In this episode, the guys jump into a blind tasting of Peerless whiskies—no labels, no hints, just their palates and a lot of opinions. They go back and forth on what they’re picking up in each pour, from flavor notes to favorites, and crack plenty of jokes along the way. There’s some real appreciation for how complex and bold the Peerless lineup is, and it’s fun hearing how different each person’s palate is. They also get into how much these bottles cost, how easy they are to find, and how their taste in whiskey has evolved over the years.

Oh, and the hunt for the perfect name for Zack’s baby begins... Peerless, anyone?