Big Think

Big Think

By Big Think
Download on the App Store

Big Think episodes

  • Why flat-Earth theory & anti-vax conspiracies exist | Michio Kaku | Most Talked About 2019
    Why flat-Earth theory and anti-vax conspiracies exist
    Watch the newest video from Big Think: https://bigth.ink/NewVideo
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    If you see animals when you look at clouds or see faces in pieces of wood, that's called pareidolia: the phenomenon of making familiar objects from vague stimuli. Humans evolved to be superstitious, and Michio Kaku posits that there is a gene for superstition and magical thinking. Nine times out of 10, your beliefs can be wrong, but one time out of 10 it saved your ancestors' butts, says Kaku. Flat Earthers and anti-vaccination conspiracy theorists exist now, and they will still exist in 1,000 years, says Kaku. It's natural. Humans evolved to believe in nonsense, but it's by becoming good at something totally unnatural to us – science – that reason can prevail.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    MICHIO KAKU
    Dr. Michio Kaku is the co-founder of string field theory, and is one of the most widely recognized scientists in the world today. He has written 4 New York Times Best Sellers, is the science correspondent for CBS This Morning and has hosted numerous science specials for BBC-TV, the Discovery/Science Channel. His radio show broadcasts to 100 radio stations every week. Dr. Kaku holds the Henry Semat Chair and Professorship in theoretical physics at the City College of New York (CUNY), where he has taught for over 25 years. He has also been a visiting professor at the Institute for Advanced Study as well as New York University (NYU). His latest book: https://amzn.to/2rY0Wgz
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT
    MICHIO KAKU: We still have Flat Earthers, we have people that don't believe in vaccinations, and what do we do about it? Well, first of all, I think there's a gene. I think there's a gene for superstition, a gene for hearsay, a gene for magic, a gene for magical thinking. And I think that, when we were in the forest, that gene actually helped us. Because 9 times out of 10, that gene was wrong. Superstition didn't work. But 1 time out of 10, it saved your butt. That's why the gene is still here, the gene for superstition and magic.
    Now, there's no gene for science. Science is based on things that are reproducible, testable -- it's a long process, the scientific method. It's not part of our natural thinking. It's an acquired taste, just like broccoli. You have to learn how the power can be unleashed by looking at your diet, for example. So I think 1,000 years from now, 1,000 years from now, we will have Flat Earthers. A thousand years from now, we will have people that still do not want to be vaccinated. OK? So what do we do about it?
    Well, it's a struggle. It's a struggle that's eternal, because I think it's part of our genetic makeup. And there's even a name for some of this superstition. It's called pareidolia. What is pareidolia? It's the idea that when you look in the sky, you see things that are not there. Here's one experiment: Look at the clouds and try not to see something there. It's very difficult. You look at the clouds. You can't help it. You see Donald Duck. You see Mickey Mouse. You see snakes, animals. You see all sorts of stuff. You can't help it. Recently, the Notre Dame Cathedral partially burned down. And sure enough, somebody said, 'I see Jesus Christ there.' I saw the picture. Maybe you did, too. It really did look like Jesus Christ. But it was the ashes of Notre Dame. And how many times do people see the Virgin Mary in a glass of tea? So we are hardwired to see things that are not there. Because for the most part, they're harmless. For the most part, they do nothing. And once in a while, it saves our butt.
    And so that's why I think we will have Flat Earthers, we will have the people who don't like vaccination, because hearsay throughout human history was the dominant form of information-sharing. You know, the internet is very new. Newspapers are very new. Science and technology is very new. But gossip, hearsay, slander, rumors, there's a gene for that. OK? So how do you combat it? Slowly, carefully, painfully -- it's a painful process, but in some sense, we're going up against our genetic predisposition to believe in nonsense.
    4 min
  • Who decides whether art is ‘good’ or ‘bad’? | A.O. Scott | Big Think
    Who decides whether art is ‘good’ or ‘bad’?
    Watch the newest video from Big Think: https://bigth.ink/NewVideo
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    "Taste" in art and entertainment can often represent societal hierarchies, prejudices, and inequalities.
    Part of the job of a critic is to refuse categorization of art as "high" or "low."
