Breaking Consensus

Breaking Consensus

By Kevin von NiederhäusernSociety & CulturePhilosophy
Download on the App Store

Breaking Consensus episodes

  • #11 Lance Bush - Lance Independent Respectfully Destroys My Philosophical Assumptions

    Dr. Lance Bush is a psychologist and philosopher working on moral psychology and metaethics. His research asks whether non-philosophers are moral realists. He runs the Lance Independent YouTube channel and blog, where he debates and discusses metaethics and other philosophical topics.


    00:00 Why "Realist Vs Anti-Realist" Is The Wrong Divide

    05:26 Anti-Realist Quietism: A View With No Name Yet

    11:05 The Hidden Assumption Behind All Five Meta-Ethics Positions

    13:00 "Words Don't Mean Things, People Mean Things": Are Ordinary People Moral Realists?

    15:42 Is Lance An Emotivist? Why Not

    23:01 How Quasi-Realism Ended Up Indistinguishable From Realism

    30:30 The Empirical Data: Three Quarters Of People Give Anti-Realist Answers

    35:04 Is Realism "King Of The Hill"? The Common-Sense Burden Shift

    37:51 "Psychopath" And Other Things Anti-Realists Get Called

    45:15 Philosophical Induction: Why Philosophers Don't Think Like Normal People

    47:57 The Weirdest Of The Weird: WEIRD Populations And Moral Philosophy

    50:15 How Can English Sentences Reveal How 7,000 Languages Work?

    53:25 Science Brings The Receipts, So What Does Philosophy Bring?

    59:29 Phenomenal Conservatism: Epistemic Blank Checks And "Vibes"

    1:09:13 Analytic Philosophy Is "Reading The Wrong Book"

    1:12:05 Pragmatism: Truth That Can Change

    1:24:19 Qualia Quietism: Why "What Is It Like" May Be A Conceptual Mistake

    1:37:38 Is Philosophy A Game Of Fantastical Sudoku?

    1:43:25 Math, Logic And Intuitions: A Dilemma For Huemer

    1:53:31 Squirrels Vs Schmirls: Can You Communicate The Concept Of A "Reason"?

    2:05:09 Would Aliens Agree With Us About What's Bad?

    2 hr 8 min
  • #10 Michael Huemer - Huemer's Ultimate Guide to Reason

    Michael Huemer is an analytic philosopher and professor of philosophy at the University of Colorado Boulder. He is the author of 'Ethical Intuitionism', 'Knowledge, Reality, and Value', 'The Problem of Political Authority' and 'Progressive Myths', and is known for defending phenomenal conservatism, ethical intuitionism, direct realism and libertarian free will.

    0:00 Does Philosophy Teach Better Reasoning?

    2:15 Formal Logic vs. Learning by Example

    6:41 Why Other Fields Don't Transfer

    7:40 Economics, Assumptions and Democracy

    11:29 Michael's Books and Where to Start

    14:04 Skeptic Busting: Modus Ponens vs. Modus Tollens

    16:28 The Moorean Shift and Answering Skepticism

    23:27 Free Will and Why Hard Determinism Fails

    30:54 Ontology: What Exists?

    33:50 Moral Facts and Intuition

    45:53 Numbers, Universals and Kinds of Existence

    56:57 Physicalism and the Mind

    1:00:40 Phenomenal Conservatism and Common Sense

    1:04:14 Trusting Science and the Replication Crisis

    1:08:08 Epistemic vs. Moral Normativity

    1:15:08 Why Be Rational?

    1:21:16 Pascal's Wager and Believing for Practical Reasons

    1:23:05 Compatibilism and the Consequence Argument

    1:32:12 What You Should Read Next

    1 hr 33 min
  • #9 Michael Granado - Was The Scientific Revolution A Philosophical One?

    Michael Granado is a philosopher whose work focuses on the history and philosophy of science. He also has a YouTube channel covering philosophy, history, and the philosophy of time.

    00:00 The Complexity of the Scientific Revolution

    03:07 Aristotle's Influence on Science

    13:46 The Shift from Teleology to Mechanism

    15:54 The Role of Mathematics in Astronomy

    21:57: Was Ptolemy Unique?25:54 Aristotle’s Reign

    29:17 Copernicus’ Heliocentrism

    35:37 Christianity vs. Science

    44:20 Kepler’s Imperfect Circles

    46:24 Differences between Kepler and Galileo

    49:56 Realists vs. Anti-Realists about Mathematics

    51:23 Galileo’s Methodology and Observations

    59:23 So What Was the Scientific Revolution About?

