Big Think

Big Think

By Big Think
Download on the App Store

Big Think episodes

  • Is the universe a hologram? The strange physics of black holes | Michelle Thaller | Big Think
    Is the universe a hologram? The strange physics of black holes
    New videos DAILY: https://bigth.ink
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive video lessons from top thinkers and doers: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Since energy cannot be destroyed, only transformed, some argue that information — arguably a form of energy — cannot be destroyed either. So then, what happens to information when it is absorbed into a black hole? Scientists don't know for certain, but some posit that it may be possible for it to leak away from the black hole over time. Black holes may hold information in a two-dimensional manner similar to a hologram, which take on three dimensions when light is shone through them. Some theorize that the underlying nature of reality can be glimpsed through black holes — that all the information about the entire universe is somehow held on a two-dimensional space of something.
    To better understand how black holes work, as well as the elements surrounding them, we may need a level of physics to be developed.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    MICHELLE THALLER
    Dr. Michelle Thaller is an astronomer who studies binary stars and the life cycles of stars. She is Assistant Director of Science Communication at NASA. She went to college at Harvard University, completed a post-doctoral research fellowship at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech) in Pasadena, Calif. then started working for the Jet Propulsion Laboratory's (JPL) Spitzer Space Telescope. After a hugely successful mission, she moved on to NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center (GSFC), in the Washington D.C. area. In her off-hours often puts on about 30lbs of Elizabethan garb and performs intricate Renaissance dances. For more information, visit
    NASA.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT:
    MICHELLE THALLER: Black holes really are kind of getting to the very heart of our physics. And I believe that they're kind of showing us the way that eventually we're going to need different physics and new physics. People ask questions like, "What happens inside a black hole?" Or even, "What happens at the very boundary of a black hole, the event horizon, when light is absorbed?" And honestly, our physics is telling us a lot of contradictory things. And our image of what an event horizon really is may be changing. People like Stephen Hawking and Leonard Susskind have recently come up with this idea that a black hole should not be able to destroy information. O.K., what do we mean by information? Information can be almost anything.
    All of the different atoms in my body have angular momentum, they have charge, they have mass. There's all sorts of little bits of information that make me me. At the quantum mechanic level, the tiniest of levels, there are different amounts of energy, there are different probabilities that are contained in the structure of my matter. And information, in some ways is a form of energy. It's actually a way that you can describe something which is somehow, in a strange way, a higher energy state than not being able to describe something. And so one of the questions is, "If energy really can't be destroyed energy itself is something that is intrinsic in the universe, you can't really created or destroy it is it possible that information is the same way? Is there really no way to actually destroy the information about what all of my subatomic particles are doing right now?"
    So black holes kind of stare you right in the face. What a black hole supposedly does is it absorbs everything. Space and time bend into a black hole so that nothing can escape. That means that any information about the material that fell in is gone. The only thing we know about it is that as a black hole absorbs material, it gets more massive. It actually adds that mass to the mass of the black hole. And as that mass increases, the event horizon becomes larger. Basically, the area where space is so curved that you can't get out begins to extend the more massive a black hole is. The most massive black holes we know of in the universe are many billions of times the mass of our sun. And the physical extent of this event horizon is about the size of our solar system, maybe like out to the planet Pluto.
    So is it possible, then, if everything goes into a black hole and nothing ever comes out, space and time go inside the black hole and don't come out? What happened to that information? And this has begun to make a lot of people wonder if we really have thought of black holes the wrong way. Maybe there isn't an event horizon in the true sense. I actually had a friend of mine that studies black holes say, "Well, I'm not sure if they're black. They m...
    For the full transcript, check out https://bigthink.com/videos/black-holes
    8 min
  • How social narratives stop us from being happy | Andrea Breanna | Big Think
    How social narratives stop us from being happy
    New videos DAILY: https://bigth.ink
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive video lessons from top thinkers and doers: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Many of us are trying to fit into existing roles that aren't specially crafted for us, and, as a result, we don't fit perfectly in them. This causes us a lot of stress and anxiety.
    Though many people aren't transgender, they can still relate to the feeling of not completely fitting in, and having to figure out their own path.
    Often finding out own way directly overlaps with figuring out what makes us happy. When someone is trans, it is possible for them to feel attracted to either gender. For example, Breanna wishes she could tell her teenage self that it is possible to "be a girl and like girls."
