In August of 2025, the team reviewed various valuation models and their application to the new asset Bitcoin. Today the team looks at a different way to think about Bitcoin valuation through the lens of several different valuation models to identify a necessary transition from “pure” theoretical models (physics and code) to “hybrid” macroeconomic frameworks (institutional liquidity and geopolitical friction). The team presents a clash between deterministic mathematical laws and the chaotic reality of the 2026 financial landscape.
Here is a summary of Bitcoin value analyzed through the six primary valuation models presented in the podcast.
1. The Physics Lens: The Power Law & Scale Invariance
Core Premise: Bitcoin is not a financial equity but a digital organism or “city.” Its value grows according to deterministic, scale-invariant laws found in nature and urban planning, specifically scaling super-linearly with time.
* The Mechanism: The model relies on a feedback loop: Price increases ===> Mining profitability rises ===> Hashrate increases ===> Security strengthens ===> Value is locked in.
* The Metric: It posits a log-log linear relationship where Price is a function of Time raised to the power of roughly 5.8.
* The 2026 Stress Test: In early 2026, Bitcoin experienced a “drift” where price stagnated near $70,000, falling into the lower 15% of the Power Law corridor.
* Critique & Resolution: Critics argue regressing price against time creates “spurious regression” because time is not a causal economic factor. The resolution proposed is substituting calendar time with “Block Height” (endogenous time), which links valuation directly to thermodynamic work rather than the mere passage of days.
2. The Biological Lens: The S-Curve & Network Effects
Core Premise: Bitcoin is a communication technology diffusing through society. Unlike the Power Law’s unbounded growth, the S-Curve dictates that growth must eventually slow and plateau due to “finite wealth” and market saturation.
* The Mechanism: Value is derived from Metcalfe’s Law, where network value is proportional to the square of connected users.
* The 2026 Shift: Fidelity’s Jurrien Timmer argues that by 2026, Bitcoin transitioned from the steep “Early Adopter” phase to the flatter “Early Majority” phase. The “bending of the curve” implies diminishing returns, where supply halvings matter less than the sheer volume of capital required to move a trillion-dollar asset.
* Constraint: The model introduces a “hard ceiling” defined by Global M2 money supply. Bitcoin cannot exceed the total addressable market of the money it seeks to replace.
3. The Supply-Side Lens: Scarcity & Stock-to-Flow (S2F)
Core Premise: Value is driven by “unforgeable costliness” and absolute scarcity. The S2F model valued Bitcoin based on the ratio of existing supply (Stock) to new issuance (Flow).
* The Breakdown: While S2F successfully modeled early price history, it failed catastrophically in the 2024–2026 cycle. The model predicted prices exceeding $500,000, ignoring that scarcity alone does not generate value without demand.
* Econometric Failure: Thorough analysis revealed the model suffered from “spurious correlation”—it lacked cointegration, meaning the relationship between scarcity and price was a statistical illusion caused by both variables trending up simultaneously.
* The Thermodynamic Floor: A sub-component of this lens is the Cost of Production model, which argues miners provide a “hard price floor” at their breakeven cost ($77k–$90k in 2026). However, the pivot of miners toward AI/High-Performance Computing has weakened this floor, as miners can now exit the network to service AI contracts rather than defending the Bitcoin price.
4. The Macroeconomic Lens: Global Liquidity Barometer
Core Premise: Bitcoin is a “high-beta” derivative of fiat debasement. It functions as the “denominator effect” in action; as the supply of fiat money ($M2$) expands, the nominal price of fixed-supply assets must rise.
* The Mechanism: Analysis confirms a long-run “cointegration” (real relationship) where a 1% increase in money supply leads to a ~2.65% increase in Bitcoin price.
* The “Warsh Paradox” Decoupling: In early 2026, despite high global liquidity, Bitcoin crashed. This was caused by the “Warsh Paradox”—the nomination of Kevin Warsh as Fed Chair signaled aggressive balance sheet shrinkage (QT), draining “Net Liquidity” even while headline M2 remained high.
* The Lag: The model now incorporates a ~60-day transmission lag, explaining why liquidity injections take two months to reflect in asset prices.
5. The Geopolitical Lens: Sovereign Reserve Asset
Core Premise: Bitcoin acts as insurance against “Fiscal Dominance” (unpayable sovereign debt) and a neutral settlement layer for nations fearing sanctions.
* Valuation Model: The VanEck 2050 Model projects a $61 trillion market cap ($2.9M/coin) based on Bitcoin capturing 10% of global trade and 2.5% of central bank reserves.
* The Reality Check: In 2025, during acute geopolitical stress (”Tariff Turmoil”), gold rallied +55% while Bitcoin fell -6%. This proved Bitcoin is currently a risk-on “debasement hedge” rather than an immediate “safe haven” like gold.
* Legislative Catalyst: The GENIUS Act and proposals for a U.S. Strategic Bitcoin Reserve have structurally integrated Bitcoin into the U.S. financial plumbing, effectively “hardwiring” it to the dollar system.
6. The Market Structure Lens: On-Chain & “The Black Box”
Core Premise: The blockchain provides a perfect ledger of cost basis (Realized Cap) and investor psychology (MVRV Ratio).
* The ETF Blind Spot: The launch of Spot ETFs broke traditional on-chain analysis. Massive volumes now trade off-chain in “omnibus” custodial wallets (e.g., Coinbase Prime), rendering Layer-1 data a “lagging ghost”.
* The Unified Model: Modern valuation requires a “Hybrid” approach. It combines L1 data (supply floor) with ETF flow data (marginal demand) and CME derivatives data (leverage/speculation) to see the full picture.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bitcoinnewsdigest.substack.com