Actual Veggies took the opposite approach, making recognizable vegetables the hero. The lesson for CPG leaders is simple: understand why consumers are entering a category before deciding what your product should look like. Aligning ingredients, positioning, and messaging with that motivation can create meaningful differentiation.


    • [08:48] Know What Drives Trial, and What Drives Repeat Purchases

    Hailey explains that distinctive appearance and taste helped Actual Veggies earn its first purchase, but clean ingredients, convenience, and the feeling customers experienced afterward drove repeat purchases. The distinction is crucial for brands that focus heavily on generating trial while overlooking loyalty. Marketing can attract attention, but functional benefits create habits. Understanding what happens after purchase can help leaders prioritize product improvements and customer experiences that turn initial curiosity into lasting demand.


    • [09:48] Protect Product Integrity With One Simple Question

    Hailey used a straightforward filter when making product decisions: “Would I want to eat this?” That conviction helped her reject cheaper fillers, synthetic ingredients, and shortcuts that could have weakened Actual Veggies’ differentiation. For CPG leaders, the lesson is to establish clear principles before external pressures arrive. When retailer feedback, margins, or trends push toward compromise, a strong product standard can keep decisions grounded in the reason customers trusted the brand.


    • [11:36] Scale The Brand By Solving The Same Problem Differently

    Actual Veggies expanded beyond burgers because Hailey recognized a broader consumer need: people wanted an easy, enjoyable way to eat more vegetables. That insight created a platform for products including fries and dinosaur nuggets without losing the brand’s identity. The lesson for senior marketing leaders is to expand around an underlying consumer problem rather than simply adding adjacent products. When every new SKU reinforces the same core promise, growth strengthens the brand instead of fragmenting it.


    • [17:59] Build Loyalty Through Product Experience, Not Just Branding

    Hailey argues that product experience is the strongest predictor of long-term success. Branding can generate awareness and encourage a first purchase, but a product that delivers on its promise is what creates loyalty and repeat behavior. For CPG leaders, this means separating awareness metrics from retention metrics. If consumers know your product but do not return, more advertising may not solve the problem. Improving taste, convenience, quality, and satisfaction may be the real growth lever.


    • [19:16] Master The Retail Details That Get Products On Shelves

    Hailey highlights the operational details consumers rarely notice but retailers care deeply about, including package dimensions, pricing, shelf fit, and logistics. A great product can still struggle if it does not work within a retailer’s physical and commercial constraints. Actual Veggies’ expansion into more than 15,000 locations demonstrates the importance of operational discipline alongside product innovation. For emerging CPG brands, understanding retailer requirements early can determine whether a product simply gets distribution or actually reaches consumers.


    Quotes:
    1. "We did this consumer research, and we showed this mom a picture of the ingredients in an Impossible Burger. She didn't even read that how processed the product was. It was just like the fact that they are being told to feed their kids plant based, that was all that mattered."
    2. "It's a good product, and it's clean ingredients. There's something about the convenience aspect of it as well, and it's just a quick meal that's both filling, tastes good, healthy for you, and easy to make. The feeling good after eating it, I think, just keeps bringing people back to it."
    3. "We really stuck to only using whole and real ingredients. We got feedback that sometimes a certain filler would make our product taste better or cheaper, but it was really important to us to stick to ingredients that we would wanna eat."
    4. "Consumers were just excited about a way to get veggies in easily. Everything that we've built now is really about fun and delicious ways to do that. We just launched our new dino nuggets for kids, sweet potato, cauliflower, and broccoli, all about making kids excited about eating veggies."
    21 min
  • The Power of the Two-Second Habit with Jessica Hamel on Making Nutrition Effortless
    What if the strongest innovation in food isn’t about making bigger promises, but making healthy choices easier? 

    In this episode of Behind the Shelf, Keren Novack sits down with Jessica Hamel, founder of PlantChi, to explore how “seasonings with benefits” can bring nutrition into everyday routines without complexity, hype, or exaggerated claims. Jessica shares why she resisted adding salt and sugar despite outside pressure, how a simple two-second microhabit can drive lasting consumer adoption, and why product experience ultimately matters more than clever branding. 