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ANDREA BREANNA
    Andrea Breanna is the founder and CEO of RebelMouse. RebelMouse is a powerful CMS platform that has built two of the biggest new media companies to date — The Dodo and Axios — and powers United Airline’s hub. Andrea was previously CTO of Huffington Post. She now serves on Advisory Board for American Express and is an advisor to Lerer Hippeau Ventures. Andrea is proudly and openly transgender.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT:
    ANDREA BREANNA: I'm obviously an extreme. What I found when I came out of the closet as trans because I will say, I always knew I was trans. And I think that's not true of all trans people. It's not what defines us. But it is true of a lot of us. So in part, I think I lost, I sometimes feel like many of us do a lost childhood that I didn't get to fully be myself. But on the other hand, I also feel like I was able to frequently be myself because I was never in the closet to myself. And it was something that I always found a little space, literally a closet, sometimes, to be myself. Growing up in the Valley, and my dad started a software company, I learned to code. And the first reason I learned to code, the first thing I did with it, was create I wrote a little thing of code to password protect a file. It was like really early days.
    My dad had bought a computer and it was assembled. And it was the first private space that I had. With sisters and cousins and my mom, as nosy as we all knew she was, there was no way I could have a diary. But the first place I could write was this space that I knew like no one would read but me. And that, for me yeah, I think a lot of trans people work in tech, because as kids it was a place we could be ourselves. But what I think I found when I came out of the closet, the biggest fear, that once my wife accepted me instead of wanted a divorce and she understood I didn't, I actually, I've always been attracted to girls. And that was really hard on the whole gender orientation and sexual orientation. And like, if I could whisper back to myself as a teenager, you can be a girl and like girls. But it was also confusing through all of this. And for her, there's no narratives. And I think if you accept, more than anything I think, I think I've been thinking about this a lot.
    And I think that there is a when we are living in a paradigm, which is our current one, where we are trying to find the role already existing that we fit into, I think when we try to exist in modern times in that paradigm, it causes a tremendous stress and anxiety. Because as humans, it turns out, that very few of us fit so perfectly. I think coming out as trans, what has been beautiful for me is to see that while I get to meet a lot of people who identify as trans, I meet, overwhelmingly people who identify with trans people. With this sense of not fitting into those things and I see, with four kids, and all of them little, from 12 to 1 and 1/2, "Are you going to grow up to be a fireman or you can be the president. Don't forget to dream big!" And the biggest dream we can put out there for them is the president. But they ask from middle school for kids to think about their specialty. And it's like, how could you know? You don't know. You won't I think the smartest people don't know what their thing is when they're 70.
    But the biggest dream should be, you're going to invent something we don't know yet. And when you look at humanity, everyone who's alive picks from the existing narrative roles that we've been given. And they used to be terribly primitive, but they were shockingly primitive from where I think we can get to quite rapidly if we accept this different paradigm, where the goal is to create a new role. It's to build a new narrative, that we have hundreds of years of expanding narratives before we've exhausted...
    For the full transcript, check out https://bigthink.com/videos/transgender
    7 min
  • Comedian Pete Holmes on depression and negative emotion | Big Think
    Comedian Pete Holmes on depression and negative emotion
    New videos DAILY: https://bigth.ink
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive video lessons from top thinkers and doers: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Everyone's experience with depression is different, but for comedian Pete Holmes the key to living with depression has been to observe his own thoughts in an impartial way.
    Holmes' method, taught to him by psychologist and spiritual leader Ram Dass, is to connect to his base consciousness and think about himself and his emotions in the third person.
    You can't push depression away, but you can shift your mindset to help better cope with depression, anxiety, and negative emotions. If you feel depressed, you can connect with a crisis counselor anytime in the US.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    PETE HOLMES:
    Pete Holmes is a comedian, writer, cartoonist, "Christ-leaning spiritual seeker", and podcast host. His wildly popular podcast, You Made It Weird, is a comedic exploration of the meaning of life with guests ranging from Deepak Chopra and Elizabeth Gilbert to Seth Rogen and Garry Shandling.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT:
    PETE HOLMES: You woke up in a conundrum. You were born into a conundrum. And I don't care how we label it or lower our anxiety by going, well, it's this and it's not this, and it's that -- let's just talk about this shared mystery that we're soaking in. I want to be careful here, talking about depression, because I had a friend who was very depressed, and I remember talking to him, out of love, trying to explain some of these ideas, some of these ways that we can think and interpret our suffering. And sometimes when someone is suffering, the last thing they want is for you to go, 'Hey, there's another way to look at this.' That's later. None of this is to be imposed on anybody, and I don't want to belittle or just say, 'You know your brain is -- it's your attachment to your desire to not be depressed that's causing you--' no, none of that. That is not what I'm saying at all. We can give space to someone's depression. We can love them, we can honor -- we can just eat some noodles, we can watch some movies, whatever it is. We can just sit and not talk. That's real stuff. It's a real -- I don't know if you call it a disorder, a disease, but it's happening, and we don't need to coach people through with ideologies.