    By challenging and redefining these assumptions, critics can level the playing field to include work from all walks of life.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    A.O. SCOTT
    A.O. Scott joined The New York Times as a film critic in January 2000, and was named a chief critic in 2004. Previously, Mr. Scott had been the lead Sunday book reviewer for Newsday and a frequent contributor to Slate, The New York Review of Books, and many other publications.
    Mr. Scott was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize in Criticism in 2010, the same year he served as co-host (with Michael Phillips of the Chicago Tribune) on the last season of "At the Movies," the syndicated film-reviewing program started by Roger Ebert and Gene Siskel.
    A frequent presence on radio and television, Mr. Scott is Distinguished Professor of Film Criticism at Wesleyan University and the author of Better Living Through Criticism (2016, Penguin Press)
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Follow Big Think here:
    📰BigThink.com: https://bigth.ink
    🧔Facebook: https://bigth.ink/facebook
    🐦Twitter: https://bigth.ink/twitter
    📸Instagram: https://bigth.ink/Instragram
    📹YouTube: https://bigth.ink/youtube
    ✉ E-mail: [email protected]
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Transcript: I think that taste hierarchies do exist and they're almost always the kind of the representation of other sorts of hierarchies and assumptions. And that's why I really think that part of the job of criticism is to be against them, is to refuse, at least the categorization of things as high and low.
    I think it was Duke Ellington who's often quoted as saying, "There are two kinds of music; good music and bad in music." And everything else is kind of sociology and politics and prejudice and snobbery kind of sneaking in. And we're none of us immune to those things. We live in the world we associate with, who we associate with; we identify ourselves as we identify ourselves. But I think that the job of critics and of criticism is to kind of to push against that. And it has just even historically been the job of critics very often or of criticism to insist on the value and the dignity and the importance of works of art and types of works of art that had been neglected or ignored or disrespected. And it's in fact the rise of criticism, within any of those arts, that gets it to be taken seriously.
    Movies are a great example. I mean movies, you know, nobody took movies seriously except like maybe in Germany in the '20s as an art form. And it was critics first in France and then in the United States after the Second World War who said well look no, this junk that's been coming out of Hollywood actually this is a significant modern art form. These people whose names you just see in the credits, Howard Hawks, Alfred Hitchcock, John Ford, Orson Welles, these are artists. This is art. And it was critics who were able to do that and I think jazz critics and rock critics and people who have written about hip-hop and television have done that work too of recategorizing and redefining and challenging the hierarchical assumptions about what is high art and what is low.
    The thing that's great about movies is that they are high and low and that they run, you know, there's a very wide spectrum from the most crassly commercial genre of products and the most refined and difficult works of art. And the thing that you discover when you write about criticism is that sometimes the ones that are very low are actually, you know, fantastic works of art and the ones that are very high can be just as terrible and a hacky and stupid as anything else.
    4 min
  • How to parent like a comedian, Gaffigan style | Jeannie Gaffigan | Big Think
    How to parent like a comedian, Gaffigan style.
    Watch the newest video from Big Think: https://bigth.ink/NewVideo
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Sometimes if we bring our own point of view into someone else's act, it's not funny. It's funny through their vantage point.
    Although Jeannie Gaffigan can channel her husband Jim Gaffigan in writing content for his standup act, she sometimes disagrees with his point of view — even though she knows it's funny.
    Similarly to their differing styles of comedy — Jeannie is more of an essayist, Jim is more of an observational comedian — they also have differing parenting strategies. Whereas Jeannie believes more in a "reward-punishment situation," Jim believes "get rid of all the iPads." They have different points of views of what will motivate their children, but they compromise.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    JEANNIE GAFFIGAN
    It was only by chance that Jeannie Gaffigan found out she had a pear-sized tumor on her brain stem. During a visit to her kid's pediatrician, the doctor noticed something off about Jeannie Gaffigan's hearing, which led to the diagnosis.
    She needed to have immediate brain surgery. Gaffigan describes this highly stressful and uncertain time in her as traumatic—and deeply hilarious, says Gaffigan. Comedy, she says, can be used to process your traumas.
    A comedy writer by trade, she obsessively documented the experience and asked people who visited her in hospital to make notes and lists, which she later turned into her memoir When Life Gives You Pears.