    They also discuss the gap between functional claims and genuine efficacy, the importance of consumer education, and why PlantChi is taking a “narrow and deep” approach to growth. It’s a candid conversation about simplicity, trust, and building brands that earn repeat purchases. 

    What you will learn:
    • Why "seasonings with benefits" beats "superfood blends" 
    • The courage to say no to what works against your values
    • How to build habits through effortlessness, not disruption
    • The gap between functional claims and actual efficacy
    • Product experience outlasts branding in predicting long-term success
    • The "narrow and deep" strategy wins over expansion at scale


    Jessica Hamel
    is a curious, results-driven marketing leader and founder with more than 15 years of experience developing innovative strategies, optimizing digital investments, and using data-driven insights to build brands. As founder of PlantChi, a seed-based seasoning line designed to make nutrition effortless and accessible, she brings together her branding expertise and CPG experience to rethink how consumers approach everyday nutrition. A former CPG startup founder, Jessica combines strategic clarity, creativity, and analytics to build authentic brands that prioritize lasting impact over trend-chasing. 

    Episode Resources:
    • Jessica Hamel on LinkedIn
    • PlantChi Website
    • PlantChi on Instagram
    • Keren Novack on LinkedIn
    • Curion Insights Website
    • Curion Webinars and Podcasts  
    • Behind the Shelf on Apple Podcasts
    • Behind the Shelf on Spotify
    • Behind the Shelf on YouTube


    Episode Highlights:
    • [06:55] The Two-Second Habit That Makes Nutrition Effortless

    Jessica explains how PlantChi turns nutrition into a two-second microhabit by asking consumers to add seasoning to foods they already eat. Instead of replacing meals or demanding new routines, the product fits naturally into salads, eggs, avocado toast, and snacks. This frictionless approach makes adoption easier, encourages repeated use, and gives unfamiliar functional products a better chance of becoming lasting habits.


    • [12:02] How One Phrase Changed PlantChi’s Consumer Appeal

    Jessica explains how changing just a few words transformed consumer response to PlantChi. “Super seed blends” prompted comparisons with familiar ingredients, while “seasonings with benefits” immediately communicated flavor, texture, and nutrition. By testing language directly with consumers, she discovered that precise positioning could generate curiosity and trial. The lesson: unfamiliar products need simple language that communicates purpose and differentiation instantly.


    • [14:36] Why Jessica Chose Brand Integrity Over Added Salt

    Jessica shares why she rejected advice from a well-known athlete to add salt to PlantChi for greater flavor appeal. Although the recommendation could have improved palatability, it conflicted with her mission to encourage nutrient-rich eating without relying on salt. By protecting the brand’s core values and allowing consumers to add salt themselves, she chose authenticity and long-term trust over shortcuts.


    • [00:15:56] How Packaging Can Build Better Everyday Habits

    Jessica explains why PlantChi’s packaging size was deliberately designed around habit formation rather than conventional retail economics. While retailers suggested smaller bags, she wanted consumers to have enough product for multiple daily uses. The larger format reinforces the idea that PlantChi belongs in everyday routines, helping consumers experiment, repeat usage, and build familiarity. Packaging, she argues, can actively shape consumer behavior.


    • [20:36] Why Jessica Believes Narrow and Deep Beats Mass Retail

    Jessica explains why PlantChi is deliberately pursuing a narrow-and-deep growth strategy rather than rushing into major retail. Drawing on lessons from a previous food company, she prioritizes direct-to-consumer, Amazon, and independent retailers where consumer feedback and education can happen more closely. This slower approach allows the brand to refine its product, messaging, and community before pursuing broader distribution and scale.


    • [22:31] Why Addition Beats Subtraction in Wellness Marketing

    Jessica challenges wellness marketing’s obsession with subtraction, from “no sugar” to “no gluten,” arguing that consumers can respond more positively to messages centered on addition. PlantChi focuses on what people can gain: nutrients, flavor, texture, and everyday nourishment. By framing health as enhancement rather than restriction, Jessica believes brands can create more empowering communication and encourage genuine, sustainable behavior change.