    That being said, if you're in a place to talk about this, usually when you're not depressed, I found it helpful to step inside what I call the witness. And other traditions call that your soul. I believe science might just call it the phenomenon of your base consciousness. If you think about when you were born -- I have a baby girl now; she's not thinking in ideas yet. She doesn't know she's American. She doesn't know she lives in California. Just like a ladybug doesn't know it's Italian. You know what I mean? It's just awareness. So she's just there. But slowly over time, we build up what Jung and others called the false self. So we have the story of who we are. I'm a man and I'm a comedian and I'm a tall man, I have big teeth, and all these things, and I like the first two Batman movies, and I don't drink coffee, or whatever it is. So you build up this identity. And oftentimes, in that identity is where things like suffering are occurring, sometimes. I can't speak for everybody. But I will say that for me, when I've been depressed -- and I get depressed. I have irrational bouts of anxiety. I have random FedEx deliveries of despondency. Just like, "I didn't order this. Oh, well, keep the PJs on, cancel everything you're doing today. It's time to take a sad shower." That happens to me. So I'm speaking for me with full respect to other people's processes and their experience.
    When I'm depressed, if I can get into that quiet space, it's the space that's noticing the thoughts. So if you think, 'I'm hungry' -- we always just think that 'I'm hungry' is the thought in the animal, and then we eat, and then it goes, 'Thank you.' Who's talking to who, really? I would say that the thought is talking to your awareness, your base awareness, your witness. So that's what's watching your thoughts. And if you can get into that, you see how impartial and unswayed by your life circumstance this witness really is. It's just there. It's neutral. It's just is-ness. It's just this. And it's just watching. It's compassionate, it's involved, it's invested. But it's not really as connected and tied to the events of your life story as you are, as your false self is. So when those depressions happen, I found it helpful -- and this is something Ram Dass taught me -- is instead o...
    For the full transcript, check out https://bigthink.com/videos/depression-is-different-for-everyone-heres-what-its-like-for-me
    7 min
  • Neuroprosthetics and deep brain stimulation: Two big neuroscience breakthroughs | Susan Hockfield
    Neuroprosthetics and deep brain stimulation: Two big neuroscience breakthroughs
    Watch the newest video from Big Think: https://bigth.ink/NewVideo
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Neuroscience and engineering are uniting in mind-blowing ways that will drastically improve the quality of life for people with conditions like epilepsy, paralysis or schizophrenia.
    Researchers have developed a brain-computer interface the size of a baby aspirin that can restore mobility to people with paralysis or amputated limbs. It rewires neural messages from the brain's motor cortex to a robotic arm, or reroutes it to the person's own muscles.
    Deep brain stimulation is another wonder of neuroscience that can effectively manage brain conditions like epilepsy, Parkinson's, and may one day mitigate schizophrenia so people can live normal, independent lives.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    SUSAN HOCKFIELD:
    Susan Hockfield is a neuroscientist based at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. From 2004 to 2012, she served as the 16th president of the university. Hockfield was the first woman, and the first life scientist, to lead the institute. Prior to MIT, she worked at Yale University, where she served in myriad capacities. Among them, the William Edward Gilbert Professor of Neurobiology, Dean of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, and Provost.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT:
    SUSAN HOCKFIELD: One issue that I think haunts all of us is enabling the disabled. How can we make it possible for people who have lost the ability to use their limbs -- either by amputation or by stroke -- how do we give them a better life? How do we make their lives more enjoyable, give them greater mobility? One of my colleagues -- going back to my early days as a neuroscientist -- John Donoghue, has been fascinated in how the part of our brain that controls movements works. It's called the motor cortex, part of the cerebral cortex; it's located just about here. And we have known for many, many, many years that signals from the nerve cells in that part of the brain drive motions. If I want to reach out my arm to grab a glass of water, it's signals from the motor cortex that send their information down the spinal cord in our back and then out to the limbs. If you've had a spinal cord injury or a stroke, those connections are interrupted. But John Donoghue understood that just because the connections were interrupted didn't mean that the motor cortex wasn't working. And he resolved to figure out a way to pick up the signals from the motor cortex and translate them into either a robotic arm or an individual's own arm by connecting to another set of electronics that could drive the muscles in the arm of someone who was paralyzed.
