Broken but Readable

Broken but Readable

By Greg Scaduto is a freelance journalist, corporate finance professional, and a former US Army officer.Society & CulturePhilosophy
Download on the App Store

Broken but Readable episodes

  • The lecture hall of dead-eyed undergraduates.

    The Campus

    I walked across Fordham’s Bronx campus in the early fall, when the air still held a trace of summer but the light had already begun to thin. Leaves scraped along the walkways like small animals fleeing something unseen. Somewhere a bell rang without urgency, just to mark the hour.

    Students crossed the quad with the unhurried purpose of a migration, some speaking, some not, and their voices grew thin as they neared the buildings. Their steps slowed. The laughter died. They went on in silence toward what waited there.

    I followed the path toward the philosophy building, and the campus seemed to close upon itself as I walked, brick and stone rising with a somber intent, as though erected less to welcome than to endure. The buildings loomed broad and darkened by years of weather, their towers lifting into the gray air like sentinels posted by men who had perished. The windows lay deep in the walls, unlit and inscrutable, giving nothing back to the gaze that searched them.

    There was no haste in the place, only the deep stillness of continuation. It felt shaped by time rather than urgency, possessed of a permanence that neither hurried nor softened. As I moved through it, I sensed that whatever knowledge lay within those walls would not be given freely or quickly, but would ask for patience, and perhaps leave behind a measure of doubt as the cost of learning.

    Inside, the room was dim and cool. Wooden desks scarred with hieroglyphs. A chalkboard that had heard many claims about truth and would hear many more, none of them final. This was where we were meant to encounter Plato. This was where we were meant to reckon with justice.

    The Book

    I bought Plato’s Republic and carried it with me like a responsibility I hadn’t fully agreed to. The thing had real weight. It sat in my bag like a brick with opinions. The font was small. The paper was thin. And the sentences moved forward with the quiet assurance of something that did not care whether you were coming along.

    I highlighted religiously. Whole pages. Paragraphs that glowed with meaning I assumed would reveal itself later, once I was smarter or calmer or older. My internal monologue was deeply sincere.

    This matters.This is important.I’ll come back to this.

    I did not come back to this.

    In class, I nodded. I perfected the look of a young man in active contemplation. I learned to say things like “the ideal city” in a way that suggested I had spent meaningful time there. I participated just enough to avoid suspicion. Around me, others did the same. We were a room full of people quietly agreeing not to ask certain questions.

    Here’s the part I didn’t understand then, but do now: I wasn’t lazy, and I actually wanted to learn this thing. I respected it. I just didn’t understand it. Not in a way that lodged anywhere durable or in a way that changed how I thought or acted or understood the people around me.

    I was earnest. And I still didn’t learn.

    Which is the question that stayed with me long after the book went back on the shelf:

    What exactly did that struggle accomplish?

    The Polite Fiction

    Here’s the polite fiction we maintain, together, like a family lie about how the dog died peacefully in his sleep.

    Most students are not really reading these books.

    They are skimming. They are sampling AI. They are opening them with the same hope you open a Terms and Conditions page, which is to locate the exit as quickly as possible.

    Professors have been doing this long enough to recognize the look of someone who has read the first twenty pages, the last five pages, and a summary written by a person who does not technically exist.

    The students know the professors know.The professors know the students know they know.

    And so we all participate in this quiet, elegant ballet of mutual non-confrontation.

    A hand goes up in class. A comment is made. It is… adjacent. No one stops the music.

    This is not a moral failure, and no one here is a villain. This is what happens when we treat learning like a triathlon people just need to survive.

    The remarkable thing is not that students fake it. It’s how long we’ve all agreed to pretend that they aren’t.

    And the professors, God bless them, tend to treat this like a charming inevitability, like a kind of weather.

    They smile wryly and shrug. They make little jokes about “kids these days,” as if what’s happening is no more alarming than students wearing pajamas to class or calling them by their first name.

    Which is strange, when you think about it, because this is the part where the transmission of ideas quietly fails. Where centuries of thought start getting treated like decorative antiques. And yet the prevailing attitude is one of malaise and resignation, as if the slow erosion of understanding is just one of those things that happens, like inflation or lower-quality towels.

    They seem to think what they are witnessing is harmless, merely because it is familiar.

    And humanities professors, I’ve noticed, love to take pictures of their bookshelves. Not to show you what they’re reading, exactly, but to prove that reading has happened.

    The shelves are never casual, but heavily curated. Color-coordinated in a way that suggests both moral seriousness and light OCD. The spines face outward like a police lineup of guilt. Plato. Kant. Hegel.

    Someone always slips in a copy of Being and Nothingness, which is there less to be read than to quietly threaten guests.

    These images are posted with captions like “Office vibes” or “Current companions,” which is charming, because the books are not companions. They are chaperones. They exist to supervise you, silently, while you answer emails and judge undergraduates.

    The bookshelf isn’t there to be used much. It stands to show that its owner knows which books belong in a room like this.

    This is a collective misunderstanding we agreed not to correct. Owning the books feels adjacent enough to understanding them that we let the distinction blur, and over time the blur hardens into a credential.

    Which is how a shelf becomes a proxy for a mind, and why so many very full shelves are guarding such oddly untouched ideas.

    Reframing Learning

    We talk about learning as though it were synonymous with exposure, as if sitting near a difficult text or struggling through its sentences and smelling the musty pages were itself the point.

    But learning is not reading hard books.Learning is understanding things.

    Difficulty has acquired an almost spiritual status in our culture. We treat it as evidence of seriousness, a kind of moral surcharge paid in confusion.

    Yet difficulty, in itself, has no ethical value. It is simply a condition that may or may not serve understanding.

    We know this intuitively in other domains. No one trains soldiers by issuing contradictory orders and calling the resulting chaos “character-building.” No one teaches a language by deliberately scrambling the grammar and insisting the student persevere out of respect for the language’s history.

    Training is structured challenge. It is calibrated resistance. It is difficulty in the service of clarity, not difficulty as a test of worthiness or a rite of passage.

    If we really care about ideas, we have to care about whether they arrive. Guarding how difficult they are might feel like respect, but it doesn’t keep them alive. It just keeps them contained. Understanding isn’t a favor we grant to people who struggle. It’s the whole reason we bothered having the ideas in the first place.

