The New York Giants' recent woes have made it somewhat difficult for many to remember just how fantastic the franchise did to win four Super Bowl rings in five trips, starting with the 1986 edition that hammered the Denver Broncos (XXI) to grab its first Vince Lombardi Trophy.

So this was as good a time to jar the memory banks of those five title games and identify the players at each position who performed the best under the spotlight. And some of those decisions were quite a challenge!

Do you take Phil Simms, who had the most efficient Super Bowl game in history, or two-time Super Bowl MVP Eli Manning? To nobody's surprise, this was the most difficult choice because the three-member panel had to decide on just one quarterback.

Big Blue Breakdown host Paul Dottino, a veteran of 42 years on the New York Giants beat, corralled multi-year Pro Football Hall of Fame media finalist Vinny DiTrani (who covered the Giants for 34 years) and Patricia Traina, author of The Big 50: The Men and Moments That Made the New York Giants (and on the beat for 30+ years), to join him in creating this all-time Giants Super Bowl lineup.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy