This episode explores the biblical story of King Josiah (2 Kings 22-23). There are two powerful puzzles related to this story. 1) Why was the prophetess Huldah so negative and depressingly unhopeful? Jeremiah was prophesying great hope and salvation predicated on obedience at this same time! (Jer 7). Secondly, if Josiah was so pious (and he was!), why didn't God protect him in battle? Here, Josiah could hardly been a more pious and godly leader. He did his level best to follow the Torah laws by destroying all the idolatrous paraphernalia in Judah and establishing a Passover ceremony for the whole nation according to biblical law. And these laws promise blessings and prosperity to those who keep them (see Lev 26 and Deut 28). Yet Josiah, the great and godly king, went into battle and was promptly killed. The paradigm of divine retribution on parade in the Old Testament is clearly not working. So the whole notion of divine retribution is a paradigm in crisis and increasingly biblical writers question and reject it (Job and Ecclesiastes). Interestingly, when we read the NT, we find both Jesus and Paul have rejected the whole notion of divine retribution (Luke 13:1-4, John 9, Romans 8:18ff).
So the Bible itself has changed its mind (if we can say it that way). Within the Bible, we have a clear shift of opinions: sometimes the righteous suffer and the wicked prosper. The world is much more mysterious and ambiguous than you would believe reading the Old Testament. So, let's talk about changing your mind. Let's learn to do it well. Some people, when they decide to change their mind, completely reject everything they believed before. A better process might be to determine exactly what isn't working and what is (the old baby and bathwater idea).
Let me offer a few words of advice on changing your mind (its going to happen because we're human and don't know lots of things).
Do it in conversation with others - a community of faith.
Do it in conversation with scripture - What is revealed by scripture?
Do it with an awareness of the traditions of our church - What is illuminated by tradition? “Does the Book of Discipline or the Social Principles of our church address the topic?”
Be clear as to exactly your reasons - What is confirmed by reason?
Identify what, in your experience? - What is verified by my experience?
Be clear exactly what you’re leaving and what you’re hanging on it.
You’ll find Christ walking beside you every step of the way.