    Football and Mill

    So imagine a Division I football player. A real one. Someone who has spent years learning a playbook so detailed it might as well be written in another language, and who understands, down to muscle memory, what happens when one person freelances at the wrong time.

    Now imagine trying to explain John Stuart Mill to him—the strange, humane part where Mill argues that societies only get better when individuals are allowed to try different ways of living. That progress doesn’t come from everyone doing the same safe thing, but from people running different routes and se…



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit gregscaduto.substack.com
    16 min
  • NATO is not a charity

    In 2014, Vladimir Putin was helping himself to Crimea, as one does when one has tanks and a complicated relationship with borders. In the summer of that year, the U.S. Army sent my unit to Germany to train with about fifteen other NATO armies.

    The idea was simple: shoot, move, and communicate together, as if we were one fighting force. Different languages, different uniforms, same plan. In theory.

    The five officers in my artillery battery were issued a single car to share. A tiny, egg-shaped European hatchback, the kind that looks like it comes free with the purchase of a croissant. It was a stick shift.

    I figured this would be fine.

    At the time, I was a platoon leader for a howitzer platoon: four self-propelled 155-millimeter guns and thirty-six cannon crew members. We called them “gun bunnies,” affectionately. They were young, loud, permanently dirty, and ran on caffeine, nicotine, and a belief that somehow this would all make sense later.

    One evening, after training wrapped up, we finished briefing the soldiers on the next day’s plan. All the officers decided to drive over to the PX on Grafenwöhr base.

    I grabbed the keys.

    “I’m driving, bitch,” I said to the battery XO. We were all lieutenants, but the XO was the most senior lieutenant.

    “Greg,” he said carefully, “do you know how to drive stick?”

    No, I said. But I am about to learn.

    We all piled into the car. I turned it on. Immediately stalled. Turned it on again. Stalled again. The XO began coaching me from the passenger seat with the tone of a man who had already accepted that God was testing him.

    “Okay, ease off the clutch. No, not like that. Greg. Greg. You’re killing it.”

    The car lurched backward like a drunk mule.

    I panicked. Overcorrected. Gunned it.

    And backed directly into a massive drainage ditch on the side of the road.

    We ended up nose-high, rear end buried in the trench, front wheels dangling uselessly in the air, like a cartoon car realizing too late that the road has ended.

    We all got out and just stood there, staring at it.

    The XO put his hands on his hips. “Greg,” he said, “you are calling the fucking commander to explain this.”

    Before I could respond, eight or ten soldiers appeared out of nowhere.

    They were not American.

    They were lean. Sinewy. All tendon and quiet competence. They looked like men who could survive indefinitely on bread, cigarettes, and mild disappointment. They did not ask questions. They did not speak. They simply assessed the situation the way wolves assess a problem.

    Without being asked, they moved to the back of the car, crouched slightly, and lifted.

    In about three seconds, the car was back on the road. Perfectly fine. Not a scratch.

    They immediately started walking away, like this was nothing. Like they had just helped an old woman cross the street.

    “Thanks, guys!” I yelled.

    One of them gave a thumbs-up.

    “Hey!” I shouted. “What country are you from?”

    “Romania,” one of them said, smiling, as they disappeared into the dark.

    I turned to the other U.S. officers and said, sincerely and confidently, “Wow. I did not know Romania was part of NATO.”

    Romania, it turns out, was not just some random country that happened to have extremely competent guys lurking in the woods.

    Romania joined NATO in 2004, after the Cold War ended and the Soviet Union collapsed. For decades before that, Romania had lived on the wrong side of Europe’s dividing line, under authoritarian rule, inside the Soviet sphere, watching history happen mostly to them.

    When the Iron Curtain lifted, Romania did what many Eastern European countries did: it sprinted west.

    They joined because survival, when you have spent decades on the wrong side of history’s dividing line, requires paperwork. Treaties. The kind of binding promises that make it harder for the next tank column to pretend you do not exist. It was a way of saying, formally and indelibly, we are done being the buffer zone. We want binding guarantees, shared planning, and allies who show up before things get bad, not after.

    And a note to those who side with Putin, citing “NATO expansion”:

    This is where the argument collapses.

    It assumes that nations were pushed there by Washington rather than choosing it themselves. It denies agency to states that had lived under domination and decided, deliberately, that they did not want to do so again.

    NATO did not expand because it was forced outward. It expanded because countries asked to join. They did so openly, repeatedly, and with full knowledge of the risks.

    To describe this as “provocation” is to rewrite cause and effect. It is to say that the desire to be left alone is itself an act of aggression. And you are performing a useful service for the Kremlin when you say this so confidently.

    That kind of logic has a long history. It is the language of empires explaining why other people’s choices are unacceptable.

    And it is dishonest.

    Once Romania joined, it took membership seriously. Training. Interoperability. Proving, over and over again, that it belonged.

    Which may explain why, years later, a group of Romanian soldiers could quietly lift an American officer’s car out of a ditch.

    Lately, when Americans hear “NATO,” they are not thinking about dusty treaties signed in the twentieth century. They are thinking about recent headlines.

    In the past few weeks, the United States has been openly threatening tariffs on European NATO allies because Denmark and other countries sent troops to Greenland, an Arctic territory the U.S. president has insisted America must control for security reasons. European leaders rejected that idea outright and rallied behind Denmark’s sovereignty.

    Though he later walked this back in remarks at Davos, the president at one point declined to rule out using military force to seize Greenland, a move that would pit the United States directly against a NATO ally.

    That dispute prompted war-game exercises with European forces in Greenland and emergency talks in Brussels and Davos. Russia seized on the controversy to claim the alliance was in crisis. The European Union began preparing an Arctic security initiative in response.

    At the same time, the Pentagon has reportedly planned to reduce U.S. participation in some NATO advisory groups, a decision that, while gradual, signals a shift in how America engages with alliance planning and military expertise on the continent.

    The question, then, is not abstract. It is what NATO is, and what happens if the glue that holds it together starts to crack.

    Taking NATO skepticism seriously matters.

    The United States spends more on defense than the rest of NATO combined. For decades, many allies under-invested in their own militaries while assuming American protection would remain permanent, unconditional, and essentially free. That created a lopsided arrangement in which U.S. taxpayers carried costs while foreign governments deferred hard choices at home.