    Jeannie Gaffigan is a director, producer and comedy writer. She co-wrote seven comedy specials with her husband Jim Gaffigan, the last four of which received Grammy nominations. Jeannie was the head writer and executive producer of the critically acclaimed The Jim Gaffigan Show, which was loosely based on her and Jim's life. She collaborated with Jim on two New York Times bestsellers, Dad Is Fat and Food: A Love Story. Jeannie, with the help of her two eldest children and some other crazy moms, created The Imagine Society, Inc., a not-for-profit organization that connects youth-led service groups. Most impressively, she grew a tumor on her brain stem roughly the size of a pear.
    Jeannie presently lives in New York City with her five children, two dogs, and one “superdad” husband, Jim Gaffigan.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT: Co-parenting as comedians is just completely unique to our own situation because we are, Jim and I are actually really different comedians. I know that sounds really weird because we write together and a lot of times especially with all the standup, that’s all his point of view. So I can really write in Jim’s point of view. If I bring my point of view into Jim’s comedy it’s not funny. I’m funny as Jim but in Jim’s point of view. In Jim’s show I can make observations within his point of view like here is something that you would say in this situation that would be really funny but a lot of the things that he has, kind of his MO are things that really disagree with. I disagree with a lot of his funniness even though I know it’s funny. But my lifestyle I would never do some of the things or make the observations that he makes. I have like a Ph.D. in Jim Gaffigan. Like I know what he finds funny. I mean I can’t do what he does. He’s the head writer of his comedy. I know what my role is and I know that I make it better, but I do it as Jim.
    Conversely, when we were writing, when he was writing Dad Is Fat which is the, it’s a bestselling book called Dad Is Fat that he wrote about being a father of five kids in a two bedroom apartment. And I was there in the two bedroom apartment so I knew what he was doing and what was funny. But that’s when we really found out that he is the observational comedian and the wordsmith and I’m the essayist. I am the storyteller. Like it was pretty clear that we needed to stay working together because it was just enhancing everything we did. I brought a little bit more of a storytelling aspect to the standup comedy as well as the books. And he also in my storytelling could be like you know what’s really funny, you know, I wrote the book but he read it and wrote some notes in the margin. I’m like oh, now you’re me but you’re doing the wordsmithing and I’m doing the storytelling rather than you doing the wordsmithing and I’m coming in at the end with the storytelling. And I think that our collaboration became very, very clear when we wrote the Jim Gaffigan Show because now it was Jim as a character, Jeannie as a character and all these other crazy characters and the kids as characters. Read Full Transcript: https://bigthink.com/videos/jeannie-gaffigan-parenting
    5 min
  • Why conspiratorial thinking is peaking in America | Sarah Rose Cavanagh | Big Think
    Why conspiratorial thinking is peaking in America
    Watch the newest video from Big Think: https://bigth.ink/NewVideo
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    The internet has allowed fringe groups founded on paranoid thinking to merge in ways we've never seen before.
    Part of modern political polarization in American is that we're becoming a people who believes in different realities, some of which are based on fears rather than facts. Many of these conspiracy theories are targeted on groups that we believe are plotting against us.
    There is a romanticization that we're going to somehow solve all of life's unknowns, Da Vinci Code-style. However, this ironically may put us at a disadvantage in terms of breaking puzzles — we look for the familiar in vague stimuli, a phenomenon known as pareidolia, which only further confounds us.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    DR. SARAH ROSE CAVANAGH
    Dr. Sarah Rose Cavanagh is a psychologist, professor, writer, and Associate Director for grants and research for the Center for Teaching Excellence at Assumption College. Her research focuses on affective science, specifically emotion regulation and mood and anxiety disorders. Dr. Cavanagh is the author of Hivemind: The New Science of Tribalism In Our Divided World, (Grand Central Publishing, 2019) and The Spark of Learning: Energizing the College Classroom with the Science of Emotion, (West Virginia University Press, 2016). She lives in Massachusetts.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT: Rather than look at reality and agree on one whole reality we’re becoming a society where we have these different groups that believe in different realities. And that is a big part of political polarization where people don’t just agree about their opinions, disagree about the opinions about a series of facts but they disagree about whether the facts are actually true. But we can also see it in conspiracy thinking where these fringe groups, or at least they used to be fringe groups on kind of the outskirts of thinking about what could be real or what is happening, paranoid thinking for instance.
