Book Bits & Chill

Should you read Threshing Day by Rebecca Yarros now or wait for book 4? Spoiler free verdict first, then full spoilers.

Threshing Day isn't book 4. It's a collection of 13 threshing stories from your favorite Empyrean series characters and their dragons. We break down what the point of a novella even is, why Rebecca released this one now, and whether you need it before Fourth Wing book 4. Plus: audiobook vs the GraphicAudio version (out Oct 13), and whether to read it now or after ACOTAR 6.

Then we cross the spoiler line: favorite and least favorite POVs, marked ones vs Navarrians, the lying dragons, the trees, who the brother is, Garrick and Imogen, and which dragons would realistically bond with us (and whether we'd survive threshing).

Which dragon would choose you? Tell us in the comments or on Instagram @bookbitsclub.

00:00 Happy threshing day
01:23 What Threshing Day is and isn't
02:32 What's the point of a novella
04:39 Why Rebecca released it now
06:33 Why 13 stories instead of one
08:01 Read it now or wait for book 4
11:53 Audiobook vs GraphicAudio
12:45 Our spoiler free ratings
13:28 Spoilers start: favorite POVs
21:09 The POV we didn't see coming
23:33 Who's the brother
26:00 What are the dragons up to
28:27 The trees
29:54 The dragons are lying
32:00 Unreliable narrators and Asher Sorrengail
34:08 Xaden's family twist
36:11 Dain and Violet's family theories
37:56 Blue dragons vs Navarre
38:59 Garrick and Imogen
42:15 Where signets come from
44:33 A new appreciation for Violet's threshing
45:23 Which dragons would bond us
50:51 Would we survive threshing
53:11 Next week

Follow on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bookbitsclub

Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BookBitsAndChill

The Love Hypothesis movie just dropped on Prime Video and we have one very important question: WHERE WAS THE YEARNING?

This week Book Bits Club is breaking down the full adaptation of Ali Hazelwood’s The Love Hypothesis, what the movie got right, what it completely changed from the book, and whether Adam Carlson survived the jump from BookTok boyfriend to on-screen boyfriend.

We get into the missing fake-dating tension, the Chapter 16 of it all, why the entire conference storyline had us spiraling, the Tom villain rewrite, Holden getting completely AXED, Lily Reinhart and Tom Bateman’s casting, and why the movie somehow lost so many of the stakes that made the book work.

Plus, we have very different opinions on whether you should read The Love Hypothesis before watching the movie or save the book for after.

If you watched The Love Hypothesis and immediately needed to discuss every single change from the book, you’re in the right place.

🎙️ Book Bits & Chill is a podcast for people who read romance and romantasy, love a book adaptation spiral, and are always two chapters from a book hangover. New episodes every week.

⏱️ CHAPTERS

0:00 The Love Hypothesis forgot one very important thing: yearning
1:04 First impressions: did we actually like the movie?
4:10 Did it deliver the Ali Hazelwood effect?
6:30 Should The Love Hypothesis have been a TV show?
7:32 The weird Off Campus similarities
8:40 Should you read the book before watching?

-- Spoilers Start Here --

11:31 The biggest book-to-movie changes
11:49 What happened to Adam and Olive’s yearning?
14:42 Olive’s missing backstory
15:25 They changed the entire reason for fake dating
18:25 Tom Bateman as Adam Carlson
19:47 WHY did they cut Holden?!
21:17 The conference is where everything fell apart
21:47 Chapter 16: did the movie deliver?
24:00 The conference ending and Tom rewrite
25:20 Book ending vs. movie ending
28:22 Lily Reinhart and Tom Bateman casting
29:55 Did they remove all the stakes?
33:07 What the movie actually got RIGHT
36:19 Should you read or watch The Love Hypothesis first?
36:50 Final verdict: was it a good adaptation?
37:55 Our final movie ratings

📚 MENTIONED IN THIS EPISODE

The Love Hypothesis by Ali Hazelwood
The Love Hypothesis — Prime Video
Off Campus / The Deal by Elle Kennedy
People We Meet on Vacation by Emily Henry
Deep End by Ali Hazelwood
Heated Rivalry show and book
Fourth Wing / The Empyrean Series by Rebecca Yarros

💬 Drop your Love Hypothesis rating in the comments AND settle the debate: are you team read-the-book-first or team watch-the-movie-first?

#TheLoveHypothesis #AliHazelwood #BookAdaptation #BookPodcast #BookTok

Follow on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bookbitsclub

Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BookBitsAndChill

Mafia boss, morally gray villain, or a beast in a mansion: why do we love book boyfriends we'd run from in real life?

Cassie and Emily start with a real Reddit request for a mafia romance where the FMC has no idea the MMC is in the mob, and he refuses to let her walk away once she finds out. Then they get into what makes a love interest unhinged in a fun way versus too far.

