What happens when a wholesome romance turns into a nightmare of fake pregnancies, staged crimes, and a decade-long prison sentence? On this episode of Binge or Cringe, hosts Suzi Lazarus and Jamie Joffe dive deep into the mind-bending Netflix documentary A Toxic Love Story. They break down the convoluted web woven by Michelle, Ian, and Angela, exploring the shocking body-cam footage and the "unreliable narrator" Leslie that had the sisters ready to watch the whole thing standing up.
But the true crime doesn’t stop there. Jamie shares her "deep dive" findings from a Dateline follow-up, revealing even more concrete evidence of the elaborate framing schemes and the dark history of "sympathy scams" that didn’t quite make it into the Netflix edit.
The conversation then shifts to Hell’s Kitchen for Suzi’s "Rick Pick" of the week: The Westies. Set in the 1980s, this gritty MGM+ drama features an iconic performance by J.K. Simmons as the leader of the notorious Irish-American gang. The hosts discuss the brutal reality of organized crime, generational clashes, and the fragile truce with the Italian mafia during the construction of the Javits Center.
Next, they head to the Nevada desert for the HBO Max docuseries The Man Will Burn. They trace the evolution of Burning Man from a 1986 beach bonfire to a massive tech-bro-dominated city, discussing the controversial leadership of CEO Marian Goodell and the struggle to keep the "leave no trace" spirit alive amidst funding crises and drone shows.
To wrap things up, Suzi and Jamie look ahead to the most anticipated releases of August. From the elite prep school serial killer thrills of Bret Easton Ellis’s The Shards to the rumored return of Ted Lasso focusing on a women’s soccer team, find out what’s a guaranteed binge and what might just be a "money grab" retread.
Will Jamie ever make it to the dust of Burning Man without her Diet Coke? and can Suzi handle the 80s fashion of The Westies? Tune in to this episode of Binge or Cringe to find out which stories are worth your time and which ones are just "wack."
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices