This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Gary Seligson: The Grammy-Winning Broadway Drummer Phil Collins Refused to Work Without
Phil Collins snuck into a performance of Wicked one night without telling Gary Seligson he was coming.
The next morning, he walked into Tarzan rehearsal and told the producers he didn’t care who else they put in the band. There was one guy he wanted on drums. Not Chuck Burgi — who had literally replaced Phil Collins in Brand X and was calling in every favor he had to get the gig. Gary Seligson. The one he heard play in the theater when nobody knew he was watching.
That’s the kind of reputation you build over a career that most Broadway musicians would trade anything for.
I chatted with Gary on August 24, 2021. The video is on the Broadway Drumming 101 YouTube channel. Now the audio is available everywhere you get your podcasts — Apple Podcasts, Spotify, wherever you listen.
Gary is a Grammy Award winner who originated the drum books and recorded the cast albums for Aida, Wicked, Tarzan, A Little Princess, School of Rock, and Soft Power. He held the drum chair on Billy Elliot for over three years. He’s on the Motown: The Musical cast recording playing percussion. His Broadway credits span more than two decades — from The Gershwins’ Fascinating Rhythm in 1999 through Bob Fosse’s Dancin’ and Harmony in 2023. In 2025, he headed back out on the road with the Beauty and the Beast revival. He’s also subbed on more than 20 Broadway productions, including Chicago, The Lion King, Les Misérables, Miss Saigon, Cats, and Rent.
Gary grew up in West Orange, New Jersey, banging on his mother’s pots and pans before his father bought him a tiny metal snare drum at age three. He studied with the same teacher from second grade through twelfth grade. He went to the Hartt School of Music in Hartford. He found his way to Gary Chester in New York, who completely rewired how he thought about the instrument, and then told him flat out: never leave town for more than four weeks.
Gary took a touring gig anyway.
Nine years on the road followed. And the moment he pulled into his mother’s driveway after finally deciding to come home, the phone rang. It was Bob Billig calling about Chicago. That’s how this business works when you’ve done the groundwork.
We get into his first Broadway subbing experience at The King and I — walking into the pit two hours before curtain, sitting down at a drum set that felt completely foreign, getting thrown out by the stage manager before the show even started, then spending an hour and forty-five minutes walking around Midtown getting more nervous with every step. Trial by fire. He made the cut, and word traveled fast.
We talk about what it felt like to play alongside Elton John in an Aida rehearsal room. We talk about Phil Collins tapping a pencil on a desk during Tarzan rehearsals — not even playing, just tapping — and how the groove was so wide the entire room felt it. And we talk about the moment Gary flew himself to San Francisco on JetBlue just to watch Wicked out of town, because he needed to know for himself whether to leave Aida for it.
He knew by the first number.
Gary is a Pearl Drums, Sabian Cymbals, Pro-Mark Sticks, Grover Percussion, and Remo Heads endorser, and has been featured in Modern Drummer and DRUM magazine multiple times.
Press play. And if this episode gives you something, please leave us a glowing five-star review wherever you’re listening. It takes 30 seconds and it means everything to the show.
If you’re serious about your own path in this industry, pick up Broadway Bound and Beyond at broadwayboundbook.com. Signed copies at signaturebrandworks.com.
Clayton Craddock is the drummer for Cats: The Jellicle Ball on Broadway at the Broadhurst Theatre. He is also the founder of Broadway Drumming 101 and the author of Broadway Bound and Beyond: A Musician’s Guide to Building a Theater Career.
His Broadway credits include Memphis, Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill, Ain’t Too Proud, and Cats: The Jellicle Ball, with additional credits spanning tick, tick…BOOM!, The Hippest Trip: The Soul Train Musical, and subbing on Rent, Motown, Evita, Avenue Q, and the Hadestown tour.
Clayton has appeared on The View, Good Morning America, The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon, The Today Show, and the Tony Awards. He has performed with artists ranging from Chuck Berry and Ben E. King to Kristin Chenoweth and Norm Lewis.
www.claytoncraddock.com
Get full access to Broadway Bound and Beyond at www.broadwayboundandbeyond.com/subscribe