    Quotes:
    1. "PlantChi came to be when a doctor, during one of my spells of being vegan, said, Just sprinkle hemp seeds on everything you eat. And I was like, wow, this is what we're not hearing today, and this is what we should be hearing, that the answer is just simple, real, whole foods to get a little extra nourishment into your diet."
    2. "PlantChi is a two-second microhabit to make meals more nutrient-dense. I didn't want to ask people to overhaul their lifestyle. Asking someone to make a huge change takes a lot of influence and takes a lot of time. A seasoning with benefits that's seed-based is an effortless action where all they have to do is sprinkle it on whatever they're already eating."
    3. "Going this honest route, it's not gonna make the big bang bam kind of noise that a big sexy claim would make, and so that's hard. It takes a lot of education, and it kind of takes people to watch over time and get curious, so it might take a little bit more time, especially when you're making a newish product. People have to watch for a while before they actually dive in."
    4. "Asking somebody to make a huge change in their lives is a lot to ask because people are busy, they don't have a lot of energy, and they're set in their ways. When getting somebody to develop a habit, you wanna ask them to make a small change, like sprinkling something on a food, whatever they're already eating, because it's effortless and it takes two seconds and there's no extra work."
    23 min
  • From Family Tradition to Global Shelf: How to Scale a Cultural Product Without Losing Its Roots
    What if the key to launching a global product wasn't about reinventing the wheel, but bringing an authentic cultural tradition to an entirely new market?

    In this episode of Behind the Shelf, Keren Novack sits down with Roger Velasquez, Co-Founder of The Purple Drop, about introducing chicha morada, a traditional Peruvian drink made from purple corn, to American consumers. Roger shares the realities of moving from a family kitchen to the retail shelf, from sourcing the right ingredients and preserving traditional methods to educating consumers and winning over retail buyers. 

    They explore why branding may earn the first purchase, but product experience earns the second, and how sampling, storytelling, and social media can turn unfamiliar flavors into lasting habits. The conversation also examines sustainability, consumer behavior, and the countless operational decisions required to scale a heritage product without compromising its identity. 

    What you will learn:
    • Why branding earns the first purchase, but product experience drives repeat purchase
    • The sourcing reality behind "authenticity as non-negotiable"
    • How to educate consumers without alienating retail buyers
    • The "Say-Do Gap" in sustainability and convenience
    • Why cultural products require a different go-to-market playbook 
    • The million tiny decisions that happen behind the shelf


    Roger Velasquez
    is a senior media and growth leader with 18+ years of experience building integrated marketing ecosystems for global brands and high-growth businesses. He has led multi-million-dollar investments across CTV, social, search, commerce, sponsorships, and platform partnerships, helping brands accelerate growth through data, creativity, and channel intelligence. Roger is also Co-Founder and Fractional CMO of Purple Drop, a Peruvian purple corn beverage rooted in functional wellness and Latin heritage. He focuses on building culturally grounded, consumer-centric strategies that turn marketing into measurable, repeatable business results.

    Episode Resources:
    • Roger Velasquez on LinkedIn
    • The Purple Drop Website
    • Keren Novack on LinkedIn
    • Curion Insights Website
    • Curion Webinars and Podcasts  
    • Behind the Shelf on Apple Podcasts
    • Behind the Shelf on Spotify
    • Behind the Shelf on YouTube


    Episode Highlights:

    • [01:14] The Invisible Work Behind Every Product on the Shelf

    Roger reveals that every successful product is built on hundreds of decisions consumers never see; from formulation iterations and supplier negotiations to production challenges, distribution logistics, and late-night doubts. For founders and product leaders, the lesson is simple: marketing is only one part of the journey. Before scaling demand, brands need reliable sourcing, consistent production, and a product that works. Operational excellence isn't behind growth; it's what makes sustainable growth possible.


