In September of 1978, Pope John Paul I was found dead in his bed after only 33 days as head of the Catholic Church. No autopsy. Conflicting witness accounts. Immediate confusion over who discovered the body—and why the Vatican’s story kept changing. What should have been a moment of global mourning instead became one of the most unsettling mysteries in modern Church history.

In this episode, we walk through the final days of the “Smiling Pope,” a man known for humility, reform-minded ideals, and quiet resistance to corruption. We examine the strange circumstances surrounding his death, the rushed embalming, the missing details, and the powerful institutions he may have unsettled—including the Vatican Bank, secret societies, and figures who stood to lose everything if reforms moved forward.

Was it a tragic natural death… or something far darker hidden behind locked doors and sacred walls?
Tonight, Beyond the Campfire steps into the shadows of the Vatican to ask the question many still whisper:
Did Pope John Paul I die—or was he silenced?

Follow Us:Instagram: @BeyondCampfireTwitter: @BeyondCampfire

Each year, as children sleep and households grow quiet, an old woman is said to travel the night sky on a broomstick—slipping down chimneys, leaving gifts for some… and coal for others. Known as La Befana, she is often remembered as a kindly Christmas witch, but her origins are far older, stranger, and darker than the folklore suggests.

In this episode, we peel back the cheerful veneer to uncover the ancient roots of La Befana, tracing her story through pagan ritual, Christian myth, and whispered Italian tradition. From her supposed meeting with the Magi to her eternal wandering in search of a child she believes she failed, La Befana’s tale blurs the line between benevolence and curse.

Is she a protector of children—or a reminder that judgment always comes quietly in the night? Tonight, we follow the sound of broom bristles on the rooftop and ask the question few dare to: what happens if La Befana decides you were never meant to receive a gift at all?

Follow Us:Instagram: @BeyondCampfireTwitter: @BeyondCampfire

In the quiet town of Amityville, New York, a Dutch Colonial house stands with windows that seem to watch anyone who dares look back. In 1974, the DeFeo family was brutally murdered inside its walls. One year later, the Lutz family fled the home after just 28 days, claiming the house was alive — oozing black slime, whispering at night, and feeding on fear. What happened inside 112 Ocean Avenue would become one of the most infamous haunted house stories in American history.

This week on Beyond the Campfire, Will and Steve step inside the Amityville Horror House to separate documented events from chilling testimony. From demonic voices and unexplained cold spots to alleged possession, levitation, and priestly encounters, they trace how the house’s dark reputation spread — and why investigators, skeptics, and believers still argue over what was real and what was imagined.

Was Amityville a genuine case of a demonic infestation… or a tragic crime followed by mass hysteria and media manipulation? As the story unfolds, one thing becomes clear: whether haunted or not, the Amityville house left scars that never truly faded — and some doors, once opened, refuse to close.

Follow Us:Instagram: @BeyondCampfireTwitter: @BeyondCampfire

On a freezing February night in 1978, five young men vanished in the Sierra Nevada mountains—only to leave behind one of the strangest cold cases in American history. Their abandoned car sat high on a remote mountain road they had no reason to be on, untouched and in perfect working condition. From there, the story only grows more baffling: scattered remains, a forest service cabin with untouched food and blankets… and miles of wilderness no one believes they willingly walked into.

In this episode of Beyond the Campfire, Will and Steve retrace the final known steps of the Yuba County Five. They dive into the timeline, the conflicting theories, and the chilling details that still haunt investigators decades later. Why did the men drive into the mountains? How did only some of them attempt to survive? And how did a case so well-documented become so utterly unexplainable?

As the night unfolds, the duo confronts the deepest mystery of all: what happened during those lost days in the woods… and why has no one ever been able to agree on an answer? This is a story where every detail raises another question—and where the truth feels just out of reach.

Follow Us:Instagram: @BeyondCampfireTwitter: @BeyondCampfire

With Sahil out this week, Will teams up with Editor Hailey for one of the strangest investigations Beyond the Campfire has ever tackled: the Montauk Project.
Together, they dive into the rumors surrounding Camp Hero, a decommissioned military base on the far edge of Long Island—an installation whispered to have hosted cold-war mind control experiments, psychic warfare research, time-bending technology, and something far more dangerous known only as “The Montauk Chair.”

As Will digs into witness accounts and government denials, Hailey brings a skeptic’s eye—until the pair follow a trail of testimonies that point to a runaway experiment, a missing boy, and a creature some believe slipped out of a ripped-open dimension.

By the end of the night, Will and Hailey begin to suspect the truth: not all the doors at Camp Hero stayed closed.

Follow Us:Instagram: @BeyondCampfireTwitter: @BeyondCampfire

Deep in the forests of New England lurks a creature older than the first tribes, older than the first settlers, older than the stories themselves. The Pukwudgie — small in stature, but deadly in intent — is said to stalk the woods with glowing eyes, poisoned darts, and a temper that flips from mischief to murder in a heartbeat. For centuries, Native legends warned travelers to stay away from the places where the forest suddenly goes quiet… because that’s where the Pukwudgie waits.