    Thinking about reptoids controlling our government. There have always been people who believe these sort of strange things but what social media and the internet in general has allowed to happen is for people with these beliefs to find each other and then when they’re hearing back those same sorts of facts or same sorts of theories then their beliefs strengthen. One thing that is particularly alarming that’s happening is what Michael Barkun calls fusion paranoia where these fringe groups who might have believed in aliens and these others that might have believed in reptoids and these others that may have believed that the JFK conspiracy are merging and that’s kind of alarming to me.
    Jesse Walker wrote a wonderful book, The United States of Paranoia in which he classifies the various types of paranoid thinking that have occurred in our country right since our very founding. He classifies them into four different types. Enemies outside, enemies within, enemies above and enemies below. All of them involve fear. All of them involve belief in conspiracy style thinking but they vary in their sources. So the enemies above are those that have more power than us and they’re trying to control our lives. So pharmaceuticals, creating vaccines just to make money rather than to help people is an example of the enemies above. Enemy below tends to be people who have less power, who we have oppressed or who don’t have a lot of power kind of rising up and overthrowing things. Outside is immigration, people who are unlike us that might come and infiltrate us. Enemies within are people like secret communists or witches during the Salem witch trial. People who look like us, seem to be embedded in our society but actually are plotting against us.
    I think that fear is an incredibly dangerous emotion. I think that it causes us to narrow our thinking. I think it causes us to shutdown options and there are a lot of threats in the world but I think what we need to face those threats are open, creative, playful thinking. When we think as a hivemind, when we think collectively and we do so in a fearful sense then that shuts down a lot of our thinking.
    One thing that I think we tend to do is we think that we’re going to be the person who is going to crack a big mystery, who’s going to solve a whole puzzle. I think that Hollywood has given us this idea and the famous book and movie, The Da Vinci Code sold us on this that we were going to be the hero who would figure everything out, this big vast conspiracy. . Read Full Transcript Here: https://bigthink.com/videos/conspiracy
    5 min
  • John Cleese: ‘Does it make you laugh?’ | Big Think
    John Cleese: ‘Does it make you laugh?’
    Watch the newest video from Big Think: https://bigth.ink/NewVideo
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    People have very subjective senses of humor, which means some jokes may be funny to certain people but not at all for others.
    It can be hard to notice just how subject humor is because laughter has an infectious effect on people. This phenomenon is especially true in large groups of people.
    When it comes to reviewing what jokes to put into a show, test it on friends and family to see which parts evoke laughs from them and which parts don't.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    JOHN CLEESE
    John Marwood Cleese is an English actor, comedian, writer and film producer. He achieved success at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe and as a scriptwriter and performer on The Frost Report. In the late 1960s, he co-founded Monty Python, the comedy troupe responsible for the sketch show Monty Python's Flying Circus and the four Monty Python films: And Now for Something Completely Different, Monty Python and the Holy Grail, Life of Brian and The Meaning of Life.
    In the mid-1970s, Cleese and his first wife, Connie Booth, co-wrote and starred in the British sitcom Fawlty Towers. Later, he co-starred with Kevin Kline, Jamie Lee Curtis and former Python colleague Michael Palin in A Fish Called Wanda and Fierce Creatures, both of which he also wrote. He also starred in Clockwise, and has appeared in many other films, including two James Bond films as Q, two Harry Potter films, and the last three Shrek films.
    With Yes Minister writer Antony Jay he co-founded Video Arts, a production company making entertaining training films. In 1976, Cleese co-founded The Secret Policeman's Ball benefit shows to raise funds for the human rights organisation Amnesty International.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Follow Big Think here:
    📰BigThink.com: https://bigth.ink
    🧔Facebook: https://bigth.ink/facebook
    🐦Twitter: https://bigth.ink/twitter
    📸Instagram: https://bigth.ink/Instragram
    📹YouTube: https://bigth.ink/youtube
    ✉ E-mail: [email protected]
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT: The trouble is that people have very subjective senses of humor. And when I'm onstage doing my one man show I show clips from stuff I've done in the past. And because I don't have to speak or do anything while the clips are being played I sit and watch the audience because I can see the first three or four rows in the light that's coming from the screen. And the extraordinary thing is how varied their reactions are. He'll be roaring with laughter. She'll be roaring with laughter. He'll be looking pleasantly amused. Nothing there at all. Maybe they don't get it. Maybe they don't think it's funny. And someone they're laughing a little bit here and there. Then there's a big laugh. But he doesn't laugh. And then a minute later he roars with laughter at something that nobody else is laughing at. So it's much more subjective than you think. But when you're in a large group of people you don't notice it so much because laughter has an infectious effect on people.