    There is also a deeper concern. Alliances, once formed, tend to become self-justifying. Missions expand. Commitments harden. What began as a clear Cold War necessity can drift into something automatic, defended more out of habit than strategy. From that perspective, asking whether NATO still serves concrete American interests is not reckless.

    Skeptics also point out that Europe is wealthy, technologically advanced, and fully capable of defending itself if it chose to. If nations face real threats, the argument goes, they should meet them with real investment, not moral appeals or historical sentiment. A security guarantee that costs nothing eventually means nothing.

    Finally, there is a democratic argument. Americans never voted for permanent, open-ended obligations that could drag the country into conflicts far from home, based on decisions made by governments they did not elect. Questioning those commitments is not isolationism. It is accountability.

    From this view, the pressure applied by figures like Donald Trump is not about abandoning allies, but about forcing realism back into a system that drifted toward complacency, and reminding everyone tha…



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit gregscaduto.substack.com
    19 min
  • What men can't say about love.

    Sometime last year, an essay titled “he’s not a good husband” circulated widely on social media. It was written by feminist writer Emily May, and it struck a nerve because it named something many women recognize immediately: the exhaustion of being married to a man who is not cruel, not abusive, not unfaithful—but who also does not reliably carry his share of the daily, invisible work of family life.

    The piece argues, forcefully, that women have been trained to soften their language around this problem. To call these men “amazing” or “good guys” because they clear the lowest imaginable bar. To gaslight themselves into gratitude and accept being the unpaid project managers of adulthood while reassuring their partners that everything is basically fine.

    This is not a frivolous argument, and much of it is true.

    When the essay made its way onto social media, I replied in that spirit. I agreed that women often shoulder an unequal share of the mental and emotional labor in heterosexual households. I said plainly that there are many marriages where women feel like unpaid managers of family logistics, and that this is a real and legitimate grievance.

    But I also asked a question that immediately complicated the exchange.

    I wondered whether any part of this story was missing the interior life of the men being described. Whether something real was being flattened by a framework that only allowed us to talk about outcomes, never inner strain.

    Emily replied that she couldn’t acknowledge what was happening inside these men because it was guesswork. That men, in her experience, were not introspective or articulate enough to explain their inner lives. And that it wasn’t her job, as a woman, to do that work for them. She could only speak to the very real effects of their behavior.

    This reveals the quiet rule governing so much modern relationship writing.

    Empathy, in this framework, is conditional. Women deserve it automatically, because their labor is visible and narratable. Men only deserve it if they can articulate their inner struggle clearly enough to be legible. If they fail at that task—if their distress is clumsy, inarticulate, or expressed as withdrawal—then it is treated as either nonexistent or irrelevant.

    This same logic appears, with more professional polish, in recent relationship coverage from The New York Times, including the now-popular concept of mankeeping. Once again that’s mankeeping, like a zookeeping or beekeeping, but for men. This is idea that women are unfairly burdened as the primary emotional infrastructure of men’s lives, that they are left to deal with the “epidemic of male loneliness”. Again, there is truth here. Men are more socially isolated. Women often become the sole outlet for male vulnerability.

    But notice what quietly happens in both arguments.

    Intimacy becomes the thing you’re supposed to protect yourself from. Need—the plain fact of needing someone, or worse, being needed back—gets treated like a diagnosis. The shared labor of sustaining a life together is described as something one person endures while the other passively benefits.

    If a martian were to read the latest gender discourse in the New York Times. I’m talking about columns written by journalists like Catherine Pearson, they would understandably come to infer that men are simply the less-evolved pets of the women they attach themselves to. That they are not competent enough to handle the burdens of a household unsupervised.

    But to share a life with another person is to consent—again and again—to being needed. To need, and to be needed in return. That is not love malfunctioning. That is love working. That is the unspoken contract two people sign when they choose to construct a life whose duration exceeds what either of them could sustain alone.

    When we lose the courage to need and be needed—when we start treating mutual reliance as a moral failure—we don’t become liberated, but instead become brittle, and resentful. We lose the small mercies: the unglamorous accommodations, the patience with inarticulateness, the grace that allows people to grow inside a bond rather than audition for it.

    Because if the price of being grown-up is never needing anyone, then what you are advocating for is loneliness.

    I wrote down the thoughts that will follow, because I became so disheartened by the kind of relationship article that appears with dependable regularity in places like The New York Times, that arrives wearing the calm authority of therapy language and the moral confidence of an HR slide deck, and it explains—patiently, why modern heterosexual men are exhausting, underdeveloped, and in need of supervision.

    They use degrading words like “mankeeping”, probably because they think it’s clever and edgy, but it’s a lazy moral shortcut: a vocabulary that confers righteousness without curiosity, used by female writers in their late 30s who haven’t earned it, because they have never been able to sustain intimacy over decades. Women who have left behind a wake of failed relationships, and use the New York Times as an outlet for their frustration, calling it relationship advice.

    I am tired of the media treating men like creatures one keeps out of obligation rather than affection, fed and tolerated, perhaps even named, but never really trusted to roam the house without supervision. We are told, again and again, that men “can’t express emotions,” as though this were a biological defect rather than the predictable outcome of a lifetime spent learning which feelings are permissible and which must be packed away quickly, lest they cause trouble.

    Somehow, the difficulty of expression gets translated into the absence of feeling altogether. And over time, this misreading hardens into a story we tell ourselves about an entire half of the species, until it becomes a shared cultural script, widening the distance it claims merely to describe.

    So if you’re one of those female columnists—bright, educated, fluent in the language of insight, typing late into the evening in an apartment so orderly it feels faintly reverential—I hope you’ll pause for a moment and consider this: what you are describing as emotional absence may actually be a lifetime of feeling things intensely and being told, repeatedly, to keep it to yourself.

    And I offer this, ladies, as a diplomat. I offer it with love, in the hopes that you may understand us. I do not speak for all men, but probably a lot of them.

    This is called The Quiet Way Men Love, which I posted in written format a few weeks ago.

    The Quiet Way Men Love

    There is a myth men inherit without consenting to it: that love announces itself.

    That it arrives as certainty, as conquest, as unmistakable arrival. That you are supposed to know – immediately, definitively – and that hesitation is evidence of failure rather than the beginning of seriousness.

    But for many men, love does not arrive that way. It moves in like water into low places. No sound or warning. Just there when you look again.

