It’s the first episode of the new year, and The Only Bourbon Fans crew is kicking things off with a brand-new blind tasting series.

They introduce a new review series focused on classic, often-overlooked whiskeys—bottles that deserve more love and make great everyday pours. For the first blind tasting, they dive into three high-proof favorites: Wild Turkey Rare Breed, 1792 Full Proof, and Old Forester 1920.

The Guys chime in with their thoughts on each whiskey and whether these classics still deserve a spot on your shelf.