    • [08:09] Why Regional Sourcing Can Become Your Moat

    Roger explains why Purple Drop sources its purple corn exclusively from Peru, where regional soil, farming practices, and seasonality influence both flavor and nutritional properties. For CPG leaders, authenticity becomes more than a brand story; it becomes a defensible competitive advantage. While sourcing locally or switching suppliers may appear easier, preserving ingredient specificity can strengthen differentiation, support premium positioning, and give brands a credible reason for consumers and retailers to choose them.


    • [11:37] Your Brand Gets the First Purchase. Taste Gets the Second.

    Roger shares a powerful two-stage framework: branding creates curiosity and earns the first purchase, but product experience determines whether consumers return. This is particularly important when introducing unfamiliar global flavors, where expectations can differ dramatically from reality. Purple Drop's experience shows that consumers may initially say, "not what I expected," but return when the taste delivers. For emerging categories, exceptional product experience must ultimately validate the brand promise.


    • [14:56] Scaling Without Sacrificing What Makes You Authentic

    Roger describes the difficult choices involved in scaling a cultural product while protecting its identity. For Purple Drop, sourcing Peruvian purple corn and preserving traditional brewing methods remain non-negotiable, while alternative formats such as powders or concentrates offer room to adapt. The broader lesson for CPG founders is to identify which ingredients and processes define cultural authenticity and competitive advantage, then find flexibility everywhere else. Scaling doesn't require abandoning what makes the product distinctive.


    • [16:37] Education Can Turn Curiosity Into a Buying Habit

    Roger explains why education is essential when introducing consumers to an unfamiliar category. Sampling, social content, retailer education, and demonstrations help answer basic questions and give consumers reasons to incorporate a new product into their routines. For Purple Drop, showing different consumption occasions, from cocktails to everyday meals, helps transform chicha morada from an unfamiliar Peruvian drink into a versatile beverage. Education, Roger argues, isn't simply marketing support; it's part of the distribution strategy.


    • [00:23:43] Why Sustainability Often Loses to Convenience

    Roger highlights a significant gap between what consumers say they value and what actually influences their purchases. Despite strong stated interest in sustainability, conversations at consumer events showed that it rarely becomes a priority unless someone prompts the discussion. For CPG brands, the implication is clear: lead with the benefits consumers actively seek- taste, experience, health, or authenticity, and make sustainability a supporting layer. Values can strengthen loyalty, but they don't necessarily drive initial trial.


    Quotes:
    1. "Every product has a story behind the shelf that consumers don't get to see. We see years of decisions, sacrifices, hundreds of little choices and decisions that got us here."
    2. "I think seeing the global trend to some of the trends on the consumer here in the United States, the appetite for more global flavors, the fact that people are leaning more into the health-better-for-me drinks as well. One of the things that Purple Drop has is that it actually has 10 times the antioxidants than blackberries."
    3. "Authenticity wasn't negotiable for us. We weren't interested in creating a purple-inspired new drink. It was like, let's bring Chicha Morada from the way we drink it and bring it to a new market."
    4. "A 100 a 100 percent. And I think that was always on the back of our heads. Like, even when we got our first taste out of coming out of the brewery, are we doing it right? It does just taste like my mom's recipe that she has perfected over the years."
    21 min
  • Why Familiar Beats Revolutionary in CPG with Sean Knecht
    What if the secret to building a breakthrough CPG brand wasn't inventing something entirely new, but reimagining something familiar?

    In this episode of Behind the Shelf, Keren Novack speaks with Sean Knecht, cofounder of Tantos, and President of PrideBites LLC,  about transforming a chef's accidental discovery into the world's first pasta chip. Sean shares how early sellout launches validated demand, why combining familiarity with novelty lowers the barrier to consumer trial, and how thoughtful branding can make all the difference in a crowded snack aisle. 

    He also explains why great taste must come before health messaging, how retailers evaluate emerging brands, and why proving shelf velocity is essential to earning long-term retail placement. Beyond the product itself, Sean offers an honest look at the operational realities of building a CPG company, from inventory forecasting and production planning to managing expiration dates and fulfillment. 

