On the morning of May 8, 1621, forty-seven men knelt on a beach in the Banda Islands. They were the orang kaya, the merchant-aristocrats who had governed these islands for generations. They had surrendered peacefully, trusting Dutch promises. Japanese mercenaries stood behind them with swords. Jan Pieterszoon Coen watched from a wooden chair as, one by one, they were beheaded. Their crime: selling nutmeg to whoever offered the best price.
This episode traces three thousand years of obsession. Rome hemorrhaged fifty million sesterces annually for pepper. When Alaric the Visigoth ransomed the Eternal City in 408 CE, he demanded three thousand pounds of peppercorns alongside the gold. For centuries, myths about serpents guarding cinnamon and birds nesting in cloves protected the middlemen who controlled the trade. Then Marco Polo returned from China and revealed the truth: the spices came from ordinary trees in places that could be found.
Portugal found them first. Vasco da Gama reached India in 1498, was mocked for his pathetic gifts, and returned to burn the Miri—a ship of pilgrims returning from Mecca—killing four hundred men, women, and children as an example. Afonso de Albuquerque conquered the chokepoints: Goa, Malacca, Hormuz. The cosmopolitan Indian Ocean, where merchants of all faiths had traded for centuries, became a Portuguese protection racket backed by cannons.
Then came the Dutch. The VOC, chartered in 1602, invented the modern corporation: permanent capital, transferable shares, limited liability. It needed these innovations to commit violence at scale. On Banda, Coen eliminated the entire population—fifteen thousand people reduced to fewer than one thousand through massacre, starvation, and enslavement—to secure a nutmeg monopoly. The trees survived. The people did not.
In Amsterdam, shareholders collected eighteen percent annual dividends. Rembrandt painted masterpieces. The Golden Age bloomed. The distance between the boardroom and the blood was measured in thousands of miles and layers of bureaucracy. This insulation was not a bug. It was a feature.
Pierre Poivre, a one-armed French botanist who hated the Dutch, spent twenty-five years smuggling spice seedlings out of the Moluccas. By 1772, he had broken the monopoly. The VOC collapsed in 1799, one hundred ten million guilders in debt. The genocide had been for nothing.
Today, tourists photograph the old Dutch fort on Banda. They buy nutmeg from descendants of the enslaved workers imported to replace the dead. The beach where the orang kaya knelt has no memorial. The sand has been washed by four centuries of tides. But the blood soaked into the soil of those islands paid for the world we inherited. The spice must flow. It always has. The cost of that flowing need not be forgotten.