    What comes first is often not joy, but responsibility. A low, steady awareness that something fragile has been placed in your care.

    Men rarely say this because the culture has taught them that fear is a disqualifying emotion. That if love is real, it should feel triumphant. But fear often comes first; not fear of the other person, but fear of losing her, fear of inadequacy, fear of discovering that you are not large enough to hold what is being asked of you.

    And sometimes fear is not the enemy of love, but its earliest signal.

    For many men, love begins not as certain, but with quiet instability. Men are taught to distrust that moment, to override it with decisiveness and to convert uncertainty into action. Many of these men stay with it, and so they choose before they understand. They commit without the reassurance of grandeur.

    This kind of love is deeply unromantic in its early stages. It looks like showing up without conviction and staying when it feels so much heavier than leaving. It looks like choosing the work…



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit gregscaduto.substack.com
    16 min
  • Venezuela part 2: The monsters we made

    “America goes not abroad, in search of monsters to destroy. She is the well-wisher to the freedom and independence of all. She is the champion and vindicator only of her own. She will commend the general cause by the countenance of her voice, and the benignant sympathy of her example.

    She knows that by once enlisting under other banners than her own, were they even the banners of foreign independence, she would involve herself, beyond the power of extrication, in all the wars of interest and intrigue, of individual avarice, envy, and ambition, which assume the colors and usurp the standards of freedom.

    The fundamental maxims of her policy would insensibly change from liberty to force.”

    ~John Quincy Adams, 1821

    In Part 1, I talked about how we’ve learned to flatten complexity into symbols we can hate at just a glance. What follows is the record of what a nation does when it governs by the same logic.

    Let’s start with 1954, Guatemala.

    The United States justified its intervention in Guatemala by claiming it was stopping communism from taking root in the Western Hemisphere. The Cold War was tightening. The Soviet Union was expanding its influence. We said we could not allow another foothold in the Americas.

    What Guatemala actually had was a democratically elected president, Árbenz, who proposed land reforms in a country where most farmland was owned by a tiny elite. One of the largest landholders was an American corporation, United Fruit. The reforms threatened corporate assets, and those assets were reframed as national security concerns.

    The CIA organized a coup. Árbenz fled. A military government took power.

    The United States said it had restored stability. What followed was forty years of civil war and mass killing, largely of Indigenous civilians. The country never recovered its democratic footing. The intervention achieved its short-term goal, but it destroyed the long-term one.

    1973, Chile.

    The U.S. justification for intervening in Chile was ideological containment. Salvador Allende was a socialist. He had been elected, but in our view, elections were not the issue. Alignment with the US was.

    The Nixon administration feared that a successful socialist democracy would inspire others in the region. That fear mattered more than Chile’s constitutional process. The U.S. applied economic pressure, supported internal destabilization, and made clear it would welcome military intervention.

    When the coup came, it was framed as an internal correction. The United States did not pull the trigger, but it approved the result.

    Pinochet’s dictatorship brought order. It also brought torture, disappearances, and fear. Chile eventually returned to democracy, but only after a generation paid the cost. The U.S. got a compliant ally. Chile lost tens of thousands of lives to state violence.

    1980s, Nicaragua.

    The U.S. justification in Nicaragua was straightforward: stop communism by any means necessary.

    The Sandinistas had overthrown a brutal dictator who had been backed by the United States. They promised reform, literacy, and land redistribution. We saw only alignment with Cuba and the Soviet bloc, which was intolerable.

    The U.S. funded and armed the Contras, a guerrilla force that attacked civilians, infrastructure, and local leaders. Congress tried to stop the funding. The administration continued anyway, secretly, illegally.

    The justification never changed. The threat was existential. The methods were regrettable but necessary.

    The result was a devastated country, tens of thousands dead, and a generation traumatized by war. The U.S. preserved ideological dominance. Nicaragua inherited instability that persists decades later.

    1989, Panama.

    In 1989, the United States invaded Panama to remove Manuel Noriega, a corrupt dictator and indicted drug trafficker, and in the narrowest sense the mission succeeded. Noriega was captured and tried in U.S. courts. But the cost was borne elsewhere.

    Several hundred Panamanian civilians were killed, entire neighborhoods were destroyed, and thousands were displaced, while drug trafficking routes quickly adapted, rerouted and continued. The deeper question is whether this made the US safer. It did not. Panama posed no strategic threat to American security, the drug trade was unaffected in any durable way, and the invasion lowered the threshold for using military force by recasting war as law enforcement.

    A criminal was removed, but at the price of civilian lives and a precedent that made intervention easier to justify the next time. That trade did not enhance American safety; it eroded the norms meant to preserve it.

    Now let’s talk about Venezuela from 2002 up until our recent intervention.

    The U.S. justification for its actions in Venezuela has been consistent: promote democracy, punish corruption, relieve suffering.

    In 2002, elements within Venezuela attempted to overthrow Hugo Chávez. The United States did not organize the coup, but it recognized the interim government immediately. When Chávez returned to power, Washington shifted tactics.

    Sanctions followed. Diplomatic isolation followed. Alternative leadership was recognized. Each step was justified as necessary pressure on an authoritarian regime.

    The stated goal was democratic transition. The effect was economic collapse, increased repression, and a population caught between an abusive state and a punishing external force.

    The U.S. said it was standing with the Venezuelan people but the Venezuelan people bore the consequences.

    If Panama showed how easily force could be justified procedurally, Venezuela shows how long pressure can be sustained bureaucratically, with suffering dispersed slowly enough to be ignored.

    So here’s the pattern.

    In each case, the American justification was internally consistent. It could be written down, explained, defended. Communism had to be stopped. Order had to be restored. Drugs had to be controlled. Democracy had to be promoted. The law had to be enforced.

    In each case, the intervention succeeded in addressing the problem it named and failed to reckon with the problems it produced. Immediate control was achieved at the expense of lasting legitimacy. Authority was asserted where consent was absent.

    Venezuela is not an exception to this history but just another example in a long chain of interventions that did nothing but inspire resentment.

    Over time, our behavior taught Latin America a particular way of reading us. Not as friends, exactly, and not always as enemies, but as something more tiring and harder to trust. Like a relative who shows up during crises with strong opinions, rearranges the furniture, explains why it had to be done, and then leaves before living with the consequences.