    What you will learn:
    • How to validate product-market fit before betting the business
    • Why "familiar plus novel" is the most powerful positioning in a crowded snack aisle
    • The underrated role of strategic naming in shelf-stopping branding
    • How to prioritize product quality over health claims in emerging food categories
    • Why retail buyers cling to established giants and how to break through their risk aversion
    • The hidden operational complexity behind one bag of chips


    Sean Knecht
    is the co-founder of Tantos, the first and only pasta chip brand, transforming a casual dinner innovation into a scaled CPG business available in 1,500+ U.S. retail locations. With a background in product validation and entrepreneurship, Sean has built two revenue-generating companies while mastering the intersection of consumer psychology, operational efficiency, and retail dynamics.

    Episode Resources:
    • Sean Knecht on LinkedIn
    • Tantos Website
    • Keren Novack on LinkedIn
    • Curion Insights Website
    • Curion Webinars and Podcasts  
    • Behind the Shelf on Apple Podcasts
    • Behind the Shelf on Spotify
    • Behind the Shelf on YouTube


    Episode Highlights:
    • [05:33] Test Demand with Limited Product Drops

    Rather than relying on surveys or focus groups, Sean validated demand by releasing three small batches of 500 units that sold out in just 13, 8, and 7 minutes. More importantly, customers kept coming back. Those repeat purchases proved the product had staying power beyond initial curiosity. Sean explains why small, controlled launches can reveal genuine product-market fit while providing better insights than expensive traditional market research.

    • [08:44] Great Taste Must Come Before Health Claims

    Sean believes every food brand should solve one problem before anything else: make the product taste exceptional. Health benefits, clean ingredients, and nutrition matter, but they won't drive repeat purchases if consumers don't enjoy eating the product. Working with a Michelin-trained chef ensured Tantos delivered on flavor first, with healthier attributes refined later. For Sean, taste is the foundation of lasting customer loyalty.

    • [09:26] Build on Familiarity to Reduce Buyer Risk

    Instead of positioning Tantos as a replacement for chips like Doritos or Fritos, Sean introduced it as a new option that complements existing favorites. That simple shift reduced resistance from both retailers and consumers. Because pasta is already universally recognised and loved, the product felt familiar despite being innovative. Sean explains why expanding an established category is often easier than convincing people to embrace something entirely new.

    • [00:12:39] Create a Brand Name That Wins in Seconds

    Sean reveals that the name "Tantos" was carefully designed to stand out while feeling instantly familiar. Inspired by iconic snack brands ending in "-os," the name also reflects the company's Italian roots. Since shoppers often make purchasing decisions in just a few seconds, every branding element must quickly communicate confidence and credibility. Sean explains why thoughtful naming can become a powerful competitive advantage on crowded retail shelves.

    • [00:17:38] Shelf Velocity Is the Metric That Really Matters

    For Sean, success isn't measured by social media buzz or impressive launch-day sales. The real indicator is how quickly products move off retail shelves and whether retailers continue placing repeat orders. By closely monitoring sales velocity across more than 1,500 stores, Tantos can distinguish genuine consumer adoption from short-lived curiosity. Sean explains why repeat purchases provide the clearest signal that a brand is built for sustainable growth.

    • [20:17] Turn Supply Chain Challenges into an Advantage

    Sean shares how managing inventory, production schedules, supplier relationships, forecasting, and expiration dates became just as important as developing the product itself. While these operational challenges are often overlooked, they create a significant competitive advantage for brands that master them. Sean explains why disciplined supply chain management enables sustainable growth and makes it harder for much larger competitors to successfully replicate your success.

    Quotes:
    1. "For me, if I'm gonna bring something to life, it has to be new and it has to be different. The fact that we could say we are the first and only of something, to me, that was like, okay. That is good enough for me to go down this rabbit hole." - Sean

    2. "I'm not gonna do this unless it tastes good. Like, first and foremost, because all these new brands are coming out where it's ingredients you don't even know, you've never even heard of, can't even pronounce, and they don't taste good." - Sean

    3. "The snack aisle is stale. Right? Figuratively, literally. There's been no innovation in the last thirty years." - Sean

    4. "We're not trying to replace Doritos, Cheetos, and Fritos, but when you're going to buy your Cheetos, Doritos, and Fritos, we wanna be that extension." - Sean

    24 min
  • The Say-Do Gap in Food: Jacob Trumbull on What Consumers Really Buy
    What if the real barrier to healthier food isn't what consumers want, but how they shop?