    So the first thing is you can't say it's funny or it's not funny because it could be funny for one person and not funny for another. What you can say is I think it's funny and then you extrapolate from that. I think enough people will find it funny for it to be worth us putting this show on.
    In my case it was also true when we got together at the beginning of Monty Python where we had no idea what we are going to do, what was funny was what made us laugh. People brought material in that they'd written over the previous six or seven days. We sat around a big table at Terry Jones's place and if people laughed it was in the show and if they didn't laugh it wasn't. And if they laughed at bits of it we say well can we use the funny bit and get rid of the rest, which is why we started cutting the ends of sketches and all that kind of thing. So that was the best criteria is, does it make you laugh?
    3 min
  • Yann Martel: ‘Transgression is central to art’ | Big Think
    Transgression is central to art
    New videos DAILY: https://bigth.ink/youtube
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Man Booker Prize-winning writer Yann Martel, a Canadian man, has written from the perspectives of a man with AIDS, a body-switching woman, an Indian boy, and 20th-century Portuguese widowers.
    Is it acceptable to write from the perspective of someone who is completely unlike you? Martel believes these transgressions put empathetic imagination into practice, allowing your mind to go where your body cannot.
    In Martel's case, it's the recipe for great art—books that have been loved and read by millions. "[W]e are who we are in relation to others," says Martel. "But the key thing is the empathetic imagination, and the empathetic imagination is the great traveler. And travelers necessarily cross borders. And not only do they have to but it's a thrill to do so. It's a thrill encountering the other."
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    YANN MARTEL
    Yann Martel is the author of The High Mountains of Portugal and Life of Pi, the #1 international bestseller and winner of the 2002 Man Booker (among many other prizes). He is also the award-winning author ofThe Facts Behind the Helsinki Roccamatios (winner of the Journey Prize), Self, Beatrice & Virgil, and 101 Letters to a Prime Minister. Born in Spain in 1963, Martel studied philosophy at Trent University, worked at odd jobs—tree planter, dishwasher, security guard—and traveled widely before turning to writing. He lives in Saskatoon, Canada, with the writer Alice Kuipers and their four children.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Transcript: I think transgression is central to art. In art you cross borders and I’ve done that constantly in my fiction. So, for example, my first book was a collection of short stories and in it were the main stories about two students, one of whom as a result of a blood transfusion gets AIDS and he slowly spirals towards death. And the two encounter each other. His friend visits him every week in the hospital and they start telling themselves a story set in Finland about this Italian family in Finland. And to give it backbone they say that each episode in the story of that family must resemble one historical episode of the twentieth century. So in the first episode of this family, the Helsinki’s of Roccamatios it has to imitate 1901. And in 1901 Queen Victoria died. So in the family, in the Helsinki family Roccamatios the patriarch dies. So it creates this parallel. And so right away you have a setting here. Here I’m a Canadian writer and I’m writing about a fictitious Italian family in Finland and they’re using historical parallels that come from all over the world. Right away I’m exploring realities that are different from mine. It’s even more obvious with my next book which is my first novel called Self.
    In Self you have a boy who’s traveling, he’s backpacking, he’s 17. He’s starting very young. And on his eighteenth birthday he wakes up and he’s a girl, he’s a young woman. And he’s a young woman for seven years. And then he becomes a man again. And his gender orientation starts to vary too. Initially when he’s a young woman he’s thinking as a heterosexual male so he’s attracted to women. So sorry, she’s attracted to women. And then slowly her orientation starts to shift and she’s attracted rather uncomfortably to young men. And the first time she kisses a young man the first thought that pops into her head is I’m gay. Because in her mind, in her thinking she’s still a male and she’s kissing a male therefore she’s gay. But in fact she has the body of a woman. So conventionally she’s heterosexual. And then when she switches back to a man again once again the slide takes place. And so there I was very obviously exploring a front, a border that I haven’t crossed myself. With my mind I went somewhere else. I was interested in exploring what it means to be a man, what it means to be a woman, where does sexual orientation come from.