    Governments learned to nod politely while keeping one eye on the door. Ordinary people learned that American concern often arrived wrapped in the language of help but carried a hidden invoice payable in instability, suspicion, or violence. The result was not just resentment, though there was plenty of that, but a kind of learned guardedness: a sense that aligning too closely with Washington could be politically fatal, that reform movements might be dismissed as puppets, that democracy itself could be discredited simply by association.

    In this way, even well-intentioned American involvement began to function like static in the signal, distorting trust before a word was spoken. And so each new intervention now lands on a region already braced for disappointment, already fluent in the language of domination, already aware that whatever is promised in the name of order, they will be the ones left to sweep up afterward.

    And now I want to address the MAGA right in a way that is highly unusual for a center left liberal:

    I can already hear your response, and I want to say this carefully: I recognize the exhaustion. I recognize the feeling of being hectored by a cultural referee who seems more interested in tone and symbolic purity than actual outcome, and in reminding us, hourly, that America is uniquely awful and racist, when a brief glance at the rest of the human record suggests something closer to “deeply flawed but unusually self-correcting.” Ask Black Americans who have traveled abroad, really ask them, about Japan or Italy or Ireland or South Korea, and ask where they felt more at ease.

    So yes, I see the frustration. I feel it too. What I cannot understand is how that very real anger turns into historical and intellectual amnesia, waving off the Constitution, excusing people who smeared feces on marble walls in the Capitol while beating police officers, or develop a soft spot for strongmen who poison rivals, murder journalists and dream aloud about re-drawing borders. I watch people who call themselves conservatives sneer at NATO, the alliance that has kept Europe from repeatedly setting itself on fire for seventy-five years, flutter their eyelashes at Vladimir Putin like he’s some kind of clarity-dispensing life coach, and nod gravely at the idea of invading Greenland as if this is statesmanship rather than a boyish dare someone lost.

    I don’t hear conservatism in that. I hear a kind of selective memory, the political equivalent of walking into a room and forgetting why you came in there, except the room is history and the consequences are real. But I’d like to hear from you. But that requires you to be a man, and engage with the merits of my argument instead of saying things like “Greg, you sound like you jerk off in front of the mirror.”

    Which is very imaginative, Ralph. But the substance is lacking. And I’m not going to confirm or deny that accusation Ralph. But frankly it’s none of your business.

    What would be so much more productive is if you were man enough to get a beer with a guy who has served our country in uniform and tell me what is making you so unhappy. And you’d find that you like me. You might even become my friend. I have many friends who are Trump supporters. Because we’re not the thinkers of our thoughts. I didn’t choose to have the mental and emotional wiring and nervous system I have that gave me the beliefs I have any more than you did. We’re just two people trying to feel ok in this world. So why can’t I be decent to you?

    And the world does not need more clever cynics. One more guy who imagines all his comments are mic drops. We need more love. More curiosity. More mercy, and forgiveness. We need to recognize the humanity in one another. And realize that at the root of our character flaws as adults are moments in our childhood when you felt unloved. There is a scared child…in all of us.

    That’s it for now.



    Get full access to Broken but Readable at gregscaduto.substack.com/subscribe
    11 min
  • Venezuela Part 1: How we lost each other

    I look around me most days - at my relatives, at my phone, at the television murmuring to itself in the background - and what I notice is not malice so much as confusion. A kind of ambient bewilderment. Capitalism, in its infinite cleverness, has built us these beautifully personalized reality tunnels that feel flattering and familiar, like a room where the lighting is always just right for your face. Inside them, we are shown the world not as it is, but as we are most likely to nod along to it. And over time, this has left people not energized or informed, but quietly sad, betrayed, and oddly angry without being entirely sure why.

    Most people now encounter ideas the way they encounter ads. Passively. Through a feed. Through a voice that sounds confident enough to be mistaken for wisdom. They weigh information not with their conscience, or their lived sense of right and wrong, but with the vague feeling of whether it agrees with the version of themselves the algorithm has been nurturing.

    So someone like Joe Rogan will say something about how Democrats would have won Michigan if they weren’t obsessed with trans bathrooms and insisting gender was a social construct. And a guy who looks like me hears this and feels a real tightening in his chest. A resentment. Not because he has ever actually met a trans person and been wronged by her, but because the story he’s been handed gives his frustration somewhere convenient to land.

    But what he doesn’t do is sit across from one. He doesn’t look her in the eye, introduce himself, and ask her what she’s carried.

    If he did, she might tell him that for most of her life she walked around with a generalized self-hatred she could never quite explain. That she drank too much. That she tried to outwork it, out-joke it, out-discipline it. And that one day, in her forties, sober for the first time in a long while, she realized the thing she had been fighting wasn’t weakness or indulgence or ideology. It was the daily strain of living in a body that felt like a stranger. So she did the thing that finally made her feel okay in the world.

    She might say, calmly, “SOME people might be asking for special treatment. But I’m certainly not. All I’m asking for is the basic right of human acceptance.”

    And you think: she’s not trying to convert anyone. She’s not asking to be celebrated. She just wants the medical care that doesn’t make her feel sick or alien in her own skin. She wants to work, to love, to find some ordinary happiness. She wants to walk through a revolving door without the person behind her muttering “Jesus Christ,” as though her existence were a personal inconvenience.

    Meanwhile, on the other end of the spectrum, you have liberals who sincerely believe that Trump supporters are all bad people. That half the country is irredeemable. A write-off.

    But there was this one time I got a flat tire late at night. I pulled over to the side of the road, hazards on. A truck slowed and stopped behind me. Being from New Jersey, my first instinct was to prepare for a confrontation. I rehearsed a couple of lines in my head, just in case. Something defensive.

    Then I remembered I was in Texas.

    The driver got out. A country guy. Ball cap. Boots. He looked at me like someone who had found a neighbor in mild trouble, which is exactly what he had done. He asked, in a thick, unhurried accent, if I needed a hand. No suspicion. No lecture. Just help.

    He pulled a better tire iron than I had out of his truck as I cranked the jack. We changed the tire. He waved. Drove off. A Trump bumper sticker bobbed gently on the back of his truck as he disappeared down the road.

    I do not recall this happening to me in New York.