    In this episode of Behind the Shelf, host Keren Novack sits down with Jacob Trumbull, founder of Roaring Fork Mill, to explore the hidden forces shaping the future of food brands. Jacob reveals why the biggest challenge facing healthier, more sustainable food products isn’t consumer demand; it’s consumer behavior. Together, they unpack the “say-do gap,” where shoppers express interest in better ingredients and sustainable practices but often choose based on convenience, price, and availability. 

    Jacob shares lessons from behavioral science, regenerative agriculture, and building a scalable grain ecosystem, explaining why accessibility, shelf placement, and frictionless purchasing matter more than education alone. From redefining the role of transparency to understanding what turns niche products into everyday habits, this conversation reveals how food innovators can build brands that truly connect with consumers and create lasting category change. 
    What you will learn:
    • The "Say-Do Gap" in Food Retail
    • How to Win with Accessibility Over Perfection
    • Why Regenerative Organic Certification Is the Next Big Shift
    • The Principle of Least Effort in Every Touchpoint
    • How to Bridge the Education-to-Action Gap
    • Why Transparency Isn't Enough Without Distribution


    Jacob Trumbull
    is the Founder of Roaring Fork Mill, a Colorado-based stone mill dedicated to rebuilding local grain systems through regenerative agriculture, heritage grains, and behavioral science-informed food innovation. With a unique background spanning environmental studies, behavioral science, and regenerative farming, Jacob brings a distinctive perspective to why consumers make the food choices they do and how to shift those behaviors at scale. 

    Episode Resources:
    • Jacob Trumbull on LinkedIn
    • Roaring Fork Mill Website
    • Keren Novack on LinkedIn
    • Behind the Shelf on Apple Podcasts
    • Behind the Shelf on Spotify
    • Behind the Shelf on YouTube


    Episode Highlights:
    • [05:12] The Gluten Sensitivity Myth Explained
    Jacob reveals the surprising gap between perception and reality: while 32% of Americans believe they are gluten sensitive, only around 3% actually are. He explains that the issue often comes from highly processed, bleached flour rather than gluten itself. By focusing on better processing methods and heritage grains, Jacob shows how brands can solve real consumer problems, create healthier alternatives, and transform restrictive eating habits into sustainable food choices.

    • [09:21] Why Accessibility Drives Food Brand Growth
    Jacob explains why accessibility, not just product quality or marketing claims, is what separates niche products from mainstream success. He shares how pricing, availability, and shelf placement determine whether consumers actually adopt better food choices. For brands looking to scale, Jacob emphasizes that the distribution strategy must be considered from the beginning. A great product cannot change behavior if shoppers cannot easily find it, afford it, or fit it into their everyday routines.

    • [11:09] How Shelf Placement Shapes Buying Decisions
    Jacob explores the power of choice architecture and how retail environments influence consumer decisions. He explains that shelf placement is more than a logistical detail, it is a behavioral science tool that directly impacts discovery and sales. From eye-level positioning to retailer strategy, Jacob reveals why brands must think beyond product development and understand how physical placement affects purchasing behavior, especially when trying to move from specialty markets into mainstream retail.

    • [14:11] The Say-Do Gap in Consumer Choices
    Jacob breaks down the disconnect between what consumers say they value and what they actually purchase. While shoppers express interest in healthier ingredients and sustainable products, convenience, price, and availability often determine the final decision. He explains why transparency and education alone are not enough to change habits. Brands must remove friction and make better choices easier through accessible pricing, wider distribution, and smarter retail strategies.

    • [16:39] Removing Friction to Increase Food Sales
    Jacob applies the principle of least effort to both online and physical shopping experiences. He explains how small barriers, like a slower checkout process or poor shelf placement, can significantly reduce conversions. For brands, every consumer touchpoint matters, from website design to retail positioning. Jacob highlights that reducing friction is a competitive advantage because even the best products struggle when customers have to work harder to discover, evaluate, or purchase them.