    He and his colleagues have invented an intracortical brain computer interface; it's a very, very teeny set of electrodes -- it's about the size of a baby aspirin -- that has a hundred very fine wires that can sit in the motor cortex. They pick up the signals from the nerve cells in the motor cortex and relay them to a computer. The computer then decodes the signal and then can send that signal out to a robotic arm or, as I said, through a number of connections back to the individual's own arm and gives that individual the ability, for the first time since their injury, to feed themselves, to grab a cup of coffee and take a sip by themselves. So it gives them a kind of independence they never had.
    One of John Donoghue's colleagues, Dr. Leigh Hochberg, who's worked closely with him on these experiments, told me something really quite extraordinary. The whole world of deep brain stimulation, which is related, and it's a world that is related to recording signals from the brain, but also driving brain activity by stimulating electrodes in the brain. And this kind of deep brain stimulation has proved effective for some kinds of epilepsy. It's proved remarkably effective for some individuals with Parkinson's, it has controlled their tremors. And there are a lot of possibilities. The problem with understanding the brain and intervening is there are a billion nerve cells in the brain, and figuring out how each one participates in an activity is a daunting task, to put it mildly. But what these experiments suggest is that we may not need to do a cell by cell analysis. We may not need a cell by cell understanding of the circuitry that drives a particular activity, an activity we want or an activity we don't want...
    Read the full transcript at https://bigthink.com/videos/neuroprosthetics-and-deep-brain-stimulation-two-big-neuroscience-breakthroughs
    5 min
  • Stand up against religious discrimination – even if it’s not your religion | Eboo Patel | Big Think
    Stand up against religious discrimination – even if it’s not your religion
    Watch the newest video from Big Think: https://bigth.ink/NewVideo
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Religious diversity is the norm in American life, and that diversity is only increasing, says Eboo Patel.
    Using the most painful moment of his life as a lesson, Eboo Patel explains why it's crucial to be positive and proactive about engaging religious identity towards interfaith cooperation.
    The opinions expressed in this video do not necessarily reflect the views of the Charles Koch Foundation, which encourages the expression of diverse viewpoints within a culture of civil discourse and mutual respect.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    EBOO PATEL:
    Eboo Patel is the founder and president of Interfaith Youth Core (IFYC), a national nonprofit working to make interfaith cooperation a social norm. He is the author of the books Acts of Faith, Sacred Ground, Interfaith Leadership and Out of Many Faiths. Eboo holds a doctorate in the sociology of religion from Oxford University, where he studied on a Rhodes scholarship.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT:
    EBOO PATEL: My closest friends in high school, the kids I ate lunch with, included a Cuban Jew, a South Indian Hindu, a Nigerian Evangelical, a Mormon, a Lutheran and a Catholic. And we talked about everything under the sun as 16-year-old suburban high school kids are want to do. We never talked about religion. And even though there were parts of all of our lives that were at least a little bit religious, it generally manifested in something along the lines of 'I can't play basketball this Sunday because my mom is making me go to some religion thing', but our families had a certain set of expectations around our religious participation, and some people, especially my Latter-Day Saints friend, was especially involved in that kind of stuff. So why does it matter that religion was not part of the conversation? For a couple of months during my high school career a group of thugs in my school started going after my Jewish friend and they would call him ugly anti-Semitic slurs in the hallway and they would scrawl really terrible things on classroom desks. And I saw my once vibrant friend slink into the shadows of the school. He would come to school right as the opening bell rang; he would leave right as the closing bell rang. And I watched this happen over these couple months. A few years later when we were home from college for a summer, he brings this up with me and he says "Those were the worst months of my life. And the part of it that really sucked wasn't what those thugs did to me, it was watching you watch me suffer and do nothing. Why did you do nothing?"
    And I'm 43 years old and I've done a lot of dumb things and that's the most humiliating moment of my life – it's my friend calling me out on a moment of profound weakness, like, the opposite of courage. And I told the story to my dad, who is not a ritualistic Muslim at all, but he was like, "You failed your friend and you failed your faith." "Like what do you mean I failed my faith?" He's like, "We're Muslims, Eboo. We stand up for people who are hurting. That's the core of the religion. That's what it means to be Rahmatul Alameen -- a mercy upon all the worlds -- as Allah says to the Prophet Mohammed in the holy Quran." And that's when I started to think to myself: Why is it that my friend group wasn't talking about religion, but these thugs in my school we're happy to be openly anti-Semitic? And it's one of the early experiences in my life that got me thinking about how important it is to be positive and proactive about engaging religious identity towards interfaith cooperation. And that is now a norm in American life. Like your elementary school where you send your kids, or the hospital where your kids were born, those are all religiously diverse places and that religious diversity matters.