In this episode:

• The Aristotle theory that fiction lets us feel big, dangerous things with zero real stakes
• What unhinged means to each of us: Emily wants the obsessive, broody guy who's only down bad for one girl, Cassie wants the mob boss and the white collar criminal
• Why we fall for the beast, the vampire, and the recluse in Beauty and the Beast retellings
• Where the line is: villains who get a moment of clarity, motivations that make sense, and why serial killers and stalkers are a hard no
• Why we always pick the bad boy over the nice one
• Our most unhinged book boyfriends and TV men

Chapters:
(00:00) The Reddit request: a mafia boss the FMC doesn't know is mafia
(01:09) Why we love unhinged love stories (Aristotle weighs in)
(02:52) What unhinged means to each of us
(05:49) Beauty and the Beast, monsters, and paranormal men
(07:29) When fantasy goes too far: real life criminals and Tommy Shelby
(09:32) Where's the line? Villains, motivations, and hard nos
(11:50) Why we always pick the bad boy over the nice one
(13:50) Our most unhinged book boyfriends
(23:46) Unhinged TV men: House of the Dragon and True Blood
(26:42) Your turn: send us your most unhinged love interest

Tell us your most unhinged love story or love interest in the comments or DMs @bookbitsclub.

Mentioned: Fourth Wing, Zodiac Academy, Daggermouth, Poison Daughter, Fall of Ruin and Wrath, Chasing the Wild, Twilight, The Vampire Diaries, Gossip Girl, Peaky Blinders, House of the Dragon, True Blood, You

Heads up: adult language and spicy book talk.

Follow on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bookbitsclub

Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BookBitsAndChill

Remember when reading used to feel like the most exciting thing in the world? Staying up way too late for one more chapter, fighting for the next library book, and fully believing you might stumble into a magical world someday?

So...when did we stop having that much fun?

This week on Book Bits & Chill, we're doing a full READING RESET. We're talking about why so many adults fall out of love with reading, what childhood readers knew that we somehow forgot, and how to actually find that feeling again.

And because fall might be the perfect season for a reading slump reset, we're sharing our fall book recs for every mood: cozy romance, dark academia, magical schools, spooky sci-fi, and the slightly existential books that make you want to get your life together before 2027.

WHAT TO EXPECT:
• Why adults fall out of love with reading
• The childhood reading magic we lose as we get older
• Phones vs. school vs. adult life: who's the biggest culprit?
• What actually gets you out of a reading slump
• The romance-to-romantasy gateway pipeline
• Why audiobooks might be the ultimate reading reset
• Why fall makes us want to become readers again
• Fall book recs for cozy, spooky, nostalgic, and existential moods

BOOKS + AUTHORS MENTIONED:
The Princess Academy by Shannon Hale
Trial of the Sun Queen By Nisha J Tuli
ACOTAR by Sarah J Maas
Half City & Cursed City by Kate Golden
Zodiac Academy by Caroline Peckham & Susanne Valenti
Nightshade by Autumn Woods
Book Lovers by Emily Henry
Christina Lauren books
Lyla Sage books
First-Time Caller by B.K. Borison
Midnight Train by Matt Haig
Dark Matter by Blake Crouch

If your TBR has been collecting dust, you're deep in a reading slump, or you just miss the way books used to make you feel, consider this your official fall reading reset.

Grab a blanket, pick the book that sounds FUN, and let's bring the whimsy back.

New episodes of Book Bits & Chill every week.

Follow on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bookbitsclub

Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BookBitsAndChill

Is Rachel Gillig’s The Knave and the Moon a worthy finale to the Stonewater Kingdom duology? We’re breaking down the highly anticipated romantasy sequel to The Knight and the Moth, from Rory and Sybil’s romance and the infamous gargoyle to Benji’s villain era, the tournaments, the sprites, and that emotional ending. Plus, we compare The Knave and the Moon vs. The Knight and the Moth and decide which book wins.

⚠️ SPOILERS HALFWAY THROUGH! If you haven’t finished The Knave and the Moon, listen through the first half for spoiler-free reactions.

00:00 — The Knave and the Moon Review: Should You Read It?
01:00 — The Knight and the Moth Recap
02:00 — Rory, Sybil & the Dual POV
05:30 — The Romance, Yearning & Spice
08:30 — Why the Stonewater Kingdom Duology Works
16:30 — Our Ratings: 4.5 vs. 5 Stars
18:00 — SPOILERS BEGIN
18:40 — Bartholomew / The Gargoyle
21:00 — Sybil's Character Arc
22:00 — Benji's Villain Era
28:45 — The Tournaments & Game of Thrones Vibes
31:00 — History Repeating Itself & the Sprites
40:45 — THE ENDING: Maud, Bartholomew & Benji
46:00 — Rory & Sybil's Ending
47:00 — The Knave vs. The Knight and the Moth
50:15 — Which Book Is Better?
53:00 — Who Should Read The Knave and the Moon?

Follow on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bookbitsclub

Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BookBitsAndChill

August was one of our most chaotic reading months of the year...and somehow September is gearing up to be even crazier. 

This month we're wrapping up everything we read in August, from literary fiction and fantasy to rock star romance, tiny Victorian journals, and the rarest Book Bits & Chill event of all: a book we BOTH gave 5 stars.