    • [23:01] The Hidden Challenges of Scaling Distribution
    Jacob reveals why national expansion creates unexpected challenges for growing food brands. Moving from local sales to major retailers introduces complex distribution systems, longer approval cycles, database requirements, and increased operational costs. He explains that scaling requires more than a great product—it demands strong business models, careful margin planning, and strategic partnerships. Brands that overlook distribution complexity risk losing profitability even after achieving retail success.


    Quotes:
    1. "Thirty-two percent of people in the US think they're gluten sensitive, and only three percent actually are. It's because we've created in a food item, an ingredient, white over-processed and bleached flour that is more chemically based than a natural ingredient. Our bodies can't digest it, but it's not that you can't have flour, you can't have this over-processed flour."
    2. "One is accessibility. If a product is too special or too pricey, it's not accessible. If it's only available to a certain subset of people, it's not gonna change larger norms around how we view that item or that vertical within food. If it's not accessible in conventional stores, you're not having as big of an impact as you could."
    3. "Choice architecture is the layout of where your product is on the shelf. Our eyes are drawn to certain areas of shelves in stores. If you can work with the retailers that you're in and have your product at eye level, you're gonna sell a lot more product. Getting a good placement on a store shelf could mean the difference between your dream retailer succeeding or failing."
    4. "If you can get something to somebody and lessen the barriers to that purchasing, you're winning. If your website's confusing to navigate, you're gonna lose so much conversion because people will click out if checkout takes three seconds longer than they want. That's how short people's attention span is these days."

    29 min
  • Maggie Schmieder on the Loyalty Secret Most Beauty Brands Miss
    What if the secret to building a cult-following brand wasn't fancy manufacturing or massive marketing budgets, but genuine human connection?
    In this episode of Behind the Shelf, Keren Novack sits down with Maggie Schmieder, founder of Bitty Balm, to explore how a simple kitchen experiment evolved into a thriving clean beauty brand with an impressive 55% repeat customer rate. Maggie shares the lessons she learned from building products by hand, listening closely to customer feedback, and prioritizing relationships over traditional marketing tactics. The conversation dives into product innovation, brand positioning, consumer trust, and the challenges of standing out in the crowded beauty industry. 
    Maggie explains why simplicity can be a competitive advantage, how transparency builds loyalty, and why understanding customers on a personal level creates lasting growth. This episode offers valuable insights for founders, marketers, and anyone interested in building brands that customers genuinely love. 
    What you will learn:
    • Why "products made for girls" fail with Gen Z consumers
    • How to build a 55% repeat customer rate as a solopreneur in a saturated market 
    • The formula-first approach to brand building 
    • How to reframe product limitations as brand differentiation
    • The underrated power of consumer education in building trust and repeat purchases.
    • Why the beauty industry still has a credibility problem

    Maggie Schmieder
    is the founder of Bitty Balm, a clean beauty brand revolutionizing multi-use cosmetics for health-conscious consumers. A special education teacher and lifelong maker by nature, Maggie identified a critical gap in the beauty market: the near-total absence of dye-free, ingredient-conscious makeup options safe for both kids and adults. Since launching Bitty Balm in February 2024, she has hand-formulated and manufactured every product, earning recognition including a Clean Beauty Award in her first year and placement in premium retail locations across the North Shore of Chicago.

    Episode Timeline:
    • [00:00] Intro
    • [00:48] From Teacher to Maker: The Creator Behind Bitty Balm
    • [01:28] The Glittery Eyeshadow Moment That Started It All
    • [03:57] From Pink Pots to Colorful Sticks: How Customer Feedback Shaped the Product
    • [05:06] Why "Makeup for Girls" Failed (And What Worked Instead)
    • [09:30] Imposter Syndrome, Cancer Survivors, and Real Customer Stories
    • [12:52] The Relationship Hack That Built 55% Repeat Customers
    • [16:27] Why Hand-Making Everything Is Your Competitive Advantage
    • [17:48] The Beauty Industry's Big Problem (And Your Opportunity)
    • [20:19] Less Is More: The Real Innovation Strategy
    • [21:02] The Shelf Check: Rapid-Fire Wisdom
    • [23:04] Key Takeaways & Final Thoughts