    Let's think for a moment about how religious diversity intersects with healthcare. Different religious orientations literally have different definitions of when life begins, have different definitions of what to do when a baby is born, have different definitions of what a good life is and have different definitions of when a person dies. So if you are a nurse or a doctor and you enter the room of a Buddhist family whose grandfather is on the bed about to pass into the next world and you point to the brain scan and say...
    Read the full transcript at https://bigthink.com/Charles-Koch-Foundation/eboo-patel-religious-discrimination
    6 min
  • The psychology of moral grandstanding | Brandon Warmke | Big Think
    The psychology of moral grandstanding
    New videos DAILY: https://bigth.ink
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive video lessons from top thinkers and doers: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Moral grandstanding is the use of moral talk for self-promotion. Moral grandstanders have egotistical motives: they may want to signal that they have superhuman insight into a topic, paint themselves as a victim, or show that they care more than others.
    Moral philosophers view moral grandstanding as a net negative. They argue that it contributes to political polarization, increases levels of cynicism about moral talk and its value in public life, and it causes outrage exhaustion.
    Grandstanders are also a kind of social free rider, says Brandon Warmke. They get the benefits of being heard without contributing to any valuable discourse. It's selfish behavior at best, and divisive behavior at worst.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    BRANDON WARMKE
    Brandon Warmke, Ph.D. is Assistant Professor of Philosophy at Bowling Green State University. He is currently writing two books, Grandstanding: The Use and Abuse of Moral Talk and Why It’s OK to Mind Your Own Business, both with philosopher Justin Tosi.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT:
    BRANDON WARMKE: If you had a bumper sticker and you wanted a quick, dirty definition of moral grandstanding, it's the use of moral talk for self-promotion. Grandstanders are moral showboaters. They use public discourse as a vanity project. They're less concerned about saying what's true. They might be less concerned about helping other people. They're less concerned about contributing to a conversation that might be productive.
    More specifically, someone might want to be seen as having spectacular, superhuman insight into what is just. Some people might want to be seen as caring the most about the poor or about the troops. Some people might want to be seen as the most affected by some injustice. So grandstanding doesn't always look like the same sort of animal. Grandstanding sometimes looks like piling on. You often see cases of piling on when a lot of people join in on a shame fest for someone who's misspoken or engaged in a small minor infraction. In order to signal to their in-group or to their enemies that they have a heightened sense of justice, they pile on in cases of public blaming and shaming.
    Another form that grandstanding takes is what we can call ramping up. Ramping up involves trying to out-do each other in moral discourse. You can think of it as a kind of moral arms race. So I might say something like, 'The senator's behavior was highly unacceptable. She should clearly be censured for it.' Now you, not wanting to be outdone, might say something like, 'Yes, I agree that her behavior was wrong, but it's clearly way out of bounds. She should no longer hold her office. She should be impeached.' And then someone else, again, not wanting to be outdone, might say, 'As someone who has long stood on the side of injustice, we should look into the criminal law. This cannot go unpunished. We must remember the world is watching.' And you can think of ramping up in terms of what psychologists call social comparison. Social comparison theory says, roughly, we think of ourselves in comparison to others. So if I think of myself as caring deeply about the poor or about the troops, that's going to be important to me, I'm going to think of myself as a more just person or a more caring person than my peers. What happens in conversation is that once people reveal their positions about how much they care about or how affected they are by some problem, you can now look like you don't care as much as others about some problem. And so in order to beat someone else in the moral race, you have to outdo them. And so this often results in people taking more extreme stands than they might otherwise do on reflection, because when the world is watching, you must show that you care more.
    Moral philosophers tend to think there's three main ways for something to be morally good or bad: One, it could have morally good or bad consequences. Two, it could be morally good or bad insofar as it mistreats other people, or shows them respect or disrespect. And that's irrespective of the bad or good consequences it might have. And third, philosophers will often say something like: Something is good or bad if a virtuous person would do it or not do it. So we think about the virtues, like honesty, courage. We think that grandstanding is bad according to all three ways of thinking that something could be morally good or bad. Grandstanding has bad consequences. We argue that it contribut...
    For the full transcript, check out https://bigthink.com/sponsored-institute-for-humane-studies/the-psychology-of-moral-grandstanding
    8 min
  • Michio Kaku forecasts the future of space travel
    New videos DAILY: https://bigth.ink
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive video lessons from top thinkers and doers: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    The co-founder of Field String Theory explains why the universe has 11 dimensions rather than any other number.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    MICHIO KAKU
    Dr. Michio Kaku is the co-founder of string field theory, and is one of the most widely recognized scientists in the world today. He has written 4 New York Times Best Sellers, is the science correspondent for CBS This Morning and has hosted numerous science specials for BBC-TV, the Discovery/Science Channel. His radio show broadcasts to 100 radio stations every week. Dr. Kaku holds the Henry Semat Chair and Professorship in theoretical physics at the City College of New York (CUNY), where he has taught for over 25 years. He has also been a visiting professor at the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton, as well as New York University (NYU).