    And this is what gets lost when we live entirely behind avatars and pseudonyms, inside apps that reward cruelty with attention. We forget that understanding something - really understanding it - requires more than being right. It requires synthesis. Context. Empathy. The willingness to be unsettled by another person’s interior life.

    We are bound together whether we like it or not. Most people are not villains. They are products of a long, winding river of causes - family, geography, fear, love, habit, trauma - over which they had very little control. That doesn’t make every belief correct. But it does make every person worthy of compassion.

    We are all, in the end, made of the same stuff. Carried by the same current. Trying, clumsily, to feel okay in this world.

    But we live now inside a constant fog of opinion, produced not by argument or evidence but by repetition. Our information no longer arrives because it is important, but because it is likely to be consumed. What we see is selected for familiarity, emotional response, and compliance, with no regard for how the world really is, or the humanity layered beneath the symbols we come to despise.

    It leaves people anxious, reactive, and eager for explanations that restore a sense of order. Governments are not immune to this atmosphere. They are human beings, just like us. When a public is conditioned to think decisiveness is the same thing as courage, foreign policy follows the same logic. Whole countries - dense with history, contradiction, family memory, petty bureaucracy, jokes, rivalries, bad roads, broken elevators, stubborn rituals, and ordinary private lives that have nothing to do with us - are flattened into cartoons we can recognize at a glance.

    Venezuela becomes not a place where people wake up late, argue with siblings, stand in line, fall in love, and make compromises they hate... it collapses into a single word, a single problem, a single test of resolve. Once a nation learns to see the world this way, intervention appears as a reflex, justified in advance by the language used to describe it. What follows is not a story about Venezuela alone, but about how power, fed by distortion and certainty, repeats itself while insisting each time that it has never done this before.

    And before we quickly run through it, I’ll just say that for all the talk of “no US casualties” in the Venezuela op, does anybody listening know whether any Venezuelan civilians were killed? How many? Maybe we’ll come back to that. Just wondering if anyone is aware.

    Regarding our involvement in Venezuela, it is just another link in a long chain. The United States today repeatedly treats other societies as instruments for managing its own anxieties.

    Yet the founding fathers said this:

    “The great rule of conduct for us, in regard to foreign nations, is in extending our commercial relations, to have with them as little political connection as possible.”

    ~George Washington

    “Peace, commerce, and honest friendship with all nations - entangling alliances with none.”

    ~Thomas Jefferson

    “War is the parent of armies; from these proceed debts and taxes... known instruments for bringing the many under the domination of the few.”

    ~James Madison

    “Nations go to war not because they must, but because power seeks justification.”

    ~Alexander Hamilton

    We know what they all said.

    But MAGA, you’re touting this as a foreign policy victory.

    And you are lost. You’re not evil. You are lost.

    The founders did not arrive at such caution through theory alone. They learned it the hard way. They had seen war up close, not as abstraction but as hunger, debt, disorder, and the quiet unraveling of civic life. They knew that war does not simply end when the fighting stops. It lingers... in institutions, in habits of power, in the willingness of a government to do tomorrow whatever it justified doing yesterday.

    They understood something we often forget: that unnecessary war is not just violence abroad, but corrosion at home. It centralizes authority, dulls moral judgment, and teaches a nation to explain away what it once would have forbidden. This is why George Washington warned against entanglement, why Jefferson spoke of restraint, why Madison feared war as the enemy of liberty. They were not idealists, but veterans of chaos who knew that force, once normalized, rarely stays where it is aimed.

    They avoided unnecessary war not because they were weak, but because they had earned wisdom through blood and trauma. They had already learned how easily power convinces itself it’s afraid - and how eagerly fear asks to be armed.

    Yet Americans today like to believe that when we intervene in other countries, it is always for the first time. This one is different, we say. This one is urgent. This one is regrettable but necessary. We line these moments up like snow globes on a shelf, each sealed, each shaken once, each containing its own tiny moral weather system. If anything goes wrong inside one of them, we can always say it was unforeseeable, or tragic, or complicated. What we resist, almost instinctively, is the idea that these are not separate stories at all, but chapters in the same book. Latin America keeps trying to hand us that book. We keep setting it down, unopened, insisting we already know how the story ends.

    In Part 2, we’ll walk through the history of US interventions in Latin America in the 20th century. And maybe there’s something we can learn from those.

    END OF PART 1



    Get full access to Broken but Readable at gregscaduto.substack.com/subscribe
    11 min
  • The exile of a female astronomer (in the name of protecting women)

    Here is the link to Dr. Beatriz Villarroel’s piece in the Liberation Times, mentioned in the beginning of the episode.

    Podcast transcript:

    So I’ll just say straight off that the reason any of this matters is that, years before we put anything into orbit, something reflective and physical was already up there – appearing briefly, then vanishing.

    But there’s a lot to this story so let’s back up.

    Yesterday, an article was published in an outlet you’ve probably never read or heard of, written by an astronomer you’ve probably never read or heard of. This is not a criticism. It’s just how attention works now. Important things tend to arrive quietly, like a neighbor knocking to tell you your headlights are on.

    The outlet was Liberation Times, edited by Chris Sharp. He tends to publish careful, unnervingly sober reporting about subjects most institutions would prefer to keep at arm’s length, which is why so few people are aware of his existence. I’ll link the piece in the description.

    The astronomer was Beatriz Villarroel. Dr. Villarroel is an assistant professor at the Nordic Institute for Theoretical Physics – an establishment devoted not to the manufacture of fashionable certainties, but to the patient, often uncomfortable business of thinking at the outer edges of what is known. NORDITA exists precisely to ask questions that do not yet have agreeable answers, and to do so with mathematical rigor rather than ideological reassurance. To work there is not a credential one acquires by accident, nor one retained by indulging in intellectual frivolity.

    She holds a PhD in astronomy.

    She leads long-running projects that search historical sky surveys for anomalies most astronomers never think to question.

    And before we talk about what she found in the sky, we need to talk about what happened to her on Earth.

    Before the Science, the Treatment

    In 2023, Beatriz Villarroel published a guest essay on Critical Mass, edited by Lawrence Krauss. It was not polemical. It was not angry. It was restrained in that very Scandinavian way where the sentences line up politely, remove their shoes at the door, and then proceed to describe something genuinely harrowing without ever raising their voices.