    Episode Resources:
    • Maggie Schmieder on LinkedIn
    • Bitty Balm Website
    • Keren Novack on LinkedIn
    • Behind the Shelf on Apple Podcasts
    • Behind the Shelf on Spotify
    • Behind the Shelf on YouTube


    Episode Highlights:
    • [05:06] Build Aspirational Brands That Cross Generations
    Maggie learned that positioning Bitty Balm as “makeup for girls” limited its appeal because younger consumers aspire to use the same products adults use, not simplified versions designed specifically for them. By shifting from age-based marketing to aspirational, lifestyle-focused positioning, she broadened the brand’s reach and attracted loyal repeat buyers. The experience highlights how values-driven branding can outperform demographic segmentation and create stronger connections across multiple generations of consumers.

    • [07:33] Remove Small Frictions to Create Lasting Customer Loyalty
    Maggie discovered that seemingly minor inconveniences can have a major impact on customer satisfaction and retention. Bitty Balm redesigned packaging so customers could quickly identify colors and transitioned from pots to sticks to improve usability, even though it required significant reformulation and extra production work. By treating small customer frustrations as important product opportunities, she improved the overall experience and strengthened loyalty, proving that repeat business is often earned through thoughtful details rather than large marketing initiatives.

    • [09:30] Turn Customer Complaints Into Loyalty-Building Opportunities
    Rather than viewing complaints as problems to resolve quickly, Maggie treats them as opportunities to deepen customer relationships. When a customer questioned product variability, she explained the hand-crafted process behind Bitty Balm and provided personalized guidance to help find the ideal product match. This combination of education, transparency, and individual attention transformed skepticism into trust. Her approach demonstrates how thoughtful service recovery can create stronger loyalty than a frictionless experience and generate powerful word-of-mouth advocacy.

    • [12:52] Make Relationships Your Most Powerful Growth Channel
    Operating in a crowded beauty market, Maggie built strong repeat purchase rates by prioritizing genuine human relationships over traditional customer acquisition tactics. She invests time in remembering customers, engaging personally at events, and creating meaningful community connections that extend beyond transactions. These authentic interactions frequently lead to referrals, partnerships, and repeat purchases. Her experience challenges brands to view relationship-building not as a supplemental activity but as a primary growth strategy capable of outperforming expensive paid marketing channels.

    • [17:48] Use Simplicity as Innovation in Crowded Categories
    Maggie argues that many beauty brands rely on complex ingredient stories and exaggerated claims that often confuse consumers. Bitty Balm takes the opposite approach by emphasizing streamlined formulas, transparency, and realistic product benefits. Rather than adding more ingredients or promises, the brand focuses on creating effective products with fewer components and greater clarity. As consumers increasingly value authenticity and regulatory scrutiny rises, simplicity becomes a meaningful form of innovation that helps build trust and differentiation.


    Quotes:
    1. "I realized that while I had made the product and it's really great for everybody, a product for everybody was really kind of a product made for no one. It turned out that women who are busy and educated are the Bitty Balm buyers, those that are at the store grabbing the dye-free Cheetos off the shelf. They want to look great, but they also want to make better choices for themselves."
    2. "I started out with small pots, but I quickly learned that girls don't want makeup made for girls. Consumers were asking for a stick; I listened, and that came with challenges because I had to tweak the formula to be a different consistency. Each of these little tweaks was directly related to what the consumer wanted."
    3. "The press and the accolades are wonderful, and they give me social proof, but really the thing that's special is the actual customers. When someone tells me they bought it because they're a cancer survivor, or a woman with rare breast cancer who can't use anything with hormone-disrupting ingredients, it's those stories that make it all worth it."
    4. "Just in the last thirty days, as I look at our data, 55% of sales were from repeat customers. That's a pretty big number, and it really comes down to building those connections and finding personal relationships that solidify Bitty Balm as a brand."
    20 min