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT:
    Question: Why are there only 11 dimensions in the universe rather than something higher? (Submitted by John Menon)
    Michio Kaku: I work in something called String Theory, that’s what I do for a living. In fact, that’s my day job. I’m the co-founder of String Field Theory, one of the main branches of String Theory. The latest version of String Theory is called M-Theory, “M” for membrane. So we now realize that strings can coexist with membranes. So the subatomic particles we see in nature, the quartz, the electrons are nothing but musical notes on a tiny vibrating string.
    What is physics? Physics is nothing but the laws of harmony that you can write on vibrating strings. What is chemistry? Chemistry is nothing but the melodies you can play on interacting vibrating strings. What is the universe? The universe is a symphony of vibrating strings. And then what is the mind of God that Albert Einstein eloquently wrote about for the last 30 years of his life? We now, for the first time in history have a candidate for the mind of God. It is, cosmic music resonating through 11 dimensional hyperspace.
    So first of all, we are nothing but melodies. We are nothing but cosmic music played out on vibrating strings and membranes. Obeying the laws of physics, which is nothing but the laws of harmony of vibrating strings. But why 11? It turns out that if you write a theory in 15, 17, 18 dimensions, the theory is unstable. It has what are called, anomalies. It has singularities. It turns out that mathematics alone prefers the universe being 11 dimensions.
    Now some people have toyed with 12 dimensions. At Harvard University, for example, some of the physicists there have shown that a 12-dimensional theory actually looks very similar to an 11-dimensional theory except it has two times, double times rather than one single time parameter. Now, what would it be like to live in a universe with double time? Well, I remember a movie with David Niven. David Niven played a pilot, who was shot down over the Pacific, but the angels made a mistake, he was not supposed to die that day. And so the angels brought him back to life and said, “Oh, sorry about that. We killed you off by accident; you were not supposed to die today.”
    So in a great scene, David Niven then walks through a city where time has stopped. Everyone looks like this. And there’s David Niven just wandering around looking at all these people. That’s a world with double time. David Niven has one clock, but everyone else has a separate clock and these two clocks are perpendicular to each other. So if there’s a double time universe, you could walk right into a room, see people frozen in time, while you beat to a different clock. That’s a double time universe.
    Now this is called F-Theory, “F” for father, the father of strings. It’s not known whether F-Theory will survive or not; however, M-Theory in 11 dimension is the mother of all strings. And that theory works perfectly fine. So to answer your question, in other dimensions, dimensions beyond 11, we have problems with stability, these theories are unstable, they decay back down to 11 dimensions, they have what are called anomalies, singularities, which kill an ordinary theory. So the mathematics itself forces you to 11 dimensions.
    Also because this is a Theory of Everything, there’s more room in higher dimensions to put all the forces together. When you put gravity, electromagnetism and the nuclear force together, four dimensions is not big enough to accommodate all these forces. When you expand to 11 dimensions, bingo, everything forms perfectly well.
    4 min
  • Will the 1% act on inequality before the riots start? | Jared Diamond | Big Think
    Will the 1% act on inequality before the riots start?
    Watch the newest video from Big Think: https://bigth.ink/NewVideo
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    How bad is wealth inequality in the United States? About 1 percent of Americans hold 80 percent of the money.
    In the United States, the correlation between the income of parents and the income of their children when they grow up is higher than in any other country in the world.
    One of the big underlying reasons for poverty is receiving a crummy education, which in turn leads to crummy jobs. When people recognize their miserable long-term prospects, they are more likely to partake in riots.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    JARED DIAMOND:
    Jared Diamond, a noted polymath, is Professor of Geography at the University of California, Los Angeles. Among his many awards are the U.S. National Medal of Science, Japan's Cosmos Prize, a MacArthur Foundation Fellowship, a Pulitzer Prize for General Nonfiction, and election to the U.S. National Academy of Sciences. He is the author of the international best-selling books Guns, Germs, and Steel; Collapse; Why Is Sex Fun?; The World Until Yesterday; and The Third Chimpanzee, and is the presenter of TV documentary series based on three of those books.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT:
    JARED DIAMOND: Inequality is one of the big problems of the United States. But it's also a big problem of the world. To start with a problem for the United States, inequality with the United States, everybody knows by now the numbers the 1% or 0.1% of the people have 80% of the money in the United States. One might say if you're rich, you might say well, "Isn't that sad? But those poor people, they're poor because they're lazy and they're not trying hard and the American dream is rags to riches. They're poor because it's all their fault."
