Send us Fan Mail

We go deep on Booker’s Bourbon and put two 2026 batches head to head, chasing the uncut, unfiltered barrel-strength experience Booker Noe wanted people to taste. Big Easy Batch brings the classic Beam backbone while Milkshake Batch surprises us with dessert-like sweetness that still feels unmistakably Booker’s.

• why Booker’s stands out as uncut, unfiltered, barrel strength bourbon with real batch variation 
• where Booker’s comes from in the Jim Beam lineup and why the flavor profile is a bourbon benchmark 
• pricing and availability differences across states and how we track releases 
• details and story behind Booker's 2026-01 Big Easy Batch plus full tasting notes 
• details and story behind Booker's 2026-02 Milkshake Batch plus why it “drinks below proof” 
• our Barrel Bottle Breakdown scoring for nose, body, taste, finish and how a “butt up up” works 
• the rare tie at 18 out of 18 and the tiebreaker chart that crowns the final winner 
• rapid-fire verdicts on best nose, best finish, most “Booker’s” profile and which bottle to bunker 

www.scotchybourbonboys.com for all things scotchy bourbon boys. If you listen on Apple, please 100% leave us a five-star review. 

A barrel-proof showdown that somehow turns into a tie, then a dessert-bourbon debate. We pour Booker’s 2026-01 Big Easy Batch against Booker’s 2026-02 Milkshake Batch and chase the exact thing Booker Noe intended: an uncut, unfiltered, straight-from-the-barrel style bourbon experience that doesn’t hide behind proofing or filtration.

First up, Big Easy Batch (129.1 proof) brings a more classic Jim Beam Booker’s profile, backed by a New Orleans-inspired story and tasting notes that lean roasted peanut on the nose with baking spice and a punch of cherry that reads like cherry cola. On the palate and finish, we get bold structure, oak-driven grip, and that long Kentucky hug that makes Booker’s feel like a “main meal” pour, not a sweet treat.

Then Milkshake Batch (124.4 proof) shifts the whole mood. The batch story ties back to Booker’s chocolate malted milkshake tradition, and the whiskey follows through with creamy vanilla, caramel sweetness, toasted oak, and a malt-like note that makes the name click. It drinks below its proof, feels unusually approachable for barrel strength bourbon, and pushes Booker’s into a sweeter direction without losing the house character.

We score both using our Barrel Bottle Breakdown for nose, body, taste, and finish, land at 18 out of 18 for both, then go to a tiebreaker chart across sweetness, fruit, oak, dessert, complexity, and drinkability to crown a winner. Listen now, then subscribe, share the show with a bourbon friend, and leave us a review with your pick: Big Easy or Milkshake?

If You Have Gohsts

voice over Whiskey Thief

Support the show

https://www.scotchybourbonboys.com

The Scotchy bourbon Boys are #3 in Feedspots Top 60 whiskey podcasts in the world    https://podcast.feedspot.com/whiskey_podcasts/