Send us a text

Welcome to Better Betrayal, the podcast that dives deep into the intricate strategy, legendary gameplay, and unforgettable moments of the hit show Survivor.

Join host Xavier Fisher for a meticulous and passionate breakdown of the game's greatest players. In this epic multi-part series, we've undertaken the monumental task of ranking the Top 50 Players in Survivor History.

From cunning strategists and social savants to challenge beasts and iconic winners, we analyze every aspect of what makes a Survivor legend. We break down their games, their biggest moves, their most devastating blindsides, and what cemented their legacy in the history of the game.

Did your favorite player make the list? Where do icons like Boston Rob, Parvati Shallow, Sandra Diaz-Twine, and Tony Vlachos ultimately rank? The debate ends here.

Whether you're a day-one fan or a new recruit to the tribe, Better Betrayal offers insightful, well-researched, and entertaining content for every level of Survivor superfan.

Subscribe now to join the conversation, and get ready to hear the definitive ranking of the best to ever play.

Catch up on the full series and get ready for our return after the next two seasons for a list update!

Support the show

Listen To Better Betrayal Anywhere: https://betterbetrayal.buzzsprout.com

Send us a text

Hello and welcome back to Better Betrayal, your essential Survivor podcast! I'm your host, Xavier Fisher, and we are deep into our definitive countdown of the Top 50 Players in Survivor History.

In this episode, we're breaking down the legendary games of players ranked #20 through #11. We'll be analyzing the brilliant, the controversial, and the iconic strategies that have defined these all-time greats.

First, a quick recap: if you missed our previous episodes where we laid out our criteria, discussed honorable mentions, and revealed players #50 through #21, be sure to go back and listen to those first!

Today's list is stacked with winners, legends, and master strategists. We're talking about the only winner to save themselves with a pre-merge idol, the first person to ever play a perfect game, a two-time champion, and players who delivered some of the most dominant single-season performances ever seen.

We'll be diving deep into the games of:

• Sophie Clarke and the cult-like control of South Pacific
• Kyle  Fraser's social mastery in the New Era
• The polarizing, four-season arc of Tyson Apostol
• The calculated brilliance of Yul Kwon
• The undeniable, "as long as it ain't me" legacy of Sandra Diaz-Twine
• Amanda Kimmel's unprecedented run to back-to-back FTC appearances
• Natalie Anderson's ruthless revenge tour
• Chris Daugherty's underrated comeback story
• The stunning rise and fall of JT Thomas
• And Todd Herzog's masterclass in jury management

For each player, we'll give you a hint, break down their key stats, pivotal moves, and ultimately debate what earns them their spot on this list—and what holds them back from the coveted top 10.

The journey isn't over! Join us next week for the epic conclusion as we finally reveal our picks for the Top 10 Players in Survivor History. That list includes nine winners, two one-time players, and a competitor you'll see on the upcoming Survivor 50!

Subscribe now so you don't miss it. This is Better Betrayal.

Support the show

Listen To Better Betrayal Anywhere: https://betterbetrayal.buzzsprout.com

Send us a text

Welcome back to Better Betrayal, the Survivor podcast where we rank and analyze the greatest players in the show's history! In this episode, host Xavier Fisher dives into players #30 through #21, featuring a mix of legendary winners, strategic masterminds, and revolutionary players who changed the game.

From flawless winning performances to iconic underdog runs, this batch includes some of Survivor’s most memorable names. We’ll break down their biggest moves, toughest tribals, and how they stacked up against the competition—both in their original seasons and on returns.

Highlights from this episode include:

• A perfect game winner who dominated strategically, socially, and physically
• The only player to receive the most jury votes as a losing finalist
• A three-time player who proved age is just a number
• A new-era winner who controlled the game from start to finish
• And one of the most influential players in Survivor history, whose strategy set the blueprint for future seasons

Whether you're a longtime fan or new to the game, this episode is packed with deep dives into what makes these players legendary. Tune in to find out who made the cut—and where they land in Survivor history.