    Well, the big reason that they are poor is because they are getting crummy educations, because American support for education has declined, because where you live is tied to the quality of the school where you're at. And if you get a crummy education, you're going to end up with a crummy job and you're going to end up poor. In the United States the correlation between the income of parents and the income of their children when they grow up is higher than in any other country in the world, meaning that if you want to be rich, if you are a child and you want to be rich, the best thing to do is to be born to rich parents. There's is a cruel joke which says if you are a baby, choose your parents carefully, because that's the best predictor of whether you end up rich or not.
    You can say so what difference does it make for the rich people if there are all these unhappy unproductive poor people? Well, in my lifetime in Los Angeles, twice I've experienced riots in my city of Los Angeles, where the riots broke out in the center of the city where there were lots of poor people, miserable, recognizing that they didn't have any long term prospects. And they started rioting and they burning, they started burning. Sections like Beverly Hills that the rioters would spread out of the center of Los Angeles and start wrecking Beverly Hills. So what did the police do in Beverly Hills? The only thing they could do was to string up strips of this yellow plastic police tape across the main boulevards with signs that said rioters keep out.
    Well, at the time of the last riots, the rioters, it happened, did not invade Beverly Hills. But you can bet there will be more if there's Inequality continuing in the United States, there'll be more riots. And the next time the rioters are going to invade Beverly Hills and they will be burning and doing other bad things there. And yellow strips of plastic police tape will not keep them out. So what does inequality mean for the United States? It's really bad for those Americans at the lower end of the spectrum, but it's going to be bad, and maybe fatally bad, for rich Americans.
    3 min
  • How AI will liberate doctors from keyboards and basements | Eric Topol | Big Think
    How AI will liberate doctors from keyboards and basements
    New videos DAILY: https://bigth.ink
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive video lessons from top thinkers and doers: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Machines can help doctors by spotting abnormalities in X-rays or MRA scans that the physicians themselves may have missed.
    A.I. can also help physicians by analyzing data and, through the use of algorithms, produce possible diagnoses.
    The freed up time, as doctors make their rounds, can help physicians establish better connections with their patients, which in turn can lead to better treatment plans.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ERIC TOPOL:
    Eric Topol, a professor in the Department of Molecular Medicine at Scripps, is an executive vice president at Scripps Research and the founder and director of Scripps Research Translational Institute (previously Scripps Translational Science Institute). His work melds genomics, big data, and both information technologies and digital health technologies to advance the promise of personalized medicine.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT:
    ERIC TOPOL: Technology can't enhance humanity, that it's depersonalizing, that it's going to detract. I actually think it's just the opposite in medicine, because if we can outsource to machines and technology, we can restore the human bond, which has been eroding for decades. So what I mean by deep medicine is really a three part story: The first is what we call deep phenotyping. And that is a very intensive, comprehensive understanding of each person at every level. So that's the idea of knowing all about their biology, not just their genome, their microbiome, and all the things the different layers of the person, but also their physiology through sensors, their anatomy through scans, their environment through sensors as well, and then traditional data.
    So that's deep phenotyping. Now, no human being can process all that data, because it's dynamic, and it's actually quite large to deal with. That's why we have deep learning. That's a type of artificial intelligence which takes all of these inputs and it really crystallizes, distills it all. And that gets us to deep empathy. And the deep empathy is when we have this outsourcing to machines and algorithms. We have all of this data, and we now can get back to the human side of this connection. Well, where deep learning works the best today is with images. And so medical images are especially ideal because it turns out that radiologists miss things in more than 30 percent of scans that are done today. So in order to not miss these things, you can train machines to have vision better than humans. The difference here is that the radiologists can put more context in it, but the machines, they're very complementary.
    They can pick up things that radiologists wouldn't see, like a nodule on a chest X-ray or an abnormality on an MRA that would be missed because radiologists read 50 to 100 scans per day. There's many times that we just don't see things. So when you bring the two together, you get the best economy. It doesn't mean we're going to eliminate the need for radiologists. It's going to make the accuracy and the speed much better. And what I project is that we're going to see a time when radiologists move out of the basement in the dark and actually connect with patients, because they want to see patients. They want to be able to share their expertise, and they don't have a vested interest about doing an operation or procedure. They just want to report what they find and communicate that. So I think we're going to see a reshaping of radiology because of this remarkable performance enhancement through AI.