    She wrote not to litigate her science, but to document what had happened to her professionally over the previous two years. Not because of misconduct. Not because of fraud. Not because of bad science. But because of who she chose to work with.

    She described how, after deciding to collaborate with exoplanet pioneer Geoff Marcy, she became the target of sustained harassment and discrimination within the international astronomy community. Marcy had been accused of sexual harassment in 2015, subjected to public shaming, and forced into retirement from UC Berkeley after an internal investigation. There were no criminal charges. No court proceedings. No legal adjudication. And no pathway for rehabilitation.

    Villarroel notes this with particular care, because she herself had experienced retaliation earlier in her academic life after rejecting quid pro quo advances from a superior as an undergraduate – an experience that helped drive her out of her original field and into astronomy. She understood, firsthand, the gravity of such allegations. Years later, she got to know Marcy personally and chose to work with him on scientific grounds.

    She writes, plainly and without flourish, that she believes certain principles should not be controversial: that human beings have a right to dignity; that punishment without due process is not justice; that lifelong exile imposed by the court of public opinion is not morality. Even guilt, she argues, does not erase the right to rehabilitation. Without these principles, she suggests, human community becomes something smaller and crueler.

    With that understanding, she joined the international VASCO collaboration, which searches for vanishing stars and anomalous transients using historical astronomical data, including pre-Sputnik images. The work includes a large citizen-science component and has expanded toward real-time detection using modern instruments. It is careful, technical, and openly exploratory. She describes Marcy as an inspiring and valued collaborator.

    As a direct consequence of that collaboration, a SETI conference (which stands for search for extraterrestrial intelligence) at a public institution in the United States barred Villarroel from presenting results of her own research. The exclusion was not framed as punishment. It was executed through a newly crafted Code of Conduct provision, written broadly enough to sound principled and narrowly enough to apply only to her. The letter informing her of the decision cited Marcy by name and instructed her to withdraw her presentation.

    The same institution later held another conference and kept the very same Code of Conduct provision in place – the one that had already been used to exclude her – making clear that this was not an isolated decision but an ongoing policy for them.

    When Villarroel published a first-author paper in Scientific Reports in 2021 with Marcy as a co-author, screenshots of her name circulated on social media alongside accusations that said things like “Yes, women participate in rape culture”, because of her collaboration with Marcy. Other scientists publicly urged that the paper not be cited or promoted. A prominent astronomy promotion platform announced that it would not promote the paper at all, nor another exoplanet paper by a California team with Marcy as a co-author, citing opposition to sexual harassment – without reference to the content of either paper.

    A senior academic editor excluded Villarroel’s first-author paper from a scientific newsletter, asserting that she could not plausibly have been the intellectual driver of her own work. He claimed to recognize her co-author’s “style” and refused to promote the paper on that basis.

    * After Villarroel organized a successful academic meeting and invited the same collaborator to participate, she was subjected to direct, threat-like communications and severe public allegations. The sustained pressure culminated in a medical emergency, and she was admitted to the emergency room weeks later.

    * As her postdoctoral funding neared its end, a SETI-affiliated institute informed her that she would be barred from applying for grants or publishing papers unless her research team excluded that collaborator. She withdrew her application.

    * Another SETI-friendly conference invited her, then ceased all communication without explanation and failed to confirm her registration.

    * During this period, Villarroel observed social-media calls for “academic death kisses” for all collaborators of the same individual, including explicit instructions for how such punishment should be carried out.

    * The pattern extended beyond her case. A former graduate student – now an assistant professor – was pressured to remove the collaborator’s name from a paper despite his substantial contributions, following sustained online harassment and intimidation directed at her and her tenure prospects. Several senior academics participated in the campaign, including individuals previously involved in actions against Villarroel.

    * A subsequent article in Science praised this outcome, without acknowledging that denying proper authorship credit constitutes academic misconduct and violates editorial standards.

    * Villarroel submitted formal complaints to professional organizations, including the American Astronomical Society. She was later informed that the cases were considered closed. No corrective action was taken, and the harassment continued.

    * All of this occurred before the publication of the transients paper.

    So this was not punishment for startling conclusions. It was preemptive discipline – a message delivered quietly and repeatedly. You may work. But not with everyone. Not on everything. Not without permission.

    There’s this one quote from Orwell, when he said that power does not need to announce itself. It mer…



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit gregscaduto.substack.com
    17 min
  • What's going on with this whole Greenland thing?

    In this episode, I try to do the calm, slightly sheepish thing that feels increasingly rare, which is to pause for a moment and ask what’s actually happening before deciding what to feel about it. Using a small, unpretentious framework meant mainly to preserve my blood pressure, I walk through the recent Greenland episode, looking past the surface noise to the strategic realities underneath, and then to the deeper shift in how power is being described, claimed, and justified. Along the way, we talk about alliances, trust, and the quiet damage done when long-term relationships are treated like short-term leverage. It’s an effort to slow the moment down, to separate confidence from wisdom, and to ask whether the future being outlined in careful language and glowing maps is one we would still choose if we were thinking past the end of the week.

    FULL TRANSCRIPT (since Peter asked for it): Before we begin, I should probably admit that this is not my first time trying to understand a Trump foreign policy decision by staring at it for a while, tilting my head, and thinking, Well. That can’t possibly be the whole story.

    Because experience suggests it never is.

    So, over time, I’ve developed a little framework. Not because I enjoy frameworks. I do not. I would rather be petting a dog. But because with an administration this casually dishonest, a framework is sometimes the only thing standing between you and a full day of yelling at your phone.

    The framework is very simple.

    First: what is actually going on.Not what was said. Not how it was framed. But the underlying situation that existed before the announcement, back when people were still using full sentences and inside voices.

    Second: what is the Trump public-facing narrative.Which is usually streamlined, emotionally satisfying, and engineered to make you feel like something decisive is happening, even if the details remain politely offstage.

    Third: what are they really saying behind closed doors.Meaning the conversations where no one is performing. Where the maps come out. Where the tone changes. Where the jokes stop being funny.

    And finally: what does it all mean.Not just for this particular headline, but for how we now operate as a country. How we talk about power. How we treat allies. How comfortable we’ve become with the gap between reality and its press release.

    This is not a clever framework. It is more like a flashlight you keep by the bed. Not elegant, but useful when the lights go out.

    And with that in mind, it’s probably time to talk about Greenland.