Then it's time to build our September TBR, and the publishing industry has given us absolutely no peace. We're talking huge romantasy releases, adaptations we need to prepare for, pirates, John Green, books that will probably make us cry, and one sequel theory that already has us spiraling.

WHAT TO EXPECT:
✨ Our 5-star read of the month
📖 August reading wrap up + honest book reviews
🚩 Emily's questionable return to her dark romance roots
⚽ Friends-to-lovers discourse
🗡️ Our most anticipated September romantasy releases
🎬 Reading The Love Hypothesis before the movie
🏴‍☠️ Our incoming pirate girl era
🌙 The Knave and the Moon theories that have us STRESSED

BOOKS MENTIONED:
The Good Parts
Sweet as Sin
Slanting Towards the Sea
They're Going to Love You
Abby Offsides
Sweet Heat
The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion Vol. 4
The Knave and the Moon
Threshing Day
Cursed City
The Love Hypothesis
Tempest
The Pirate Queen
Hollywood Ending
Good People
Little Wonders

Come back next week for our Should You Read This? episode on The Knave and the Moon because we need answers immediately. Specifically: KNAVE. MENDACIOUS. WHAT DOES THE MOON MEAN?!

Subscribe for weekly book chats, BookTok reviews, romantasy chaos, author interviews, and recommendations from your book besties who are reading for pleasure, not pressure. 💕

Follow on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bookbitsclub

Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BookBitsAndChill

Anna McCallie, author of breakout sports romance debut Abby Offsides, joins us to talk soccer (football), found family, and falling for the wrong guy at the right time. Abby Offsides has taken over romance readers' shelves this year, pulling comparisons to Ted Lasso meets Off Campus, and this episode gets into all of it: the real footballers who inspired swoony Scottish football captain Lachlan Ramsey, why sports romance is having its moment right alongside the World Cup, and the messy, morally complicated stakes that make this slow burn hit different. We also get the real story behind the "Offside" versus "Offsides" title debate, what it was like writing a heroine who reinvents her whole life overnight, and a first look at what Anna's writing next, including a surprise reveal about an unreleased Pride and Prejudice retelling. Whether you're already deep in the sports romance pipeline or you've never watched a match in your life, this one has the banter, the emotional damage, and the BBC-coded chaos you came for.

Follow on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bookbitsclub

Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BookBitsAndChill

This week on Book Bits and Chill we are investigating the two types of readers who are reading This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me right now:

⭐ The “Five stars. One of my favorite books of the year. Ilona Andrews can do no wrong.”

and

🫠 The “I’m 30% in and I genuinely do not know who anyone is.”

And somehow...we get BOTH.

By the end of this episode youll know if you should bump it up your TBR to get into the action or if this one is best saved for later.

First, we’re keeping it completely spoiler-free and answering the important questions: What are you getting yourself into? How bad is the learning curve REALLY? Who is going to eat this book up? And is it worth pushing through the confusion?

Then the spoiler warning hits and we’re talking about EVERYTHING.

So if This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me has been staring at you from your TBR while the internet screams conflicting opinions at you, consider this your book bestie consultation. 💗

Subscribe for more Book Bits & Chill, including fantasy and romance book reviews, BookTok reads, author interviews, monthly reading wrap-ups, and all the chaotic book bestie conversations in between.

Follow on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bookbitsclub

Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BookBitsAndChill

Emma Brodie, author of Into the Blue, sits down with us to talk about writing a fictional fandom that feels completely real, the improv background behind AJ and Noah's connection, why she chose to market this as a love story instead of a novel, and THAT ending that we're still processing. Plus the origin of the hairdryer, her honest take on the romantasy crossover, and the TV adaptation news we're manifesting as super fans of this book. Spoiler territory starts about halfway through, you've been warned.

Follow on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bookbitsclub

Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BookBitsAndChill

It's time for another Monthly Reading Wrap Up!

July gave us everything... new obsessions, unexpected disappointments, emotional damage, and a few books we already know we'll be recommending for a long time.

This week we're sharing everything we read in July, including our biggest surprises, books that lived up to the hype (and ones that maybe didn't), before building our August TBR featuring BookTok favorites, romance, fantasy, literary fiction, and the books we're most excited to pick up next.

Books Mentioned:
 • Games: A Love Story
 • Along Came Amor
 • Burn Down Master's House
 • The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion
 • Ballad of the Falling Dragons
 • The Paradise Problem
 • This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me
 • On Mystic Lake
 • The Good Parts
 • Big Fan
 • Piranesi
 • The Alchemist
 • Love Hypothesis
 • Razorblade Tears
 • The Shampoo Effect
 • Little Wonder
 • Evenings and Weekends

Whether you're looking for your next romance, fantasy, literary fiction, or emotional read, we've got plenty of recommendations.

💛 And if you're looking for more book recommendations, author interviews, and weekly conversations that feel like chatting with your book besties, make sure to subscribe and join us every week.

Follow on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bookbitsclub

Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BookBitsAndChill