Join us next time as we climb even higher into the rankings, revealing #20-11, featuring 9 winners, three one-time players, and a competitors returning for Survivor 50!

Better Betrayal—where every blindside, idol play, and social maneuver is put under the microscope. Drop your predictions in the comments, and see you next time!

Support the show

Listen To Better Betrayal Anywhere: https://betterbetrayal.buzzsprout.com

Send us a text

Welcome back to Better Betrayal, the ultimate Survivor podcast where we rank and analyze the greatest players in the show's history! In this episode, host Xavier Fisher dives deep into players ranked #40 through #31, breaking down their strategic brilliance, social prowess, and physical dominance across their seasons.

From underdog winners to masterful strategists who fell just short of the title, this batch of players includes some unforgettable names who left their mark on Survivor. We’ll explore their biggest moves, toughest tribals, and how they stacked up against the competition—both in their original seasons and on returns.

Whether you're a longtime fan or new to the game, this episode is packed with insights, stats, and behind-the-scenes moments that define what makes these players legendary. Tune in to find out who made the cut and where they land in Survivor history—and don’t forget to check out our previous episodes covering #50-41!

Join us next time as we climb even higher into the rankings, revealing #30-21, featuring seven past winners and some of the most iconic players to ever set foot on the island.

Better Betrayal—where every vote, idol play, and blindside is put under the microscope. Drop your guesses in the comments, and see you next week!

Support the show

Listen To Better Betrayal Anywhere: https://betterbetrayal.buzzsprout.com

Send us a text

Welcome to Better Betrayal, the ultimate Survivor podcast where we break down the greatest players to ever outwit, outplay, and outlast! Host Xavier Fisher kicks off the countdown of the Top 50 Survivor Players of All Time with rankings #50-41, featuring a mix of legendary returnees, underrated strategists, and new-era standouts.  

This episode covers iconic challenge beasts, masterful social manipulators, and players who revolutionized the game—some of whom will be returning for Survivor 50! We dive deep into their biggest moves, brutal blindsides, and the moments that defined their legacies. Whether they dominated physically, strategically, or socially, each player earned their spot through unforgettable gameplay.  

Tune in to hear heated debates, surprising rankings, and analysis that will have you rethinking *Survivor* history. And stay tuned—next week, we’ll reveal #40-31, including four winners and two more Survivor 50 returnees!  

Subscribe now so you don’t miss the next rankings drop. This is Better Betrayal—the podcast for superfans, by superfans. Outwit. Outplay. Outlast.

Support the show

Listen To Better Betrayal Anywhere: https://betterbetrayal.buzzsprout.com

Send us a text

With Survivor 50 right around the corner, it’s time to celebrate the legends who’ve defined the game. In this kickoff episode host Xavier Fisher breaks down the criteria for ranking the Top 50 Survivor players of all time—and dives into the honorable mentions who just missed the cut.

We’re talking winners who didn’t make the list (from Jenna to Kenzie), non-winners who were so close (like Russell Hantz and Andrea Boehlke), and a rapid-fire rundown of notable players ranked 51–90. This episode is all about setting the stage for a fair, strategic, and résumé-based ranking—no popularity contests here.

Whether you're a casual fan or a day-one Survivor superfan, this countdown is built to spark debate, celebrate gameplay, and revisit the best (and most chaotic) moves in Survivor history.

New episodes drop weekly as we count down the Top 50.
Plus: ongoing coverage of Survivor: Australia vs. the World

Support the show

Listen To Better Betrayal Anywhere: https://betterbetrayal.buzzsprout.com

Send us a text

Welcome back to Better Betrayal: A Survivor Podcast. I’m your host, Xavier Fisher, and today we’re diving into one of the most exciting leaks in Survivor history — the tribe divisions for Survivor 50.

We’ll break down all three tribes — Purple, Orange, and Teal — including who’s playing, their tribe colors, potential alliances, and returning connections. From legends like Colby Donaldson, Cirie Fields, and Coach to newer faces from Seasons 45-49, we analyze how the producers split up past relationships and set the stage for what could be an iconic season.