    I was exploring the idea that the body is an environment to which we adapt. Just as people adapt to hot climates to cold climates we adapt to our bodies. So there’s a very obvious example of transgression. I went with my mind where I couldn’t with my own body. And the point of that is that with the empathetic imagination we can go where nothing else can go. And therefore we can bring back truths that you can’t actually bring back factually. And I’ve continued that with my other books. Life of Pi of course is a story of an Indian boy in a lifeboat with a tiger in the Pacific. None of those are true to me. I’m neither Indian. I’ve never been a castaway. I’ve never been in close proximity to a cat, to a big cat, to a tiger. Read Full Transcript Here: https://bigthink.com/videos/yann-martel
    4 min
  • Salman Rushdie: ‘Write for readers, not for critics’ | Big Think
    Salman Rushdie: ‘Write for readers, not for critics’
    New videos DAILY: https://bigth.ink
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive video lessons from top thinkers and doers: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Booker Prize-winning author Salman Rushdie recounts his evolution as a writer who has grown more aware of the reader and less aware of the critic.
    Literary reviews, famously the Times Literary Supplement, were once anonymous—and brutal. Once the Times started publishing bylines with reviews, critics suddenly got much nicer.
    Anonymity, especially online, is a double-edged sword. In authoritarian societies, it gives people great freedom. However anonymity is also the reason people say things online they would never say if they were in a room with you. That may be a degrading force in a highly digital society.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    SALMAN RUSHDIE
    Salman Rushdie is a British-Indian novelist and writer, author of ten novels including Midnight’s Children (Booker Prize, 1981), Two Years Eight Months and Twenty-Eight Nights, and The Golden House.
    The publication of his fourth novel "The Satanic Verses" in 1988 led to violent protests in the Muslim world for its depiction of the prophet Mohammad. The Supreme Leader of Iran, Ayatollah Khomeini, issued a death fatwa against Rushdie, which sent him into hiding for nearly a decade. Rushdie weathered countless death threats and many assassination attempts.
    In June 2007, he was knighted by Queen Elizabeth. In 2008 he became a member of the American Academy of Arts and Letters and was named a Library Lion of the New York Public Library. In addition, "Midnight’s Children" was named the Best of the Booker—the best prize-winner in the award’s 40 year history—by a public vote. In 2008, The Times of London ranked Rushdie thirteenth on their list of "The 50 greatest British writers since 1945."
    Purchase "Two Years Eight Months and Twenty-Eight Nights, and The Golden House" here: https://amzn.to/35b0JF6
    Transcript: You can’t really afford to think about criticism when you’re writing a book. It’s actually just too hard to write the book, to try to also second guess how people will respond to it. But I think I have quite a good sense of readers. And I think as I’ve gotten older I’ve become more and more interested in exactly how people read and what is likely to put them off and what is likely to entice them. And I’ve become sort of more conscious of the reader, you know. I think when I was younger I was just doing my thing and if readers showed up that was fine and if not that was fine too. I had a kind of very much tougher attitude towards it. But now I’m really interested in reading, in the phenomenon of reading and how if you give people information in the correct sequence you can tell them very complicated things, you know, and they’ll find those things accessible and relatable and they’ll want to find out. I mean for instance in my case I’ve always thought that comedy helps a lot. I think if you can make people laugh you can tell them almost anything. And if you can’t make them laugh there’s not a lot they want to listen to. So that’s one thing. But critics, I mean on a kind of critical response I really, you know, I can’t think about. I mean you get to this age you realize that there are people who will not like what you do no matter what you do.
    So I know that I could write the best book I’ve ever written and there will be some people who just won’t like it and that’s fair enough, you know. That’s why there are many different kinds of books in bookstores so people can choose what they like. So I don’t bother with that too much. I really don’t bother with critical response. I also think you get to a point when you’ve written a number of books where you become quite clear about the direction you want to go in. So my view is, you know, I’d like to go this way at the moment and I really hope that you’d like to come along. I really hope that you would enjoy the journey and so on and so on. But if you for whatever reason can’t come along on that journey then I’m still going this way. And then you just take what comes. I think on the whole it’s about an even break. I could tell you usually in advance where I’m going to get trashed and I’m usually right. But I sort of don’t care.
    I mean I remember in a kind of pre-Internet age there was a point where various literary magazines used to publish reviews anonymously and most famously the Times Literary Supplement would never name its critics. The idea being that it was simply the Times Literary Supplement that was giving its opinion of your work rather than any individual.