    1 hr 6 min
  • #8 Nikk Effingham - Existence Is Weirder Than You Think

    Nikk Effingham is Professor of Philosophy at the University of Birmingham, where he researches metaphysics, philosophy of time, philosophy of religion, and conspiracy theories. He's the author of An Introduction to Ontology, among many other books.


    0:00 The Big Question

    2:35 First Step To Building Your Worldview

    5:36 Where Do You Start?

    9:15 Parmenides' Ontology

    12:10 Didn’t Science Solve The Problem?

    15:30 What Does "Exist" Mean?

    18:50 Universals vs. Particulars

    22:58 Kinds of Explanations

    27:20 Are Philosophers Simply Confused?

    30:31 Types of Existence

    34:42 How To Select Metaphysical Theories

    39:32 David Lewis's Bonkers Idea

    43:15 Are We Just Arguing About Words?

    47:28 You Are Already Doing Metaphysics

    49:43 What Are Even Numbers?

    52:30 Aren’t Abstract Objects Just Concepts?

    59:10 Why Are Philosophical Theories Weird?

    1 hr 4 min
  • #7 Jonathan Matheson - Thinking Is Overrated

    Jonathan Matheson is a philosopher and professor specialising in epistemology, with a focus on the epistemology of disagreement and the rationality of intellectual deference. He is the author of 'Why It's Okay Not to Think for Yourself', in which he argues that outsourcing your beliefs to those better positioned to answer a question is not intellectual laziness but a coherent and defensible epistemic policy.


    00:00 It's OK To Be Triggered

    03:00 Explaining 'It's OK Not To Think for Yourself'

    05:53 What Is An Expert?

    10:52 Our Dependence On Experts

    13:00 Follow The Experts' Consensus

    15:25 What To Do When Experts Disagree?

    17:31 Do Experts Actually Know More?

    21:13 Matheson's Arguments

    24:40 Solving The Free Will Problem In 2 Weeks

    26:18 Gaslighting And Gatekeeping

    31:50 What About Our Intellectual Autonomy?

    36:40 Are We Smarter Than Aristotle?

    39:54 The Benefits Of Thinking For Yourself

    42:10 Should We All Study Philosophy?

    46:57 Should We Be Agnostic About God's Existence?

    51:45 Forced To Make A Decision?

    58:42 AI: Should We Defer To The Machines?

    1 hr 4 min
  • #6 Miles Donahue - How To Actually Develop Critical Thinking

    Miles Donahue is an analytic philosopher and PhD candidate at Oxford specialising in philosophy of religion, with a focus on the fine tuning argument for the existence of God and multiverse theories. He hosts The Uncertainty Podcast, where he engages professional philosophers on the biggest questions in metaphysics and religion.

    00:00 What Is Philosophy?

    05:11 Should We Always Pursue Truth?

    10:11 Theism, Absurdism, and Life's Meaning

    12:23 Which Argument Forced You To Change Your Beliefs?

    16:40 What Are The Tools Of The Philosopher?

    19:58 Is What Seems True Actually True?

    23:53 The Difference Between Philosophers and Non-Philosophers

    25:33 How To Keep Your Friends (for Philosophers)

    31:25 Engaging in Philosophical Conversations35:42 Is Philosophy Niche?

    41:39 What Skills Are Developed Through Studying Philosophy?

    44:03 The Journey of Belief and Skepticism

    50:14 How To Discuss Emotional Topics?

    55:07 Maintaining Integrity in Debates

    1 hr 2 min
  • #5 Michael Gerlich - Why AI Makes You Feel Smarter While Making You Dumber

    Prof. Dr. Michael Gerlich is a sociologist and behavioural scientist specialising in the impact of AI on human cognition and society. His research was among the first to empirically demonstrate that AI negatively affects critical thinking — findings that have since been confirmed by multiple independent studies — making him one of the leading voices on the human cost of AI adoption.

    His latest book, The Convenience Trap, argues that the most dangerous thing about AI is not that it is too powerful — but that it is too convenient.