    Because one morning we wake up and discover that the United States of America is, apparently, interested in buying it.

    Buying it.

    Which is odd, because most of us last encountered Greenland in roughly seventh grade, as a large white shape on a classroom map that our teacher assured us was “very cold” and “not actually that big in real life,” and then we all moved on to learning about Peru or mitochondria or whatever.

    Greenland, as a concept, has mostly existed for us as a kind of honorable blank space. A place where the rules of our normal thinking don’t fully apply. Ice. Silence. A few brave people. Dogs that look like they could survive a nuclear winter. End of list.

    And then suddenly it’s on the news. The President is talking about it. People are asking, with varying levels of sincerity, whether it’s legal to buy a country.

    You can almost feel the collective American brain doing that thing it does when it hasn’t quite caught up yet. Like when your phone autocorrects a word into something insane and you stare at it for a second thinking, No. That can’t be right.

    But here’s where the laughter starts to thin out.

    Because under the joke is a seriousness that refuses to go away.

    It turns out Greenland is not just a big white shrug on a map. It’s a place with radar systems and shipping lanes and rare earth minerals. It’s a place where the ice is melting, which means the future is showing up early, like an uninvited guest who knows too much about you.

    And at some point, usually mid-chuckle, you realize:

    Oh.

    This isn’t random.

    The joke arrived first. The strategy arrived quietly. And now they’re sitting together at the same table, smiling at us.

    Which is where the tone has to change.

    Let us be precise.

    The United States did not suddenly “discover” Greenland because of curiosity or whim. It did so because power, when it shifts, reveals what was always important and merely ignored.

    Greenland occupies a strategic position in the Arctic that no serious military planner disputes. It sits beneath missile trajectories, astride submarine routes, adjacent to newly opening shipping corridors, and atop resources that modern economies require.

    Russia understands this. China understands this. The United States understands this.

    What changed was not the assessment, but the language.

    Under the Trump administration, strategic necessity was translated into the vocabulary of ownership. Security became acquisition. Partnership became leverage. Geography became property.

    This is not a small rhetorical shift. Language is policy rehearsing itself.

    When a nation begins to speak of allies as assets, and treats territory as merchandise, it is preparing its citizens for a world in which consent matters less than control and power dynamics.

    The outward narrative from Trump was blunt and unmoored by ethical principle, as it often is.

    Greenland matters. Denmark is weak. America should act.

    What was omitted was the cost.

    Because empires do not collapse when they lose strength but when they lose credibility.

    Power exercised without legitimacy invites resistance. And strength expressed without restraint provokes coalitions against it.

    History is unambiguous on this point.

    The danger is not that Greenland is important. The danger is that we are relearning the language of dominance and mistaking it for clarity.

    And that brings us to what unsettles me most about this episode.

    Not the proposal itself, but what it reveals about how we are learning to speak about the world again.

    There is a loneliness in transactional thinking. A belief that everything must justify itself immediately, or be taken, or be discarded. It leaves no room for patience. No room for shared stewardship. No room for the quiet dignity of mutual dependence.

    Greenland is not empty. It is not silent. It is home.

    And Denmark, for all its imperfections, is not irrelevant. It is part of a web of trust that has, for decades, allowed American power to feel less like force and more like leadership.

    When we erode that web, we do not become freer but more exposed.

    Alliances are not treaties alone; they are habits of trust built slowly through restraint, memory, and the unglamorous discipline of keeping one’s word when no one is watching. After the Second World War, American power endured not because it was unmatched, but because it was embedded in relationships that made smaller nations feel protected rather than consumed. When that trust frays, it does not announce its departure. It lingers, then withdraws quietly, leaving behind cooperation that looks intact but no longer holds under strain. History shows that credibility, once lost, is not reclaimed through force or transaction, but only through time, humility, and acts that cannot be priced.

    Behind closed doors, the conversations are likely sober. Analysts discussing missile arcs. Admirals pointing to maps. Intelligence officers worrying about Chinese investments that arrive smiling and leave permanent footprints.

    Those concerns are real and deserve seriousness.

    But seriousness does not require cruelty, and strength does not require humiliation.

    A nation is judged not only by what it defends, but by how it defends it. By whether it can hold competing truths at once: that the world is dangerous, and that domination is not the same thing as security.

    If we teach ourselves that everything valuable must be owned in order to be protected, we will eventually find ourselves very rich, very powerful, and very alone. This is true also…



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit gregscaduto.substack.com
    10 min
  • Why college football is ruining higher education

    Picture this: It’s Christmas Eve in our new house, candles flickering like they mean business, everybody smiling the way people smile when they’re trying not to notice the slight smell of something burning in the kitchen, and suddenly I’m standing there, mid-shrimp-cocktail, explaining to a room full of nice, normal people why the American university has become this sad fluorescent terrarium where the lecturers, good, earnest lecturers, the ones who still believe in ideas, pace back and forth like zoo animals who’ve forgotten how to roar.



    Get full access to Broken but Readable at gregscaduto.substack.com/subscribe
    14 min
  • Helicopters, flashbangs, zip-tied kids: the true cost of "law and order"

    This episode is me, 13 days off cigarettes, trying to make sense of the raids that have turned neighborhoods into places where dawn knocks feel like threats. It starts with the facts: Renee Good shot dead by an ICE agent in Minneapolis last week, families zip-tied after helicopters dropped agents on a Chicago apartment building, a farmworker falling to his death fleeing a raid in California -- and the numbers showing most people detained have no criminal record.

    From there it moves through the economic hit, the constitutional cracks, the quiet damage done to communities, and the moral question John Rawls would ask: would you build this system if you didn’t already know you’d be on the safe side of the door? It’s not polished or balanced; it’s just what happens when you quit one bad habit and pick up another -- talking too much about what we’re doing to people who pick our food and clean our floors, and wondering out loud if we’re still the country we tell ourselves we are.



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit gregscaduto.substack.com
    25 min
  • A journal entry from a Mars rover

    This is something I wrote years ago but never shared with anyone. It's a journal entry from the Mars rover called Curiosity. Not really, but use your imagination.



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit gregscaduto.substack.com
    12 min

About Broken but Readable

From the publisher's feed

This is a podcast with short episodes for people who feel vaguely insane watching the news but still believe moral seriousness is possible.