    Read Full Transcript Here: https://bigthink.com/videos/salman-rushie-write-for-readers-not-for-critics
    6 min
  • Will robots have rights in the future? | Peter Singer | Big Think
    Will robots have rights in the future?
    New videos DAILY: https://bigth.ink/youtube
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    If eventually we develop artificial intelligence sophisticated enough to experience emotions like joy and suffering, should we grant it moral rights just as any other sentient being?
    Theoretical philosopher Peter Singer predicts the ethical issues that could ensue as we expand the circle of moral concern to include these machines.
    A free download of the 10th anniversary edition of The Life You Can Save: How to Do Your Part to End World Poverty is available here: https://www.thelifeyoucansave.org/the-book/.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    PETER SINGER
    Peter Singer is the founder of The Life You Can Save, an organization that aims to help change the culture of giving in affluent countries and increase donations to reputable and effective nonprofits. "The Life You Can Save: How to Do Your Part to End World Poverty: 10th Anniversary Edition" is available here: https://amzn.to/33Wdx0s
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Follow Big Think here:
    📰BigThink.com: https://bigth.ink
    🧔Facebook: https://bigth.ink/facebook
    🐦Twitter: https://bigth.ink/twitter
    📸Instagram: https://bigth.ink/Instragram
    📹YouTube: https://bigth.ink/youtube
    ✉ E-mail: [email protected]
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT: If we become capable of developing artificial general intelligence at such a high level that we’re convinced we have actually created a conscious being, a being who can not only sort of express desires or wants but actually feels something inside, has experiences, is capable of feeling joy or sorrow or misery. If we get to that point and I certainly don’t think we’re there yet but we may get there one day. Then there will be a lot of ethical issues because then we will have created beings like us. And the question has to be raised so do they then have rights like us. And I would say well, why not. If they really are conscious and if they’re also able to think, understand themselves. If they’re self-aware in the way we are then I think we ought to give as much concern and weight to their interests and their wants as we would give to any one of us.
    I’ve argued that throughout history we have expanded the circle of moral concern from initially it just being our own tribe to a nation race and now all human beings. And I’ve been arguing for expanding beyond just human beings to all sentient creatures, all beings capable of feeling pain, enjoying their life, feeling miserable. And that obviously includes many nonhuman animals. If we get to create robots that are also capable of feeling pain then that will be somewhere else that we have to push the circle of moral concern backwards because I certainly think we would have to include them in our moral concern once we’ve actually created beings with capacities, desires, wants, enjoyments, miseries that are similar to ours.
    Exactly where we would place robots would depend on what capacities we believe they have. I can imagine that we might create robots that are limited to the intelligence level of nonhuman animals, perhaps not the smartest nonhuman animals either. They could still perform routine tasks for us. They could fetch things for us on voice command. That’s not very hard to imagine. But I don’t think that that would be a sentient being necessarily. And so if it was just a robot that we understood how exactly that worked it’s not very far from what we have now. I don’t think it would be entitled to any rights or moral status. But if it was at a higher level than that, if we were convinced that it was a conscious being then the kind of moral status it would have would depend on exactly what level of consciousness and what level of awareness. Is it more like a pig, for example. Well, then it should have the same rights as a pig which, by the way, I think we are violating every day on a massive scale by the way we treat pigs in factory farms. So I’m not saying such a robot should be treated like pigs are being treated in our society today.
    On the contrary. It should be treated with respect for their desires and awareness and their capacities to feel pain and their social nature. All of those things that we ought to take into account when we are responsible for the lives of pigs. Also, we would have to take into account when we’re responsible for the lives of robots at a similar level. But if we created robots who were at our level then I think we would have to give them really the same rights that we have. There would be no justification for saying ah yes, but we’re a biological creature and you’re a robot. I don’t think that has anything to do with the moral status of a being.
    5 min
  • What detoxifies a negative work environment? | Simon Sinek
    What detoxifies a negative work environment?
    Watch the newest video from Big Think: https://bigth.ink/NewVideo
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Trust is necessary for a healthy and efficient work environment.
    This trust emerges when not only do we feel safe within our company, but that our leaders genuinely care about us.