Then, we open up the mailbag and answer your listener questions, including:

• The top 5 dumbest moves in Survivor history (from both players and production)
• A deep dive into Survivor showmances — who dated, who married, and who blew up each other’s games
• Why a teen version of Survivor probably wouldn’t work
• A listener pitches a top 200 Survivor player countdown, and I weigh in
• A behind-the-scenes look at the Survivor casting process and some of the wildest casting mistakes in show history

Whether you're a new fan or a day-one watcher, this episode is packed with bold takes, nostalgia, and deep Survivor insight. Don’t forget to send in your own questions for the next mailbag by clicking the “Text Us” link in the episode description.

Thanks for tuning in—and remember, sometimes betrayal is better.

Support the show

Listen To Better Betrayal Anywhere: https://betterbetrayal.buzzsprout.com

Send us a text

In this jam-packed episode of Better Betrayal: A Survivor Podcast, host Xavier Fisher dives deep into a growing phenomenon that’s quietly reshaping Survivor's most iconic tradition: returnee seasons. From Boston Rob to Parvati to Cirie, Survivor legends used to disappear into myth before making explosive comebacks. But with shows like The Traitors, The Challenge, and Snakes in the Grass scooping up Survivor alumni, are these return appearances losing their luster?

Xavier takes us through a detailed timeline of every major Survivor returnee season, and how many players from each era ventured into other reality shows. The stats are staggering — over 75 former Survivor contestants have appeared on other reality TV shows since Winners at War. What does that mean for the sacred legacy of a second (or third) shot at the million?

Plus: shocking news from Australian Survivor! After ten seasons, fan-favorite host Jonathan LaPaglia has been abruptly fired. We break down what happened, why it matters, and what this unexpected blindside might say about Jeff Probst’s eventual exit from US Survivor.

All that, plus listener questions, hard Survivor truths, and a look ahead to the long-anticipated Survivor 50 season. Don’t miss it.

Support the show

Listen To Better Betrayal Anywhere: https://betterbetrayal.buzzsprout.com

Send us a text

In this episode of Better Betrayal: A Survivor Podcast, host Xavier Fisher dives deep into one of the most overlooked aspects of Survivor gameplay — the physical game. Once hailed as a badge of honor, dominating in challenges is now often seen as a liability. But is that reputation deserved?

Xavier breaks down the performance of every “challenge beast” in Survivor history — players who won four or more individual immunity challenges in a single season — and examines how they fared in the overall game. He explores why physical dominance might hurt your chances of winning, how the variability in challenges skews our perceptions, and whether the shortened 26-day format has changed the importance of winning immunity.

From Kelly Wiglesworth to Tony Vlachos to modern-era beasts like Rachel Lamont and Joe Hunter, this episode is a comprehensive look at how Survivor's third pillar has evolved — and whether it still matters in a game increasingly dominated by strategy and social bonds

Support the show

Listen To Better Betrayal Anywhere: https://betterbetrayal.buzzsprout.com

Send us a text

Host Xavier Fisher dives deep into the historic Survivor 50, the largest all-returnee season ever, featuring a scattered cast of legends, underdogs, and wildcards. In this episode, we break down:

Fan-Voted Twists: From tribe colors to firemaking, how will these choices shape the game?
Pregame Threat Levels: Ranking all 24 players—who’s a dead man walking, and who’s poised to fly under the radar?
Explosive Connections: Old rivalries, secret alliances, and past betrayals that could ignite the game.
Winner Pick: Why one strategic mastermind is destined to outplay, outlast, and outwit.

Featuring hot takes on Cirie’s impossible target, Charlie’s path to victory, and whether Q or Coach will self-destruct first. Plus, superlatives (First Boot! Merge Boot! Biggest Goat!) and a rant about the cast’s glaring omissions.

Survivor 50 is chaos waiting to happen—don’t miss the ultimate preview!

Subscribe to Better Betrayal for more savage Survivor analysis.

#Survivor50 #InTheHandsOfTheFans #CharlieForTheWin

Support the show

Listen To Better Betrayal Anywhere: https://betterbetrayal.buzzsprout.com