    00:00 The Impact of AI on Critical Thinking

    02:38 Cognitive Offloading vs. Cognitive Outsourcing

    05:52 AI vs. Google

    08:47 The Influence of AI on Social Media and Beliefs

    11:42 Using AI to Enhance Critical Thinking

    14:46 Corporate Challenges with AI Implementation

    17:41 The Role of AI in Efficiency and Workload

    20:49 The Future of Work

    23:53 Critical Thinking in the Age of AI

    37:29 Creating Friction in AI Processes

    41:42 Market Forces and AI Competition

    43:59 The Challenges of AI Implementation

    47:46 Perception vs. Reality of AI Impact

    54:28 The Irreversibility of AI Development

    59:49 The Need for Dialogue on AI Regulation

    01:04:28 Preparing Society for AI's Impact

    1 hr 6 min
  • #4 Elise Crull - Why Science Can't Answer Its Own Deepest Questions

    Elise Crull is a philosopher of science and Associate Professor at The City College of New York. Her work bridges philosophy and physics, focusing on the conceptual foundations of modern physics, especially quantum mechanics and relativity. Recently named a Fellow of the American Physical Society, she has also appeared twice on StarTalk, where she discussed the philosophical foundations of physics with Neil deGrasse Tyson.


    Timestamps:

    00:00 – The Intersection of Philosophy and Science

    02:37 – Defining Science and Its Boundaries

    05:40 – What Is Matter?

    13:48 – The Value of Philosophy in Science

    19:42 – What Is Objectivity?

    29:48 – Falsifiability and the Nature of Scientific Theories

    33:07 – Quantum Mechanics: Determinism vs Indeterminism

    36:03 – The Limits of Science and God

    38:38 – The Multiverse Interpretation of Quantum Physics

    42:10 – Does Science Provide Explanations?

    46:30 – Einstein's Revolution: From Newtonian to Relativistic Physics

    53:42 – Is There Progress in Science?

    57:44 – Are Scientific Theories True?

    01:02:28 – Measuring Time and Space: A Philosophical Inquiry

    01:06:37 – Diving Deeper Into Einstein's Special Relativity

    01:08:47 – This Is Why Science Needs Philosophers

    1 hr 9 min
  • #3 Jeanette Andrews - What Magic Teaches Us About Beliefs & Polarization

    Jeanette Andrews is a New York–based artist and magician whose work bridges illusion, installation, and conceptual art. Her performances function as live thought experiments — multisensory investigations into perception, cognition, and belief. Jeanette Andrews is a New York–based artist and magician whose work bridges illusion, installation, and conceptual art. Her performances function as live thought experiments — multisensory investigations into perception, cognition, and belief. She has presented commissioned works with the Museum of Contemporary Art Chicago, the Québec City Biennial, the Boca Raton Museum of Art, among many others, and has been affiliated with Harvard’s metaLAB and held a fellowship with MIT’s Center for Art, Science and Technology.


    More from Jeanette Andrews:

    Website: https://www.jeanetteandrews.com/

    Instragram: https://www.instagram.com/jeanetteandrewsmagic/


    Timestamps:

    0:00 – What Is Magic, Really?

    5:15 – The Power of Framing: How Context Impacts Perception

    11:47 – Consensual Deception: When We Agree to Be Fooled

    13:12 – Magic, Manipulation, and the Ethics of Belief

    19:04 – The Real Purpose of Illusion

    24:58 – What Magic Reveals About the Mind and Perception

    26:37 – Where Art Meets Philosophy and Science

    35:00 – Deception, Bias, and the Architecture of Belief

    40:06 – How Magicians Exploit (and Expose) Our Cognitive Traps

    46:40 – A Live Experiment in Cognitive Magic

    50:01 – Inside Jeanette Andrews’ MIT Project The Attestation

    1:05:20 – [Announcement] What Is Coming Next For Jeanette Andrews

    1 hr 7 min
  • #2 Tristram McPherson - Should You Act Ethically Even If It Changes Nothing?

    Tristram McPherson is a moral philosopher and Professor at The Ohio State University. His work bridges ethics, metaethics, and political philosophy, with a focus on the moral challenges of contemporary life.

    More from Tristram McPherson:

    Website: https://sites.google.com/site/drtristram/

    Publications: https://sites.google.com/site/drtristram/publications?authuser=0


    Timestamps:

    00:00 Crowley The Modern Demon

    07:10 The “Drop in the Bucket” Problem

    12:43 Can Tiny Actions Have Huge Consequences?

    18:08 Morality by the Numbers: A Problem?

    26:34 Can Consequences Make a Wrong Action Right?

    34:20 Being Part Of A Group

    36:31 What If You Didn’t Know It Was Wrong?

    43:05 What About Necessary Harms?

    53:10 How Much Can We Reasonably Be Expected to Do?

    59 min

About Breaking Consensus

From the publisher's feed

A podcast that challenges mainstream views through deep conversations on the forces shaping our world. Guests include philosophers, researchers, and curious thinkers who push us to reconsider what we…