    Establishing these relationships requires vulnerability and honesty from both leaders and their employees.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    SIMON O. SINEK
    Simon O. Sinek is an author best known for popularizing the concept of "the golden circle" and to "Start With Why," described by TED as "a simple but powerful model for inspirational leadership all starting with a golden circle and the question "Why?"'. He joined the RAND Corporation in 2010 as an adjunct staff member, where he advises on matters of military innovation and planning. His first TEDx Talk on "How Great Leaders Inspire Action" is the 3rd most viewed video on TED.com. His 2009 book on the same subject, Start With Why: How Great Leaders Inspire Everyone to Take Action (2009) delves into what he says is a naturally occurring pattern, grounded in the biology of human decision-making, that explains why we are inspired by some people, leaders, messages and organizations over others.
    He has commented for The New York Times, Wall Street Journal, The Washington Post, Houston Chronicle, FastCompany, CMO Magazine, NPR, and BusinessWeek, and is a regular contributor to The Huffington Post, BrandWeek, and IncBizNet.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Transcript: When we talk about a trusting team or trusting partners I think very often we forget that trust is not an instruction. Trust is a feeling. You cannot tell someone to trust you. No leader can just tell their company trust me. It doesn’t work that way. Trust is a feeling. It’s a biological feeling that comes from the environment we’re in. When we feel safe in our own environment, when we feel that our leaders care about us as human beings and want to see us grow and build our confidence in our skills, when we feel safe in our own companies, trust emerges. It’s what happens. When we do not feel save in our own companies, when we feel that our leaders would soon as sacrifice us to save numbers rather than sacrifice numbers to save us the human response to those conditions is cynicism, paranoia, mistrust and self-interest. And so if we want to build trusting teams we have to create environments. Leaders have to set an environment in which the people feel safe amongst themselves and from us.
    There’s much discussion about this concept of vulnerability at work. We have to be vulnerable we’re told. That doesn’t mean walking around crying. What vulnerability means is saying things like I don’t know what I’m doing. It means like you put me in a job and I don’t know how to do that job. It means raising your hand and saying I made a mistake. These put us in a vulnerable position, especially in a work world in which layoffs are used so casually that I feel like I’m on a short list. And so we would rather not express any sense of weakness whether it’s fear or doubt or mistakes that we’ve made or lack of skills. We just keep it to ourselves and too many of us spend our days lying, hiding and faking. The irony is our attempt to present ourselves as strong every day means the company itself will get weak. Because if no one is admitting mistakes, those mistakes will compound. If people are doing jobs that they don’t know how to do and they’re lying, hiding and faking that means the output will be weak. The irony is is when people hide their fallibility, their humanity it actually makes the company weak. But when we create environments in which people feel safe enough to say to their boss I need help or I don’t know what I’m doing or I made a mistake. The amazing thing is that actually makes the organization stronger.
    So the question is how do we if we do not work in an environment that offers us that safe circle that we can express ourselves thusly then the question is what are we supposed to do? Well it’s kind of like any human relationship. You don’t start on the first date telling them all of your fears and anxieties and insecurities. That would be madness, right. You get to know somebody first. And then as you get to know them you take a little risk and you share something small. And you see if they listen and they make you feel understood and they make you feel heard. Or if they make you feel stupid or small. And if it feels safe you take another little risk and another little risk and they take a risk. If you’re the only one doing it it doesn’t work either.
    For the full transcript, check out https://bigthink.com/videos/toxic-work-
    4 min
  • How to test yourself in the battle of ideas | Nicholas Christakis | Big Think
    Can you defend your ideas?
    New videos DAILY: https://bigth.ink
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive video lessons from top thinkers and doers: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    When we're convinced in the truth of our ideas, we often believe if we just explain it to others that others will immediately come on board with them, says Nicholas Christakis. However, what we see in practice is that we need some resistance from others to help refine those ideas. In doing so, we make them more marketable in the marketplace of ideas. During debates, remember not to censor your opponents. We have to be confident enough to have discussions with them aimed at getting at the truth. When we prohibit the expression of ideas, we lose the chance to prove our ideas right—we lose the chance to advance their legitimacy in the court of public opinion.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    NICHOLAS CHRISTAKIS
    Nicholas A. Christakis is a physician, sociologist, and director of the Human Nature Lab at Yale University, where he is the Sterling Professor of Social and Natural Science. His most recent book is Blueprint: The Evolutionary Origins of a Good Society (March 2019). Follow him on Twitter @NAChristakis
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    2 min