    There's a lot of use of AI in the hospital setting, because when patients come in, and trying to predict what's going to happen, we're not so good at that generally in medicine. So almost everything you can think of there have been algorithms tested. One example is sepsis. So what's going to happen? Does the person have sepsis, a serious infection? Are they going to decompensate and possibly die from sepsis? We're not so great at that, it turns out, by algorithm. But what we have learned is that we can use the same machine vision, whether it's nurses, doctors, people who are circulating in a room of a hospital, to see whether or not they're doing appropriate handwashing, and to set off a signal that, no, it wasn't done and needs to be done. So there's lots of things about patient safety with machine vision.
    So for example, preventing falls, seeing that someone's walking is unsteady. Another great example is in the intensive care unit. Some people can pull...
    For the full transcript, check out https://bigthink.com/videos/ai-2637549115
    6 min
  • Fascism and conspiracy theories: The symptoms of broken communication | John Cameron Mitchell
    Fascism and conspiracy theories: The symptoms of broken communication
    Watch the newest video from Big Think: https://bigth.ink/NewVideo
    Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: https://bigth.ink/Edge
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    The world was saner when we spoke face-to-face, argues John Cameron Mitchell. Not looking someone in the eye when you talk to them raises the potential for miscommunication and conflict.
    Social media has been an incredible force for activism and human rights, but it's also negatively affected our relationship with the media. We are now bombarded 24/7 with news that either drives us to anger or apathy.
    Sitting behind a screen makes polarization worse, and polarization is fertile ground for conspiracy theories and fascism, which Cameron describes as irrationally blaming someone else for your problems.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    JOHN CAMERON MITCHELL:
    John Cameron Mitchell directed, starred in and co-wrote, with Stephen Trask, the musical film Hedwig and the Angry Inch (2001), for which he received the Best Director Award at the Sundance Festival and was nominated for a Golden Globe as Best Actor. His recent Broadway production garnered the 2014 Tony Award for Best Revival of Musical and a 2015 Special Tony for his return to the role. His latest work is the radio-cinema podcast Anthem: Homunculus.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    TRANSCRIPT:
    JOHN CAMERON MITCHELL: There is danger in the incompleteness of digital communication. It's not enough bandwidth to really feel. You know, I have -- even right now, I'm looking at your face, which is superimposed onto a camera in the Interrotron, invented by Errol Morris. And that's how he got people to talk to the camera honestly. But we don't have those on our phones and computers yet. The camera is on top of the screen in a phone and a computer, so no one is actually looking into each other's eyes and there's trouble because of that.
    Tweet wars means you can't see the expression in someone's face when they're saying something, which has complexity. And you take offense easier. And you give offense easier. And in fact, giving offense is proof of existence. And you have people screaming things that they don't necessarily always believe, because they want to exist, because they're behind a screen; they're not in a group. A lot of it has to do with being present, physically present, when you're dealing with a crisis. You know, you don't text a breakup. You know, you shouldn't. It's like, there's misunderstanding -- there's too much to be misunderstood in words.
    My advice -- in some ways we're in a better world than we've ever been, in terms of health and human rights at least being considered in different countries. And partly that's because of digital stuff. You know, you can't actually shut down digital communication, no matter how hard you try in China or wherever; there's VPNs. People get through. So there are advantages to that. But the way we get the information, 24-hour bombardment, makes people feel afraid. And you've got a lot of people who feel like dangerous shut ins, you know? Who are railing against how sad things are, or dropping out because they're overwhelmed. And because of that drop out and that polarization you get a regime like Trump. You get a fertile ground for fascism, which is about blaming someone irrationally for other problems in your life. It's an old game that has been played for millennia. That immigrant, that transgender person, that person who is of a different race, their very existence threatens you because they're getting attention, money -- they're stealing something from you. And that certainly happened -- you know, found its way in to a World War II. But also the lack, the kind of fragile state of truth right now, which also comes out of digital addiction, is that all conspiracy theories are true, all news is suspect, facts are fungible. And in a world like that, that's the biggest danger, you know, apart from climate change. You know, and they are linked, God knows. Somebody has convinced themselves that it's a hoax because they'd make less money if it wasn't a hoax.
    Consider your conspiracy theories. You have a problem with them if you only believe the ones you want to. Since they're not really based on facts, you only believe what you want. You read the news you want to read. You ignore the ones you don't. Read the stuff you don't want to believe. Even consider the conspiracy theory you don't want to believe. You know, then you can consider yourself a fair-minded nut. It's the -- think about it. Are you only believing conspiracy theories because you want them to be true? That's when you know there's trouble.
    5 min