Halacha

Breaking a Minyan by Leaving the Synagogue


Listen Later

As discussed in previous installments, if a Minyan of precisely ten people is praying, and one of them leaves in the middle of a section that requires a Minyan, those who remain may complete that section despite not having a Minyan. As long as at least six men remain, they may complete the section that began in the presence of a Minyan. Thus, for example, if the Hazzan began the Hazara (repetition of the Amida), and the Minyan was lost in the middle of the repetition, he may continue and complete the Hazara. However, Halacha speaks very harshly of a person who breaks a Minyan by departing in the middle of the service, leaving behind fewer than ten men. The Sages applied to such a person the stern warning of the prophet Yeshayahu (1:28), "Ve'ozebeh Hashem Yichlu" – "Those who abandon G-d shall be annihilated," Heaven forbid. It must be emphasized that this applies only to someone whose departure results in the loss of a Minyan. If there are more than ten men present, then one who leaves the synagogue is not included in this harsh condemnation. Furthermore, the Mishna Berura writes that the Sages speak here only of a person who leaves during a part of the prayer service that requires a Minyan – such as the Hazara (repetition of the Amida), Kaddish and Torah reading. If a person needs to leave, he may do so if the congregation is not currently reciting a part of the prayer service requiring ten men. For example, if the Hazzan is reciting the Kaddish after Yishtabah, and the tenth man wishes to leave, he may wait until after Kaddish and then leave. This is allowed even though he prevents the remaining nine from reciting the later sections of the service that require a Minyan. Similarly, if a person needs to leave during the Hazara, he should do so after the completion of the Hazara. (According to Ashkenazic custom, which views Kaddish Titkabal as part of the Hazara, he must wait until after Kaddish Titkabal.) An exception to this rule is Nakdishach, during which one may never leave the synagogue. Importantly, this entire discussion applies to a person who already prayed. Irrespective of one's responsibility to the other nine men in the synagogue, he has a personal obligation to pray with a Minyan, and so he should not leave without a pressing need that justifies missing a Minyan.
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

HalachaBy Mansour, Rabbi Eli

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

71 ratings


More shows like Halacha

View all
The Ben Shapiro Show by The Daily Wire

The Ben Shapiro Show

153,989 Listeners

WSJ What’s News by The Wall Street Journal

WSJ What’s News

4,420 Listeners

Israel Story by Israel Story

Israel Story

1,203 Listeners

The Rabbi Sacks Legacy by Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks

The Rabbi Sacks Legacy

557 Listeners

Daily Gemara Podcast - Daf Yomi By Rabbi Eli J. Mansour by Rabbi Eli J. Mansour

Daily Gemara Podcast - Daf Yomi By Rabbi Eli J. Mansour

77 Listeners

A Torah State Of Mind by Rabbi Shlomo Farhi

A Torah State Of Mind

82 Listeners

Streetwise Hebrew by TLV1 Studios

Streetwise Hebrew

987 Listeners

Meaningful People by Meaningful Minute

Meaningful People

2,003 Listeners

The Q & A with Rabbi Breitowitz Podcast by Rabbi Dr Yitzchak Breitowitz

The Q & A with Rabbi Breitowitz Podcast

233 Listeners

For Heaven's Sake by Shalom Hartman Institute, Ark Media

For Heaven's Sake

477 Listeners

Call Me Back - with Dan Senor by Ark Media

Call Me Back - with Dan Senor

3,333 Listeners

The Times of Israel Daily Briefing by The Times of Israel

The Times of Israel Daily Briefing

1,097 Listeners

Rabbi Daniel Kalish Shiurim - Waterbury Mesivta by Rabbi Daniel Kalish Shiurim

Rabbi Daniel Kalish Shiurim - Waterbury Mesivta

283 Listeners

AND HERE’S MODI by Modi

AND HERE’S MODI

229 Listeners

A-Muse with Reb Ari Bensoussan by Rabbi Ari Bensoussan

A-Muse with Reb Ari Bensoussan

26 Listeners