In this episode of Beyond the Campfire, Will and Steve break down the strange, unsettling reports tied to these woodland tricksters. From their connection to the Wampanoag people and the tragic tale of Maushop to modern encounters from hikers and hunters, the duo traces how a creature no taller than a child became one of the most feared beings in northeastern folklore. Shape-shifting, vanishing into thin air, luring people off trails — every story adds another layer to a legend that refuses to die.

As the cold winds of late autumn sweep through the trees, Will and Steve ask the question that every encounter seems to circle: are Pukwudgies merely stories told around campfires… or guardians of the woods who still watch from the shadows, waiting for anyone who wanders a little too far from the path?

Follow Us:Instagram: @BeyondCampfireTwitter: @BeyondCampfire

On October 25th, 1918, the SS Princess Sophia slipped beneath the freezing waters off Vanderbilt Reef, taking every one of its 353 passengers and crew to the bottom of the Lynn Canal. It remains the deadliest maritime disaster in the Pacific Northwest — a ship lost in blinding snow, brutal winds, and a silence that still hangs over the Alaskan coast. But the tragedy didn’t end with the sinking. Some say the dead never truly left.

This week on Beyond the Campfire, Will and Steve uncover the chilling hauntings that followed the catastrophe. When the bodies were brought to shore, Juneau’s small drug store was converted into a temporary morgue — and that’s when the whispers began. Footsteps after closing. Shadows drifting across the aisles. Cold breaths of air sweeping through locked rooms. Workers spoke of hearing muffled voices, as if dozens of souls were still waiting to be claimed. And on the shoreline near the wreck, fishermen still report figures standing in the fog — figures that vanish the moment the light touches them.

From the final distress calls to the lingering spirits said to echo through Juneau, the Princess Sophia’s story is a haunting reminder that some tragedies refuse to fade. As Will and Steve retrace the disaster, one question follows them through every icy detail: when a ship dies so violently, does the sea ever release what it takes?

Follow Us:Instagram: @BeyondCampfireTwitter: @BeyondCampfire

In the quiet villages of southern India, there’s a legend whispered after dark — a spirit that roams the streets at night, calling your name in the voice of someone you love. They call it Nale Ba, the “Come Tomorrow” ghost, a presence said to scratch at doors until the living answer. For generations, families have chalked warnings across their thresholds, praying the spirit passes by without choosing someone inside.

This week on Beyond the Campfire, Will and Steve dive into the chilling roots of the Nale Ba legend. From its origins in rural Karnataka to its spread through urban India, they unravel how this terrifying tale became one of the country’s most persistent pieces of night folklore. Was it born from real disappearances? A method of protecting women during dangerous times? Or something older — a fear woven into the fabric of every culture that’s ever believed the dead can come home?

As the two explore the meaning behind the midnight knock and the strange power of hearing your own name spoken in the dark, one thing becomes clear: Nale Ba isn’t just a ghost story. It’s a warning. Because some doors were never meant to be opened — especially when someone familiar is calling from the other side.

Follow Us:Instagram: @BeyondCampfireTwitter: @BeyondCampfire

November 10th, 1975 — the night the Great Lakes swallowed a legend. The Edmund Fitzgerald, once the pride of the fleet, vanished beneath the icy waves of Lake Superior without a single call for help. Twenty-nine men aboard, gone in an instant. To this day, no one knows for certain why.

This week on Beyond the Campfire, Will and Steve dig into one of the greatest maritime mysteries in American history. Was it a rogue wave, an undetected hull fracture, or a fatal navigation error that sealed the ship’s fate? Through survivor testimony from nearby vessels, Coast Guard reports, and the haunting final transmission from the Fitzgerald, they piece together the final hours before the storm took everything.

Half a century later, the wreck still rests in the cold dark of Superior — silent, intact, and surrounded by questions no one can answer. Some say it was the perfect storm. Others believe it was something far more human: pride, pressure, and one bad decision too many.

Follow Us:Instagram: @BeyondCampfireTwitter: @BeyondCampfire

In the Peruvian desert, beneath layers of time and dust, lie bodies unlike any ever discovered. Long, spindly fingers. Elongated skulls. Hollow eyes frozen in silence. They’re known as the Nazca Mummies, and their discovery ignited one of the most controversial mysteries in modern archaeology. Are they the remains of an ancient civilization lost to time—or something not entirely human?

This week on Beyond the Campfire, Will and Steve dig deep into the heart of the Nazca desert to uncover the truth behind the mummies that shook the scientific world. From secret excavations and disputed X-rays to theories of extraterrestrial contact, they explore every shadowy corner of this mystery. Could these beings be evidence of a forgotten race—or a carefully constructed hoax meant to rewrite history?

As the desert winds howl over the lines and tombs of Nazca, one truth remains buried: some secrets were never meant to be unearthed.

Follow Us:Instagram: @BeyondCampfireTwitter: @BeyondCampfire